Point at a sentence to see when it was said, and click the time to listen from there.Tap a sentence to see when it was said, and tap the time to listen from there.

Introducing the Bund

Sam Adler-Bell

Welcome listeners to episode 133 of Know Your Enemy. I'm Sam Adler-Bell, one of your podcast co-hosts, and I'm here by myself because my great friend Matt Sitman is having dental work done this week, which makes it very difficult to podcast. I'm a little anxious about doing this introduction because Matt says that when I do the introductions by myself, I always sound really weird and awkward and not at all how I normally sound on the podcast. Listeners, you can be the judge of this. And in fact, I would appreciate it even if I do sound weird if you tell Matt that I sound fine and normal and it's not a big deal so that this is not a problem for me in the future. I have a great episode for you today, dear listeners. I was joined today by the artist and author and activist Molly Crabapple, who most recently is the author of Here Where We Live Is Our Country, the story of the Jewish Bund. This is a book that I was looking forward to for actually several years. It's now out. You can buy it from One World Books. Of course, there'll be links to buy it in the show notes. But for those listeners who aren't familiar with it, The Bund was a Jewish revolutionary party that was founded in 1897 in the Tsarist Empire.

It was secular, socialist, proudly Jewish, and uncompromisingly anti-Zionist. It was founded by young Jewish Marxists who had the twin goals of overthrowing the Tsar and creating democratic socialism in Russia. There is so much in this book that is relevant to our political present. I think it especially spoke to me as a Jewish anti-Zionist and a socialist. And I suspect those of you listeners who share those identities will also find this conversation extremely inspiring. But it's also a really fascinating account of the 20th century and its biggest upheavals, including the two Russian revolutions, obviously World War II and the Holocaust and the founding of the state of Israel. I say to Molly in this conversation, a lot of positive things about this book, but I really can't recommend it enough. I really found it extremely useful and comforting to look back at a version of 20th century Jewish history that does not foreground Zionism and ethno-nationalism in Palestine as... A foregone conclusion. That's what the Bund envisioned. Obviously, it came to a rather tragic end, which is something we discuss in great detail in this conversation.

I feel like I am sounding weird, but again, don't tell Matt. As always, we're grateful to our partners at Dissent. One thing that they do for us is that if you subscribe to Know Your Enemy at our Patreon, which is www.patreon.com slash Know Your Enemy for $10 a month, you'll get all of our bonus episodes and a free digital. subscription to Dissent Magazine. And as always, if you subscribe on Patreon for $5 a month, you get access to our rich backlog of paywalled episodes. The most recent one was a conversation Matt and I had about misogyny and the right and a piece of writing that I did for New York Magazine about women MAGA influencers who've gotten fed up with misogyny on their own side. So if you're interested in that conversation, sign up and give it a listen. There is one more thing I have to Pedal here. On Thursday, May 14th, Matt and I and Mike Duncan, the inimitable host of the Revolutions podcast, will be recording a live podcast at the Society for Ethical Culture in New York City. The event is at 7 p.m. The topic is Decline and Fall, a conversation about right-wing narratives and rhetoric around decline, lost greatness, and everything in between.

It's a fundraiser for Dissent Magazine. So we would be delighted if you would buy tickets from the link in the show notes, and we will love to see you there and meet you and talk about whatever you want to talk about. Matt and myself and Mike Duncan, it's a match made in heaven. So if you live in New York and you can make it on Thursday, May 14th, please come by. I happen to know that our intrepid producer, Jesse Brandeman, will also be in attendance and be hanging out. at this event. So if you've been desperate to meet really the brains behind this operation, Jesse will also be in New York on May 14th. Please buy tickets. We will probably keep bothering you about this for the next few weeks. Speaking of Jesse, we of course want to thank him for editing this episode. And we want to thank Will Epstein, who does the music for the show. With that all, hopefully not terribly awkwardly said, please enjoy this interview I did with Molly Crabapple. who is the author of Here Where We Live Is Our Country, The Story of the Jewish Bund. Enjoy.

Okay, Molly Crabapple, welcome to Know Your Enemy.

Molly Crabapple

I'm so happy to be here, Sam.

Sam Adler-Bell

I'm so psyched too. As you know... Already, I've told you many times, I really love this book.

A book seven years in the making

Sam Adler-Bell

It's called Here Where We Live Is Our Country, The Story of the Jewish Bund. And it's coming out Tuesday, April 7th. So probably a few days ago when this comes out. When listeners are hearing this, there will also be a profile that I wrote of you in The Guardian US out. So we're pushing Crabapple. on all the platforms right now.

Molly Crabapple

Thank you.

Sam Adler-Bell

But I'm not kidding, and I'm not just blowing smoke up your ass. It's incredible how timely this book is, which you can't have completely designed, because as I know from talking to you in the past, you've worked on this book for what, seven years?

Molly Crabapple

Seven years.

Sam Adler-Bell

And it just so happens that as it comes out, its content couldn't really be any more relevant to international affairs, in particular, kind of the internal conflicts in Jewish life, especially This question for leftist Jews of how to relate to Jewishness and socialism and Zionism. The story of the Bund provides just kind of unbelievable resources for people like me, frankly. It's just really inspiring, but also challenging. You just got an incredible review in the New York Times today.

Molly Crabapple

Yeah, I almost couldn't believe it. And it's causing the very worst Zionists on Twitter to fill their diapers with just... torrents of rage and anger. They are so angry about it.

Sam Adler-Bell

That's got to be...

Molly Crabapple

Sweet.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah. It can't be the most important thing about this book coming out, but it's something I'm enjoying already. And the book's not even in stores yet. But I did like from the review, the New York Times review by Max Strasser, in describing the kind of feel, the style of the book, he said, picture Warren Beatty's Reds, but with a script from Isaac Bashevis Singer. I mean, I think that's an accurate description of the book. It's so thrilling to read. It moves along. It's got the bite of the, you know, Isaac Singer short story, and it's got the kind of sincere revolutionary politics of Reds.

Molly Crabapple

Thank you. There's this way that academic historians write where they don't want to draw parallels to the present. There's like a very constrained prose style. And because I'm not an academic, because I literally went to the Fashion Institute of Technology and And Dropped out of that and got my start drawing in nightclubs and have spent, fuck, two decades now involved in leftist protests. And because I'm an artist and a journalist by training, I had a very different sensibility when I came to it. I wanted to write the book in a way that made revolutionary politics feel alive and vivid and that made the revolutionaries feel like people the readers might know.

Sam Adler-Bell

I love that about the book. You totally succeeded in that. It doesn't read like a normal history book. even a normal popular history book. It's just much more emotionally resonant and personal, but not in a way that distracts at all from the real deep historical digging you did to put this together. It's just great. But I do think we should not get too far ahead of ourselves. For listeners who are not leftist anti-Zionist Jews necessarily, who therefore don't necessarily know what the Jewish labor Bund is or what the Bund was, could you tell us what is the Bund? What was it? When was it founded and why?

Three oppressions

Molly Crabapple

The Bund was an organization founded in the Tsarist Empire in 1897 by young Jewish Marxist troublemakers. And the Bund was founded because to be a Jew in the Tsarist Empire meant to be a Jew in the worst place to be Jewish on earth at that time. You were essentially suffering from three oppressions. You had this Tsarist autocracy that oppressed absolutely everyone inside their empire. This was... a government that would send you to jail for having a book club. This was a government that during a famine where hundreds of thousands, up to a million people are starving to death, the rulers are wasting money on diamond eggs that opened up into other diamond eggs. This is a government that has been doing cousin marriage so long that the last czar's son had blood that no longer clotted. This is the sort of government you're living under. Extreme um oppression, extreme stupidity, extreme autocracy. You're also living in an empire that's very poor. You do not have the minimal standards of employment law or of wages that you would have as a worker in Western Europe. A worker in the Tsarist empire was far poorer.

But then the third thing is that you also were a member of a racialized minority. The Tsarist Empire, from the moment that it... acquired a substantial Jewish population by invading Poland was structurally anti-Semitic. Jews were confined to living in the swath of Western provinces called the Pale of settlement. You couldn't live in St. Petersburg, the capital, or in Moscow. There were strict quotas to limit how many Jews were in universities. There was at one point a military conscription term that lasted 25 years, not five years like it was for... Christian subjects. You couldn't live in the countryside. You couldn't work certain types of jobs. You couldn't move where you wanted to. You had this suffocating straitjacket of legal restrictions. And as is always the case when a government decides to target a minority, this leads to a floating miasma of unofficial bigotry and violence that was most famously exemplified in a Russian word that Americans know, which is pogrom. These young Jewish Marxist troublemakers looked at the world around them, and they came to a conclusion that will seem startlingly contemporary.

They realized that in the Tsarist empire, the Jewish worker was oppressed both because he was a worker and because he was a Jew. He was oppressed for his race and for his class. They basically prefigured intersectionality. And because of that, they decided that the Jewish worker needed an autonomous organization that would both fight to overthrow the Tsar and bring democratic socialism to Russia, but also that would fight for the liberation and flourishing and dignity of Jewish people and their right to live in Eastern Europe, where they had lived a thousand years. They weren't separatists. They wanted to fight for what they called the better and more beautiful world alongside other people, whether they were Armenians or Polish or Georgian. or Russian or Lithuanian, but they also thought that they needed their own autonomous organization.

Sam Adler-Bell

And so to give listeners just the beginnings of this story, could you describe kind of in maybe the first decade of the Bund's existence, what were they doing? What kinds of work were they doing?

From reading circles to a mass party

Sam Adler-Bell

Who were they organizing? I mean, I think there's all kinds of ways in which the history of the Bund has been forgotten. Your book is going to change that. But one thing people don't know about the first decade of its existence is just how crucial. their organizing was to the building of socialism and socialist revolution in Russia, just how important they were to the building of the party that eventually became the Communist Party in Russia. So tell us a little bit about what the Bund was up to in its first decade.

Molly Crabapple

So in the Russian Empire, revolutionaries in, let's say, 1890, thought that the Russian workers were way too backwards to do a revolution. And that what you needed to do if you wanted to you overthrow the czar and create democratic socialism is you needed to set up reading groups. You need to set up a lot of reading groups and you needed to take these workers who in the case of Jewish workers, didn't speak Russian, but Yiddish, teach these workers how to speak Russian and maybe German, have them read Marx. And then eventually enough workers would learn enough Russian that they'd all read Marx and then dot, dot, dot revolution, right? That's how this sort of proto-Bund starts. It starts with these reading groups. But the problem is that the young radicals quickly realized that the workers that they're teaching Russian to read Marx are not actually using this to start the revolution. They're just becoming like hipsters about it and lugging around Russian books they can barely read and maybe trying to take a college entrance exam. And that if they want to actually have a revolution, what they need to do is they stop trying to top down, tell the workers what to think and start listening to them. And so they throw themselves into a trade union movement that workers have already been organizing.

And they use their international connections and legal know-how in order to actually improve workers' lives. And this is the philosophy, the ethos that they are imbued with when the small group of troublemakers meets in the attic. of a rickety safe house in Vilna and forms what's called the Jewish Labor Bund. Bund means organization or union. And soon after they form the Bund, three Bundists will become three of the 11 founding members of another group. And that group is called the Russian Social Democratic and Labor Party. And after a series of staggering ups and downs and betrayals and a world war, this party will eventually become, doom, doom, doom, the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah. I mean, one of the things that I was really struck by in the early period of that proto-Communist Party history is just that the Bund's contribution in terms of membership was huge. It was most of the members, right, at the beginning?

Molly Crabapple

Right. You have the situation where the Russian Social and Democratic Labor Party, year 1903, has 5,000 members. And the vast majority of its energy is spent not inside Russia, but inside this constellation of colonies of exiled revolutionaries in Western Europe. I call it exile land. The majority of what the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party is doing at the turn of the century is printing up newspapers in exile land, which they use to get into arguments with other newspapers that they're printing up. I don't know. It was funny. When I was reading about them, I was thinking about all of these dysfunctional behaviors by communist sects in New York now, where you have like 12 of the most disagreeable men in the world who are spending all of their time trying to sell newspapers. And I was like, why are they doing this? And then I'm like, oh, my God, that is what the Russian Social Democratic Party did. It was a small group of the most disagreeable people in the world selling newspapers. But at the same time as the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party is... invested in theoretical disputes and exile land fighting, the Bund is growing into a mass party. It has 30,000 members by 1903. And these members are not just printing newspapers and getting into arguments in Switzerland.

These members are arming up to fight pogroms and defend their communities. They are creating underground libraries, even underground schools and educational systems. They are creating newspapers. that don't just have political work, but also are elevating and championing the Yiddish language. The Bundists are building vast international networks of fundraising with Jewish sweatshop workers in New York and all over the world. They're controlling the smuggling routes into and out of the Tsarist empire. So even non-Jewish revolutionaries are relying on them to smuggle in papers, weapons, and people. The Bund is incredibly powerful. And a lot of that is because unlike the other parts of the Russian Social Democratic and Labor Party, they are very much an organization of the people. There's this word that I really love, which is tuer. It means doer in Yiddish. And the Bundists were tuers par excellence. I wouldn't say that they were like the greatest theoreticians in the world, but they were people who built and maintained community and we're deeply, deeply rooted. in the daily life of the working class. And they were devoted to elevating, dignifying that life and making these working class people into everyday revolutionaries.

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, we're going to have a lot more to say about Zionism in this conversation.

Bundism and Zionism, born in 1897

Sam Adler-Bell

But a fascinating part of this story is that Bundism and Zionism officially come into existence in the same year, in 1897, right? Could you tell us a little bit about how the Bundists related to Zionism, which was, you know... this other answer to the question of what to do about Jewish oppression at the turn of the century.

Molly Crabapple

Bund came to existence actually within weeks of the birth of political Zionism, maybe a little over a month between our intrepid Bundists meeting in the rickety safe house attic and Theodor Herzl prancing onto the stage at the Ritzy Basel Casino and launching the Zionist Congress. And they hated each other from the start, just mutual, mutual hatred. In 1903, you have Chaim Weizmann, who will eventually become the first president of Israel, saying, our hardest struggle everywhere is conducted against the Jewish labor Bund. While the same year, the Bund is describing Zionism as the most evil enemy of the organized Jewish proletariat.

Sam Adler-Bell

No love lost.

Molly Crabapple

No, no. Bundists banned Zionists from membership since 1901. And why did the Bund not just, you know, reject Zionism, but hate it? Well, there are a few reasons. The first was that they just thought it was really stupid. The idea, if you think about it, that millions upon millions of Jews would leave their homes of a thousand years to become collective farmers in the Levant, it's not a very realistic sounding idea, right? And so when the Bund first hears this, they're like, This is not legit. This is a scam by the Jewish bosses to justify why they're not paying their Jewish workers enough to live. It's a classic scam the capitalists do, right? They give a little money to a philanthropy and then they pay you so much that you need three other jobs to survive.

Sam Adler-Bell

It's like your boss comes onto the factory floor and says, well, I've just given money to start a yeshiva in the land of Israel. You should be so happy because you're Jews and we're all on the same side. We're in this together. but also you're going to keep getting poverty wages and working after the Sabbath and all that stuff.

Molly Crabapple

Yeah, exactly. Be so happy that I endowed a yeshiva that you don't care that you're working 16 hours a day. That was one reason. But the second thing, this was a more moral thing, and this is the reason that will be sort of a motif as Zionism becomes a more doable plan, is that they felt like Zionism was capitulation to the same bigots. that wanted to kick Jews out of their home. At this time, you have these ethno-nationalist movements in Eastern Europe that view Jews as these swarthy, satanic others who should dick off to Palestine. These movements that deeply wanted to ethnically cleanse Jews from Poland, from the Russian empire, that viewed them as subhuman, that viewed them as a plague and wanted them to get out. And then you had Zionism saying, we also think Jews are foreign. We also want them to get out. And this reaches its apogee when you have Theodor Herzl setting up a meeting with Vyacheslav von Plehve, the minister of the interior in Russia, a man that most Jews held responsible for orchestrating pogroms. And in this meeting, Herzl is trying to get von Plehve to put some pressure on the Ottoman sultan to make it easier for Zionists to colonize Palestine.

And in exchange, Herzl agrees that he will. curtail the Jewish revolutionary movement, which obviously he had no ability to do. Like, no, Bund disrespected him. But, you know, Herzl also was kind of a bullshit artist. And that was the thinking. It was like, we don't care what's happening to Jews inside Russia. We only care about building the ethnostate in Palestine.

Sam Adler-Bell

Right. On the one hand, it's like, in effect, the Zionists are taking the side of the anti-Semites in Eastern Europe. They're saying, yes, we are foreigners. We ought to leave. I'm with you. And then also in practical terms, its leadership were often literally collaborating with the regimes that wanted Jews to be oppressed and or dead.

Molly Crabapple

Always, always.

Sam Adler-Bell

So maybe let's give listeners more of a sense of what the Bund stood for in opposition to that.

Doikayt: here-ness

Sam Adler-Bell

It's so funny, like the term doikayt, which is Yiddish for here-ness, which is associated with the Bund. I feel like every leftist Jewish listener to this show knows that term.

Molly Crabapple

They may have a tattoo of it or a gold nameplate necklace.

Sam Adler-Bell

They do. But it's like beyond that little click, hopefully growing every day, and hopefully your book will contribute to it growing even more. It's not very well known. So could you tell us a little bit about that concept? And then just sort of more generally, like, yes, we can understand why the Bund was against Zionism for collaborating with its enemies in the regime and the bosses. But what was the Bund sort of positive idea of what? it meant to be a Jew in the Russian empire.

Molly Crabapple

They believe that Jews should be able to not just survive, not just be grudgingly tolerated, but to flourish and have beautiful, dignified lives in the lands where they already lived, which was Eastern Europe for the majority of Jews in the world, and that they should have lives where they could fight for a better and more beautiful world alongside the other people who were in the land, whether that was Georgians or Armenians, Russians, polls, whatever. And they called this here-ness. It was a commitment that this land that they lived on, no matter how brutal it was, no matter how much their neighbors tried to evict them, was theirs as well. They also had a right to it. It was their land. And it reminds me almost of this precursor concept to the idea of sumud, an unintentional precursor. I would never say sumud came from it, but like a precursor echo maybe. sumud is the Palestinian concept of steadfastness. And it refers to the steadfast determination to stay on your land despite the incredible predations and violence of the Israeli state. When I see the Bundist determination to stay in the towns and cities of their birth, despite the violence and despite the bigotry and despite the poverty, I can think of nothing so much as sumud.

Sam Adler-Bell

You write in the book that according to the principles you're describing, Bundists believed, quote, that Jews had the right to live in freedom and dignity wherever it was they stood. They would fight for a better and more beautiful world, even alongside people they had been raised to see as enemies, which I think is really core. And one of the things that's really revolutionary and obviously something that the Zionists don't buy, but there's this line that you quote a few times from Meyer London, who was a Jewish socialist labor lawyer on the Lower East Side. You know, we'll talk about the New York aspect of this story later, but he said about the Bund. He said, are you aware, he was giving a speech, he said, are you aware that in Russian Poland, thousands of our Jewish boys and girls pray to God not to lead them again out of Egypt, but to help them free Egypt? The idea of like deliverance, redemption. Revolution without exodus is what here-ness comes down to, and that it means that you have to have this hope in the possibility of organizing solidarity across these different ethnic particularities. And belief in that possibility comes to some tragic ends, which we'll talk about, but that does seem to be what seems so radical, even then, you know, even in 1903, about what the Bund was saying, which was that like, yes, we're Jews.

Yes, we're going to organize as Jews. We're going to reach people in Yiddish, meet people where they are, so to speak, the Jewish proletariat. But we're going to hope and believe and organize on the principle that our freedom is tied up with the freedom of workers of other ethnic groups, and that we're going to work with them in the places where we are to build, you know, international socialism.

Molly Crabapple

This belief in solidarity across difference is one of these things that's both so obvious and so radical. It's something that we see lived out every day in New York City. When I think of, for instance, the coalition that brought Zohran Mamdani to power, that is a coalition of people that are really, really different from each other. There are extremely conservative Bangladeshi taxicab workers, right? And then there's extremely hot trans girls at the $3 bill. And he spoke to both of them in their own way without ever compromising his ethics. And both of those groups supported him and so on, right? You ought to be able to fight alongside people that are different than you. In fact, if you cannot fight alongside people who are different than you, we are doomed. We are toast in this world. However, this idea still seems like a radical possibility, especially in the context that most other socialist groups would have said that Jews should just assimilate, that they should just change their name to Bob or Ivan or Fritz or whatever, and that they should just sort of melt into that. And the Bund was like, why? We think Jewish culture is just as legitimate and dignified as Russian culture or French culture or English culture or any other imperial culture. And we think we've just as much rights to our literature, our art, to state support for our culture as any other imperial language or culture does.

And also... in addition to that, in addition to being proud of who we are, we can fight alongside people who are very different from us because we're all socialists and we all believe in democratic socialism.

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, I feel like it would be strange to get too much farther into this conversation without talking about your personal and family connection to the history of the Bund, which is something that as a reader really drew me through the book.

Sam Rothbort, from painter to tannery striker

Sam Adler-Bell

And it, I think, enabled, you know, that kind of you know emotional and sincere attachment and empathy for the characters that is so evident and resonant about the book. Your great-grandfather was a Bundist.

Molly Crabapple

He was.

Sam Adler-Bell

Tell me about Sam Rothbort and how you found out about this part of his past.

Molly Crabapple

I grew up entirely surrounded by my great-grandfather. And I mean that in the most literal sense. My great-grandfather was a painter. And I grew up in apartments and houses where his art covered the walls. My mother learned how to paint from him. I learned how to paint from my mom. I always viewed my own ability to make art as some sort of gift that Sam Rothbort had given me. I knew his watercolors. I knew his sculptures. I knew his self-published philosophy. I knew these amazing photos of him eating fire and sticking pins through his cheeks and hanging from a chin-up bar by his ankles when he was 70. I remember the scraps of paper that he would write notes to himself, notes like... reject spineless authority. And without art, you're dead. And I knew the stories about him. I knew how he tried to set up a no-kill egg farm during the Depression that went bankrupt because a no-kill egg farm means infinite roosters who are all fighting.

Sam Adler-Bell

It's a resonant metaphor, possibly, for the fate of the Bund.

Molly Crabapple

Probably a resonant metaphor for other things. But I knew how he took back his own painting. from the Brooklyn Museum because he didn't like where they hung it. And then started what he called the Rothbort Museum of Direct Art, where him and his son Lawrence would put all of their paintings on the lawn and just like show them to the people in Brooklyn and how he would say, ah, the Rothbort Home Museum of Direct Art is now competing with the Museum of Modern Art. And they're scared. And I knew him. He was just, he was an amazing character and a brilliant painter. One of the bodies of work that I was most drawn to, and that I think in a lot of ways I was artistically influenced by too, was he had a body of work that were called memory paintings. And this was an attempt that he began shortly after Kristallnacht, but that he continued after the Holocaust, to paint back into existence the world of his childhood in a small town called Volkovysk, in a place that's now in Belarus, but at the time was part of the Tsarist Empire. and I loved them because they were every aspect of life. It wasn't just like the sacred stuff. It wasn't just like the sentimental stuff, not just like grandma lighting Shabbos candles. He was a bad kid. He was a totally bad kid. He taught the other kids how to smoke at religious school.

He would throw impromptu circus shows to try to impress little girls. He painted himself spying in the woman's bathhouse. He was bad. He was a bad little kid. He set his rabbi's shoes on fire. But there was one painting that I loved. And it was... a picture of a young woman with a long skirt and an updo on a miserable dirt road at night, and she's throwing a rock through a window. And her boyfriend is next to her with more rocks. And it was called, it was titled, Itka the Bundist Breaking Windows. And from the first moment I saw this, which must have been my late teens, or maybe I was 20, I was like, what is a Bundist? Because what would be the thing that would make this girl wearing this 19th century type dress be thrown a rock through a window at night? And that was what led me to the Bund.

Sam Adler-Bell

And I'll say for listeners that one of the great things about this book, too, I mean, I'm sure a lot of our listeners are going to be familiar with your art, even if they don't know that they're familiar with your art, because a lot of the iconography of the left in New York in particular, but also in other parts of the world, in my time as a leftist, like you created that iconography. Amen. I think of you as sort of an artist in residence of Occupy Wall Street and a lot of the images that I associate with that time in the city are images that you created. But in the book, there's portraits that you've done, illustrations you've done of some of the main characters that are sprinkled throughout it, which is a really excellent part of it. And also clearly a powerful kind of tribute to your great-grandfather too. And you can see, you can imagine as you describe these paintings the way in which his Sensibility has informed yours. But I think what might be helpful is just to give that sense of a texture of why somebody like Sam growing up in Volkovysk would end up joining the Bund. How did he go from somebody who was living in this small town, working in a tannery, to joining this international Jewish socialist movement?

Molly Crabapple

Sam had a youthful trajectory that in some ways was pretty common. His father went to America. Seldom came back to the Tsarist Empire. It was a really long trip. His mother worked. She had a little flour mill, which basically I think means she ground the flour herself. She sold flour off of a table at the fairs that would spring up on market days in Volkovysk. But his mother died during the Great Russian Cholera epidemic when he was still a little boy. I think he must have been like 11 or 12 years old. He was apprenticed out. first to a choir master to tour around synagogues and sing. But then after puberty hit and his voice broke, he was apprenticed out to a leather tannery. And working in a leather tannery is one of the most miserable jobs you can work. They literally would get something called the Siberian plague. And I was like, what's the Siberian plague? It was anthrax. People were routinely getting anthrax poisoning while working at tanneries. You tan leather in like some sort of mixture of like piss and chemicals. It just, the smell was so bad. No one wanted to be near you if you worked at a tannery. And, you know, the hours were such that my great-grandfather Sam's boss was Jewish.

So this meant that Sam got to take Shabbos off, right? You know, from Friday sundown to Saturday sundown. But once that sun set on Saturday, Sam was back at the leather tannery. to work all night and make up the hours that God had taken away from his boss. And this was a miserable life. And Sam was a talented kid, someone who drew since he was a little boy. And he just bridled against this. If you think about just the constraint, the physical toll of working like that, the conditions is horrible. And so when a young Jewish tutor named Chaim Nemzer comes to town offering lessons, but actually... comes to town as an emissary for a radical new Jewish group called the Bund, the way that Chaim Nemzer starts making inroads is that he starts telling the apprentices that they really ought to get Saturday night off of work. This leads to the first strike in Volkovysk, which leads to a brawl with strike breakers that takes place on the street in front of the synagogue while the Yom Kippur liturgy is being sung. And this leads to... their first labor victory, Saturday nights off of work, time, right? The most precious thing, life. You're getting your life back. And this victory very soon plunges Sam into a world of strikes, of sabotage, of revolutionary literature.

It takes him out of the very strict religious world of his birth. Suddenly he can hang out with girls. Like, oh my God, he can hang out with girls as equals and not just to date them, right? But to... see them as like fellow humans and friends. He can read secular literature. He can imagine a world that doesn't just include Jews, but even includes Christians in Volkovysk who often were persecutors, but he could imagine them not just as persecutors, but as comrades as well. And this jump out of a small, warm, safe, but very confined community into the wide world of modern insurrection is what's going to lead to the incident that will send Sam fleeing to New York.

Sam Adler-Bell

You want to tell us about that?

Molly Crabapple

Well, I had always known that Sam had left because of some sort of trouble, but what was it? And my mom always regretted that she never asked him what the trouble was. And then I was reading a book called The Making of Jewish Revolutionaries in the Pale of Settlement. I was reading the footnotes on a chapter, self-defense as an emotional experience. And I see Volkovysk in the footnote and I'm like, oh man, it's going to be good. What it is, is it's a testimony by a guy who was part of a self-defense squad in Volkovysk about how in late 1903, they had shot two cops who were leading a pogrom and about how after the shooting, Jewish members of the socialist movement, which was obviously also the self-defense squad, were getting rounded up to be sent to Siberia or else they were skipping town. And my great-grandfather arrived in America in early 1904. Quite a coincidence, right? But then my mother found a note from him where he wrote, I was involved in strikes, sabotage, even a shooting. And while I can never prove that the shooting that he was involved in was the shooting that killed those two police officers. It's very hard for me to imagine that in a town as small as this, where Sam was a major member of the local Bundist circle, that there were other shootings that he was talking about.

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, I mean, Matt Sitman, if he was here, would have already asked the sort of process question, which he always does, which is about how you went about writing this book. It took you seven years. What sorts of sources were you relying on?

Researching the Bund

Sam Adler-Bell

Where did you find them and what was the process of research. and writing like, and then we'll get back to the story.

Molly Crabapple

Well, I think that there's an obsessiveness to how I did it.

Sam Adler-Bell

I can tell.

Molly Crabapple

Yeah. Really? Really? You could tell? I mean, everyone's not up all night reading footnotes. So I think that I did this with an obsessiveness that I don't even know I would have had if I had been trained formally. So first of all, I was like, I have to obviously read every single book on the Bund that I can in the languages that I know. And then I'm like, well, if I want to really know about the Bund, I have to learn Yiddish. So I did the YIVO Yiddish summer program for two summers in a row. And that summer program, it's like a 20-hour-a-week thing with these very stern teachers who have no patience for any excuses you have. They will beat Yiddish into you. After that, I read every single book I could get my hands on in Yiddish that the Bund published because they published tons of these post-war books, including like... Some of these books were written with this socialist prose style that makes you want to die. Also, Yiddish memoirs like Rafael Abramovich's memoir, Two Revolutions, The Story of a Generation. I got access to a lot of memoirs that people might not necessarily have had. For instance, the grandson of Sofia Dubnova, one of my main characters, he gave me her memoir, which was in English. The family had published it kind of like as a gift for the family, but it wasn't necessarily widely available.

It was called... bread and matzah. And this memoir was formative to me. It was one of my major things in the book. So that's like my basic thing, right? Then a lot of elderly people who were descendants of Bundists got in touch with me. So I interviewed amazing people like Irena Klepfisz, the pioneering lesbian poet whose father, Michael, was the head bomb maker in the Warsaw Ghetto, you know, oral histories. And it wasn't just Bundists. For instance, I had heard that Alexander Erlich, who was the son of the leader of the Bund in Poland. He got to America and he sort of tried to keep the Bund going in the 20th century. I heard he was friends with Edward Said. So I contacted Najla Said, Edward Said's daughter. And I asked her, you know, is this true? Was Alexander friends with your father? Like, do you have any memories? And she gave me a beautiful memory about how when she was a seven-year-old girl, her and her father were walking and you know Alexander Erlich was there and he had a pin for solidarity, the trade union movement that would eventually bring down the Polish communist dictatorship. And she didn't know the word because she was seven. And so she asked her father, what does this word mean? And she told me, she's like, I learned that big, important word because of Alexander Erlich.

Sam Adler-Bell

The word solidarity. She asked her father, Edward Said, what does that mean? Because Alexander Erlich was wearing a pin that said it.

Molly Crabapple

Exactly.

Sam Adler-Bell

Unbelievable.

Molly Crabapple

I did a lot of that. I went to the countries. I didn't go to Russia or to Belarus because I'm scared of getting arrested, but I did go to the other countries like Latvia, Lithuania, Poland. I went to Ukraine during the invasion. Even where the street maps were utterly changed by the war, I wanted to see what wildflowers they looked at, what the sky felt like. I read people's enemies too. I read tons of the original press in Yiddish. I hired research assistants in Polish and Russian. you know, so that I could read stuff that like the Polish Socialist Party said, right? Or a Russian research assistant helped me with Jabotinsky wrote a polemical pamphlet against the Bund. I looked at the contemporaneous English press and not just like the obvious, like New York Times or Jewish Telegraph. I looked at the New York Age, which was a famous black newspaper. And what were they saying about the Russian Revolution? Basically, I just was obsessed. I compared it to doing necromancy. I literally did go to people's graves and take graveyard dust and light candles in front of it.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, all of this shows through the book, which despite the amount of labor that you put into it is not laborious to read, but it is informed by all that work. And it's such a great accomplishment. So thank you. But let's keep going. Let's talk a bit about the Russian revolutions of 1905 and 1917.

1905 and the Lower East Side

Sam Adler-Bell

Because this is obviously Hugely important for the 20th century, but also for a kind of turning point in the Bund's history as well.

Molly Crabapple

When the 1905 Russian Revolution kicks off, the spark is that a priest named Father Gapon with a government allied union. He decides to organize a bunch of workers in St. Petersburg, holding portraits of the Tsar, singing patriotic songs to ask the Tsar to intervene to make their lives a little more tolerable. And the Tsar is not in his palace at the time. He's in his vacation palace. But his soldiers gunned down these protesters. They massacre them. And this is the spark that will... lead to the entire Russian empire flaming with revolution. The Bund at this time has been basically kicked out of the Russian Social Democratic Party through the duplicity and maneuverings of one Vladimir Lenin, who will soon become one of their great antagonists. But they are a wildly popular party themselves. And when the revolution kicks off, they become the kings of all of these cities in the borderland of places like Lodz, which is a textile city with a huge proletariat. And when the barricade fighting starts, it is being led by a young Bundist named Virgili Kahan.

They are inciting the crowds in Odessa. When the battleship Potemkin pulls up, they are leading giant protests in Warsaw. They are kings. But then what happens is The revolution in Russia is getting so hot that a giant general strike breaks out in October, one that is grinding the empire to a halt. The trains are not running. The telegraphs aren't running. Everything stops. The czar's ministers tell the czar, dude, you have to give some sort of concession. You cannot just be like, I'm an autocrat appointed by God. This isn't going to work anymore. If you do not give some concession to the working class, you are toast. And so the czar releases what's called the October Manifesto, which gives some very, very minor concessions, like a censored free press and a parliament, but powerless. But this is enough to kind of buy off liberals. At the same time, the government unleashes a series of 800 clearly coordinated pogroms across the Russian empire. And sometimes I think when people think of pogroms, they think about like something like in Fievel, you know, where, I don't know, like the windows get smashed.

That's not what we're talking about. We're talking about like 800 people being murdered over the course of three days in Odessa, over a thousand in Kiev. These are massive Bundist instances of racial terror. There's no other way to describe them. They're so horrific that the black press in New York City is like, holy fuck like we are Black people living in America in 1905, and this is the worst thing that we have ever imagined what's happening in Russia. That's the level of horror. And the thing about these pogroms is that while obviously the state is behind them, the participants are often members of the Christian working class. And this failure of solidarity, it breaks this revolutionary wave. And the Bund goes into a real decline, like many Bundists. after 1905 and after the political repression that follows 1905, they go to New York City and they take part in creating the labor movement in America. You have Bundists like David Dubinsky, who goes on to lead the International Ladies Garment Workers Union. Sidney Hillman, I'm sure many listeners know about the Hillman Prize. Baruch Charney Vladeck, who was the father of public housing in New York City, an alderman, a member of LaGuardia's administration.

He was a Bundist. He had a scar across his face from a run-in with a cop. Vladeck wasn't even his real name. Vladeck was his nom de guerre. These people decided that their chances were better trying to achieve democratic socialism in America, even if that meant leaving the revolutionary stuff behind, than in trying to change a place as psychopathically racist as the one they came from.

Sam Adler-Bell

Right. I love this line. where you say, on the Lower East Side, socialism meant more than Marx. It was the idiom of something broad, free, and generous. The fight for a better and more beautiful world. To be socialist meant to be human. And I think partially what's in there, too, is that, like, these Bundists who had been involved in, yes, union organizing, but also sabotage and kind of, like, armed self-defense, revolutionary underground politics, that they arrive in New York and, yes, it's still... capitalist New York, but there are opportunities to do a kind of organizing, even as Jews, which can be legal, or at least you needed fewer handguns, basically. And that had a huge impact on their trajectory, but also on the trajectory of Jewish socialism in New York.

Molly Crabapple

Yeah. And of the labor movement, full stop, because these garment unions were some of the most advanced unions in America. And, you know, it's these Jewish workers that are going to lay the basis for the socialist party's electoral victories. For instance, Meyer London, he starts as a fundraiser for the Bund and he ends up as a socialist congressman.

1917, Lenin and Abramovich

Molly Crabapple

But you asked about 1917, the famous Russian Revolution. The Bund in 1917 is wrecked. Russia is several years into their suicidal foray into World War I. Millions of Russian soldiers are dead. Russia has also lost tons of territory to Germany and Austria. And a lot of that territory is the Bundist borderlands. So tons of their members. are now living under German and Austrian occupation. In addition, the czarist army and its infinite wisdom decided that Jews were a fifth column and mass deported Jewish communities in major Jewish cities like Dvinsk, for instance. They just put them in boxcars and deported them to the Russian interior. And also in 1917, Jews weren't allowed to live in the capital of Russia. So there isn't really like a Jewish proletarian working class in St. Petersburg, which is now called Petrograd. There's a very, very small Bund. But Bundists who are in Petrograd are not really expressing themselves politically as Bundists so much as members of the Bund's sister party, which is the Menshevik party, which had always been very allied with the Bund. So you have this situation that I guess would be analogous to now. You would have people who were members of DSA and JVP, almost like that.

Sam Adler-Bell

Jewish Voice for Peace for listeners. Yeah.

Molly Crabapple

Jewish Voice for Peace and DSA needs no introduction, I hope. So a similar type of thing. And when the working women of Petrograd on International Women's Day, 1917, decide that they are done having their men thrown into a meat grinder, and when these working women take to the streets, fight the cops, and eventually force the czar to resign, every single revolutionary party is blindsided. Not a single... one of them, not Mensheviks, not Bolsheviks, not the socialist revolutionaries, not a one thought that a revolution was going to break out at that moment. It was the people, the women of Petrograd that did that. But these socialists immediately scrambled to try to provide leadership for it, and they create something that is called the Petrograd Soviet. And Bundists are immediately involved from the first days. The Bundist Henryk Erlich literally helps create the Petrograd Soviet to provide one of the two centers of power during the first days of revolutionary Russia. However, soon the Bund's old rival, their old antagonist, good old Vladimir Lenin, arrives in a sealed train car from Switzerland and immediately sets about seizing history. And I wrote this book because I love the Bund, obviously.

No one writes a book this obsessively without some love. But the Bund at this point is definitely at its stupidest. They basically become completely theory-pilled and devoted to this vision of Marx's progression of history, where it is so dogmatic and so rigid that they somehow talk themselves into supporting staying in World War I. It's amazing. You're looking at this and you were like, can you people remove your head from the theoretical textbook and look at the world around you where soldiers are lynching their officers because they don't want to be thrown into a meat grinder? But no, the Bundists, they must keep huffing their theory. So because the Bundists, and not just them, but the SRs and the Mensheviks, are so committed to staying in this murderous, suicidal war, Lenin is able to seize power first over the Bolshevik party and then over the shattered corpse of the Russian Empire. Because Lenin and then the Bolsheviks become the only people willing to say that we will end the war. And the Bund is forced. into exile.

Sam Adler-Bell

Could you actually just quickly say why Lenin was an antagonist of the Bund? already by this point?

Molly Crabapple

There are theoretical reasons for that and there are personal reasons for that. And I genuinely feel like the personal reasons are more important.

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, I'll just say this here. This is one of the reasons that it's great to have a book like this written by somebody who's been so intimately involved in left organizational politics. You can know because you've had the experience where somebody pretends that a personal grievance is actually some kind of deep theoretical difference. You've seen it happen in meetings that you've been in, as you've seen it tear apart organizations that you were a part of. So, you know, when you read some of this stuff, like, well, was it really just that like Lenin wanted centralization and not these kinds of more distributed forms of organizational politics? Or was there something going on that was about personalities?

Molly Crabapple

Exactly. So the theoretical disagreement is that Lenin, as we know, was a believer in what is called democratic centralism, which essentially means that I'm going to say something that's going to get me in trouble with tankies, as I often am. But what democratic centralism means is that the party can talk about it all they want to, but once they come to an agreement, they have to ruthlessly carry that out. What this meant in practice was that everyone has to listen to Lenin. Lenin was a real believer in everyone listening to Lenin. It's one of his strongest beliefs. The Bund, meanwhile, had an idea for how the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party should go. where they thought it should be a federated party where different nationalities had sort of branches of it that could act autonomously. So you'd have like an Armenian social democratic thing and like a Lithuanian and a Jewish social democratic branch, and that they should be the exclusive representatives of the Jewish proletariat, which they definitely defined as people who spoke Yiddish. They weren't demanding that Trotsky had to listen to them, just to be clear. But when I read their debates about why they need to be the exclusive representative, of the Jewish proletariat and what Jewish peoplehood means and all of this stuff, what it really seems to come down to is that they don't trust Lenin. They don't like him. They think he's shifty. They think he's dictatorial.

They think he's an asshole. They think he lies all the time. I mean, when the Bundist activist Vladimir Medem finally met Lenin at Bern, this is in like 1902, he was not impressed. He had imagined Lenin would be a giant, but instead he resembled, quote, a crafty Russian grain dealer. When you speak to him, He looks at you with his small eyes, eyes directed at you obliquely from something of an angle and with a cunning devilish smile as if to say, there's not a word of truth in what you're saying. And Medem pegs Lenin as a bullshit artist and tyrant in waiting. So that's the background. They know Lenin very well. They're all part of this very, very intimate, incestuous exile community. And they hate him. They just dislike him so much. They dislike Trotsky. Trotsky makes his… entree into Bundist history by being the comment, not a question guy at a meeting.

Sam Adler-Bell

Right. Right. Yes. That comes through very clearly. But at this moment in 17, the Bund is wrong about this question about the war. And Lenin is right. I imagine even some Bundists would later think like the meme, like the worst guy you ever knew is right about something.

Molly Crabapple

A thousand percent. So one of the things that's just like devastating is obviously, even though the Bund as a party, the majority supported the idiotic continuance of World War I. There was a substantial faction that were not idiots that also saw that you needed to end the war. And in my book, that faction is represented by the Bundist Menshevik, Rafael Abramovich, whose memoirs I spent a lot of time with. And Abramovich is someone who always sees World War I as a bloody slaughter. And also he realizes the soldiers don't want to fight and that you cannot prosecute a war if your soldiers keep lynching their officers and running away. And so he spends the... months of Russia's democratic experiment, desperately trying to convince his fellow Mensheviks and Bundists, we have to end the war. If we do not make a separate peace right now, the soldiers are going to overthrow us and Lenin is going to be put in charge. And there's this one scene that I cut from the book where Abramovich finally, he gets a chance to have an audience with these Mensheviks and Bundists, and he makes his case about why they can't keep prosecuting the war. And finally, he's just looking at all the blank faces in the audience. And he's like, guys, I just want to know your plan. What are you going to do with the great Russian revolution while we still have it? Because at this time, you know, the Mensheviks and the SRs, they're the biggest party.

They still have the levers of power. And he's like, what are we going to do? And they just look at him blankly and are like, oh, that's a complicated question.

Sam Adler-Bell

Put it on the bike rack.

Molly Crabapple

Yeah, yeah. Table that. And then some of the guys later, they come to him and they're like, wow, you know, Abramovich, you were really brave for bringing that up. And you know, between us, I agree with you. And he's like, Why didn't you say something then? And they say, well, it's just too much to go against the. immortal science of dialectical materialism and also the opinions of our friends. We'd never be like that now, fortunately.

Sam Adler-Bell

No, too afraid to disagree with something that's wrong because some of our friends are taking the wrong position as well. No, I can't imagine such a thing. But of course, Lenin comes to town, takes the right position about the war. I will say that for someone who's read a lot of accounts of Lenin's arrival to the Finland station and all the... very many accounts of Lenin's kind of arrival on the scene of the 1917 revolution. Your book is a thrilling iteration of that. But of course, the Bolsheviks do take power and they do suppress the Bund. And this is a moment in which, you know, the Bund is in some ways undermined by their own mistakes.

Interwar Poland and the fight against fascism

Sam Adler-Bell

But what does the Bund do then?

Molly Crabapple

The Bund is suppressed in Soviet Russia, like every other socialist movement is. There's a whole other chapter I could get into about Ukraine that I'm not going to, but... the Bund reconstitutes in independent Poland. And here, for the very first time in their entire history, they are able to work in conditions of legality. Fraught, contested, but nonetheless real legality. And in Poland, they will build a beautiful alternate world. You have Bundists working on every single level of leftist politics. They have city councilmen. They have members of the Jewish councils. They have massive trade union movements. They build a whole secular Yiddish education system from kindergartens to night schools for teenage workers to even like a teacher's training college. They have a sanatorium for tubercular slum kids. They have boy and girl scouts. They have a woman's movement that is fighting for birth control and for child care. They have marches on May Day where 100,000 people join in. They have newspapers that are covering the... socialist movement in China that are covering Indian independence, that are covering the Scottsboro Boys and Alabama. They have an entire world that they're building.

And they're not just building it, but they are defending it from all sorts of enemies with armed paramilitary groups.

Sam Adler-Bell

It's an incredible part of the story. And I think it becomes another test of this belief in the possibility of solidarity across difference in particular of course when Fascism begins to be a serious concern in Eastern Europe and in Europe, broadly speaking. Do you want to talk a little bit about how the Bund attempts to work with some success and some less so with the Socialist Party in Poland and sort of like leading us toward their attempted collaborations during the Nazi invasion?

Molly Crabapple

The Bund keeps a close eye on the rise of fascism in Europe. They send journalists undercover into Nazi Germany. Thank you. to report on the conditions of Jewish life there at a time when this is completely censored in Poland. They send fighters to the front in the Spanish Civil War and they raise money for weapons. They send people to Red Vienna to help support the socialist government there. They are people who are internationalists who are acutely aware of what it means that fascism is rising. But at the same time as fascism is rising outside of Poland's borders, it is rising inside of it. After Marshal Józef Piłsudski, the founding father of Poland, dies in 1935, the Polish government is taken over by a quartet of puffed up military men with nothing in their brains and a bunch of medals on their chests. And these guys, the colonels they're called, decide that the glue of Poland is now going to be racism against Jews. And they spend the next years, the four years until the Nazis finally invade. trotting around the world, trying to convince countries to allow them to deport all 3.3 million Polish Jews, either to colonize Madagascar or to Palestine.

They introduce racial segregation at Polish schools. Jews have to sit on a separate side of the classroom. They fund terrorist youth paramilitaries that bomb and beat and stab Jewish neighborhoods. And they orient their entire policy to trying to create the same sort of Nuremberg laws that are happening across the border in Germany. And while they're doing this, the Bund is resisting with guns and brass knuckles. They are resisting with force of arms and fighting for their communities. And they're not doing it alone. The Bund has a sister party in Poland, which is called the Polish Socialist Party. And while the relationship could be touch and go, it was not always roses. It's not like Polish people are immune to racism. And it's not like the Bundists were immune to leftist sectarianism. Far from it. They were sister parties and they fought fascists with their fists and with guns together, side by side. So in 1939, The Bund sweeps the municipal elections in Poland. They are the most popular Jewish party in the country by far. They win the majority of Jewish delegates in every single urban center in Poland that has a Jewish community. And then the Nazis invade in September, in September 1st, 1939.

The puffed up military men, these people who had spent so many years talking about their beautiful army and the need to ethnically cleanse all the Jews, they fled the country within a day. They took the country's gold reserves and they ran away to Romania. But the Polish Socialist Party, under the leadership of Zygmunt Zaremba, they decide that even if the country's leadership has abandoned them, that the city will fight alone, that Warsaw cannot fall.

The Warsaw Ghetto and the uprising

Molly Crabapple

And Polish and Jewish workers fight on the barricades of Warsaw against tanks for weeks upon weeks, while the French and British allies of Poland conveniently forget their mutual defense pact. but When the Nazi occupation does seize Warsaw, they soon force Jews into a ghetto. And the Bund begs Jews not to go into the ghetto. The Bundist councilman, Artur Zygielbojm, he publicly urges Jews to resist going into the ghetto with their hands if necessary. He does this at a time when this meant certain death. He had to go into hiding immediately afterwards. And he escapes Poland and then the continent in this death-defying escape. And he ends up in London. serving as the Bund's representative in the Polish government in exile. But Warsaw's Jews and Poland's Jews are all forced into ghettos. And the Warsaw Ghetto, I think people don't quite understand what it was. Warsaw had the largest Jewish population of any city in the world, except for New York. And the Warsaw Ghetto soon swells with all these people that are deported from Western Poland. There's about 500,000 people in it. And they are squeezed into a space smaller than Central Park, where... they're given 180 calories a day, where it's seven people to a room, and where they are subject to every possible torment you could imagine.

But despite this, they're still in their city, and they create this kind of society and microcosm, which has everything from brothels and nightclubs to anthropologists producing vast cultural archives and classical music concerts. And it has every single Jewish political party, the Bund included. And the Bund recreate their subculture in underground form devoted to preserving life, physical and spiritual.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah. I mean, I feel this leads us to the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, which is a story that I think probably a lot of listeners know. I mean, it's sort of core to the history of the Nazi oppression and of the Holocaust as this kind of... last stand of Jewish self-organization and resistance, one of the things that's so interesting about it that I learned so much more about from your book was, first of all, just the texture of it, which is told really compellingly in your book, but also about who led it and who was willing to engage in this, you know, doomed, deadly, but dignified endeavor. And I think something that's... really interesting about it and sort of like adds to the kind of, you know, your willingness to engage with the complexity of Jewish history in this period is that the Bund had never worked with Zionists, right? Like that was like one of their first principles. No working with these people who agree that we're swarthy foreigners that should leave Europe. But in the moment of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, there were Bundists certainly involved in fighting that fight and leading it, but also there were left-wing Zionist youth groups who are also totally indispensable.

And I found it very interesting to hear about that kind of rare moment of solidarity is perhaps too strong a word, but of cooperation in a moment of total desperation that took place during the uprising.

Molly Crabapple

So there's two things I think that are really important to understand about the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. And the first one, is that it was an uprising by very young people. It was not an uprising by the adult leadership of any party. And the second is that it was doomed. And the people who were in the uprising knew that it was doomed. It was always conceived of as a suicidal act, as a way of dying with dignity. But let me move back and just give some context. The first people to propose a United Jewish Combat Organization were young left-wing Zionist activists. It was actually two lovers, Zivia Lubetkin. and Antek Zuckerman, who were young activists of Dror, which was a left-wing Zionist youth movement. And while the Bund and while everyone knew about the horrific massacres out east that were happening and even the gassing that was starting to happen of Jews in the back of trucks and about the mass murders of the Jews of Vilna, these two young people were the first people who I think really grasped that this wasn't massacres, that this was a genocide.

And I think there were a few things that they had that the Bund, but also that other groups didn't have. The first thing was that Dror was a movement of the young. They did not have a middle-aged leadership. And this is really important because the middle-aged leadership of every single movement, including the Zionists, was absolutely opposed to armed uprising. And the reason that they were opposed to armed uprising inside the ghetto is that they thought it was an act of suicide. They were not opposed to sending people to join the partisans. They were not opposed to acts of sabotage. They were not opposed to killing a German when they could. They weren't pacifists, but they were opposed to the idea of doing something that was going to get everyone in the ghetto killed. And young people, I believe, can sometimes, when they're faced with something completely unprecedented, which a genocide was in Europe, they can see things more clearly. They're not relying on their past experience, which can sometimes cloud your vision. And so this movement, which only had young people in it, didn't have middle-aged leaders to hold them back. That's the first reason. The second reason is that the Bund was spending this whole time ferociously trying to get guns in every possible way they can and begging. the Polish Socialist Party to get them weapons. The Polish Socialist Party, I want to make very clear, were heroic allies to the Bund. Members of the Polish Socialist Party went to Auschwitz for distributing the Bund's press.

They hid the Bund's kids. They hid Bundists in their homes at a time that this meant death. They taught Bundists to make bombs. They got them fake papers. They got them news. Polish Socialists were sneaking into the ghetto to meet with Bundists. This is not a group that has in any way abandoned the Bund. But Bund thought that a rebellion that they did would be part of a unified rebellion to liberate the country from the Nazis. And the Polish Socialist Party, they were part of the Polish government in exile and the Polish Home Army. And the Polish Home Army had a military strategy. And that strategy was that they would wait and they would gather their forces. They'd recruit more and more men. They'd get more and more arms and they would wait until either the Russians or the Western Allied forces were close enough to Poland. And then they would launch a countrywide uprising so that the allies could relieve them, right? Because they knew that if they did a countrywide uprising without help from the outside world, that they would just be butchered. And so they're not really getting the Bund weapons. They're getting them like a few here or there, but they're not really getting the Bund weapons. And they're certainly not willing to launch an uprising. Now, the Zionist movement didn't care about that. were not seeing an uprising that they did as part of a unified attempt to liberate Poland from the Nazis.

They were seeing it as a Jewish act of defiance, as Masada essentially. But nonetheless, because the Bund was the only group that had access to the Home Army and thus weapons through this connection with the Polish Socialist Party, these two young activists asked the Bund to create a united Jewish combat group and the Bund refuses. They absolutely refuse. In fact, their representative says, you know, if we weren't stuck in the ghetto, we wouldn't even be at the same table as you people. And then the Nazis deport 90 percent of the Jews from the Warsaw Ghetto to Treblinka.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah. The liquidation of the ghetto.

Molly Crabapple

The liquidation, 90 percent, including most people over 30 and most children. And the Polish Socialist Party, while it hides Bundist activists, they don't stop the liquidation. The Home Army does nothing to stop the liquidation. In fact, In the underground Polish press, they even criticized the Jews for going to their deaths and looked down on them for not putting up more of a fight, despite the fact that the Polish Home Army had not given the Jews any means to resist at all. And after the ghetto is mostly liquidated and after it's only young people there, the members of the Bundist youth group, Zukunft, decide that they don't give a fuck about ideology. They don't give a fuck about who. didn't like who at which conference, that no one is going to Palestine, that there is nothing left except to do a last stand and to die with dignity. And that's when they launched the Jewish Combat Organization, which contains Jewish left Zionists, communists, and Bundists. Notably, it does not contain Jewish right-wing Zionists who have their own separate group.

Sam Adler-Bell

Despite the fact that the Zionists today will take credit for participating in the Warsaw Ghetto uprising and indeed kind of... We'll get to this at the end of the conversation, but the Zionist state that is formed in 48 is sort of formed in opposition to the notion of Jewish weakness in response to the Nazi incursion. That like we will build a state that is like built from the impulses of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, which is about the idea of like armed Jews protecting themselves as Jews. It's kind of like an authorizing myth of the state, you know, but it's something that comes through in your book, which is clear is that like. It really wasn't all the Zionists.

Molly Crabapple

No, and the Zionists who were doing it, they had no help from the Zionists in Palestine at all. In fact, in Marek Edelman's memoir, he talks about Antek Zuckerman, the founder of the Jewish Combat Organization, making lists of Zionists in Palestine who he wanted to murder after the war because he felt so betrayed by them. In fact, the young Zionist fighters in Poland received so little help from the community in Palestine that they had to... live off of money that was provided by the Bund when they were hiding after the ghetto was destroyed. And even just to give you one more anecdote of the contempt with which not just Holocaust survivors were treated, but partisans as well. There's an anecdote I found where a young Zionist Polish Jewish partisan went to Palestine after the war and was giving a speech in Yiddish about her experiences as a partisan. And she was heckled from the audience. by David Ben-Gurion for daring to speak Yiddish instead of Hebrew. This is the level of just contempt for Holocaust survivors that was evinced in Israel. But they launched the uprising, which is the first urban revolt in occupied Europe, full stop. And when they launched the uprising, they have a small amount of help from the Polish Home Army. It was not nothing. They had 50 guns.

They had homemade landmines. They had Molotov cocktails, one machine gun and light bulbs filled with battery acid. That's what they launched the uprising with. They held off for longer than the entire countries of Poland and France. And while the Polish Home Army helped the Jewish ghetto fighters to some degree, they refused to allow the revolt to spread to the Aryan city. And the reason that they did this was that they felt that if the revolt spread, that the whole city would be slaughtered. And the Polish Socialist Party went along with that. They watched their friends burn alive in the center of Warsaw. The ghetto was so close to the Aryan city that it'd be like looking from one end of the street to the other. They were watching people jumping out of burning buildings and dying. The whole city was covered with smoke and ash. And the ghetto burned. The ghetto burned while Polish Warsaw lived. That's the truth. And then about a year later, the Russians have defeated the Nazis at Stalingrad and they have liberated. Eastern Europe, and they have marched to Praga, which is a suburb of Warsaw. They're right across the river. And the Red Army starts doing radio broadcasts saying, guys, come on, we're here. It's time for you to revolt. And the Polish Home Army listens. And of course they would.

And they launched what's called the Warsaw Uprising, the citywide uprising. And the Red Army waits on the other side of the river. And they watch them. And they wait. And the reason that they wait. is that Stalin didn't like the Home Army, and he was quite happy for the Nazis and the Home Army to finish each other off, saving him the trouble. And so the Red Army watched while the entire city of Warsaw burned, and they did nothing. And then they marched in and took the rubble.

Sam Adler-Bell

I'm not sure how many tankie listeners we have, but this is where you're really losing them.

Molly Crabapple

Yeah, I'm sorry to say that Joseph Stalin, he did bad things. I mean, like I... I would never besmirch the heroism of the Red Army. We all know that they liberated Eastern Europe. They liberated Auschwitz. Like 20 million Soviets died. However, they chose to watch Warsaw burn so that the Home Army would soften up the Nazis.

”Those who stayed died”

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, I think that like there's so much about this history that feels unbelievably relevant to our present moment. But I think I can already see it in responses to your book or responses to the New York Times review that I've seen from exactly those pants shitting Zionists that you mentioned earlier, they go, well, okay, yeah, what a beautiful idea, here-ness. What a beautiful idea, solidarity across difference. But look what happened. Look what happened. Those who stayed, they died. And those who left, they built a nation state, a powerful nation state now that is so powerful that it can do its own genocides these days. But it seems to be true to some degree that immediately after... the Holocaust, that the sort of plausibility of the story that the Bund was telling about what was possible and how they would get there seemed to be diminished. Even, you know, there's this amazing moment in the book where you describe this conversation that takes place in sort of like a Bundist hideout during the liquidation of the Warsaw Ghetto, where there's this sort of older Bundist woman who's just reminiscing about Red Vienna and about Walking down the streets of the Ringstrasse, holding the Bundist and Austrian children cheering for her.

And then a younger woman in the same hideout, she sort of sneers at this woman and she says, where are they now, your noble-hearted Austrians? That is kind of the story about what the Bund got wrong about Eastern Europeans. They got wrong about the whole project that they had proposed, which to the Zionists... is the kind of QED of their argument against Bundist politics, right? Like, the Holocaust happened. You were wrong. These people were never going to protect you. They were never going to be your allies in proletarian revolution. And those of you who stayed out of this naive hope for solidarity across difference and a belief in here-ness instead of exodus, you were wrong. You died. And we lived and we built this powerful state in Palestine. So, you know, I'm still manning the Zionists. But what do you make of that?

Molly Crabapple

I'm going to start with the historical disagreements. So the historical disagreements is that countless Zionists were murdered in the Holocaust. The idea that Zionists lived and Bundists died. I mean, the amount of Zionists that were murdered, including Zionist ghetto fighters, including great sociologists like Emanuel Ringelblum. including the left Zionist leader, Ignacy Schipper, died in Majdanek. The fact that Zionists are so willing to spit on their own dead who were murdered in the Holocaust in countless numbers, numbers that probably dwarfed the population of Palestine, given how small the population of Palestine was, is shocking, right? It's also shocking that they're willing to spit on the 500,000 young Jewish men and women who fought in the Red Army. to save Eastern European Jews from the Nazis. These young Jewish men and women led the liberation of Auschwitz. They invaded Berlin and the Zionist movement, which sent a mere 30,000 fighters to Europe at the very end of the war, who barely saw action. The Zionist movement is willing to sneer on these 500,000 young Jewish people who fought or the young Jewish people who fought in the American army to save the world from fascism. There's something so disgusting about that.

I also want to note. that the reason that Palestine was safe for Jews was not because it has a magical force field around it. It was safe because it was a British colony. And the British, not the Yishuv, not the noble Sabras, but the fucking British empire was what stopped Rommel at El Alamein. And if they had not stopped Rommel, then every single Jew in the Yishuv would have been murdered, just like the Jews in Poland. There was no way for Jews as a collective to protect themselves from the Nazis. It took 20 million dead Soviet citizens and the entire industrial might of America and millions of young men from the colonies as well, like the million Indians who fought to destroy Nazism. It took the whole world. It took probably like 10 million Chinese people, right? Like it took the whole world to defeat Nazism. The idea that Jews could have protected themselves from Nazism is insane. So I don't regard the Bund as a failure or anyone else for that matter. I think that they were defeated. But the thing that I do think is true is that... Zionism was able to take hegemony because the whole world decided to betray Jewish refugees. They even specifically made laws to keep out the majority of Jewish refugees in America because they thought they were communists. And that is what allows violent supremacist ideologies like Zionism to take root.

Jews are not the only group of people who are traumatized refugees rotting in camps with their whole families dead, who become radicalized by ideologies. that promised redemption through violence. This is a common tale. This is the story of the 20th century.

The Bundists were right

Molly Crabapple

And if you don't want psychopathic, violent ideologies to thrive, then you have got to offer human solidarity because that is the only defense we have against savagery and barbarism.

Sam Adler-Bell

And while all this is true, there's also the fact that the Bundists were right. I mean, this is the crazy thing about reading your book and anybody who's read sort of Bundist anti-Zionist literature from the 1930s or before. You know, Erlich in 1933 saying, if Jewish nationalism as general rule is not bloodthirsty, this is only out of necessity, not virtue. If an appropriate opportunity arose, Jewish nationalism would show its sharp teeth and nails, no less than the nationalisms of other nations. He points out then the Jabotinsky, meaning the sort of revisionist Zionist.

Molly Crabapple

The daddy of the Likud party.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah, spiritual daddy of the Likud party is exactly the right. way to put it. So the people who are in charge of Israel now, this is their philosophical lodestar. Erlich says, Jabotinsky's brown shirt soldiers, this is in 1933. And here he's talking about Beitar and the Irgun militias, Beitar, which is mostly operating in Europe and the Irgun in Palestine. This is what he says. They are no more than a tragic comic caricature of Hitler's SA. And then he says, we are not a chosen people. Our nationalism is just as ugly, just as harmful, and has the same inclination to fascist debauchery. as the nationalisms of other nations. You know, the Zionist sort of argument that the Holocaust settled the question, the sort of long debate between internationalist socialists like the Bundists and Zionist settler colonialists, that's bullshit for the reasons you've described. But also the Bundists were so prescient about what was going to happen because they understood nationalism so well. It had plagued them. It had plagued their... experience, their experience as Jews and as socialists in all these countries, they didn't think that Jews, because they were Jews, were incapable of the same sorts of crimes that The fascists, not just the Nazis, but nationalists, ethno-nationalists of every stripe, had subjected the Jews to.

They knew the Jews were capable of the same thing. And they warned the world, they warned the Zionists, they warned the Jews that that was the case. And they expressed their solidarity and their sympathy with the Palestinians right away.

Molly Crabapple

And they demanded the right of Palestinian refugees to return after the Nakba. They recognized the Nakba and they demanded the right of return. And I think that there are... two reasons that the Bund makes Zionists so angry. Because the anger is interesting, because there were other groups, right, that told Jews to stay in Europe. I live in Satmar, Williamsburg. The Satmar Rebbe, Rabbi Teitelbaum, famously told his followers to stay in Czechoslovakia, where they were all butchered and from which he escaped. But there isn't that rage at the Satmar or at other Haredi groups. There isn't that rage at... German assimilated Jews who chose to say they were French assimilated Jews, the hatred is for the Bund. And I think there are two reasons. The first is that the Bund were strong and Zionism has always maintained that they have the monopoly on strength, that there's either weak diaspora Jews or tough Sabras.

Sam Adler-Bell

That's so right. The whole thing that Jews after 67 in America, sort of like proto-neocons who would say like, oh, well, we used to think Jews were only good with a fountain pen, but they're pretty good with a rifle as well. As if Jews never fought.

Molly Crabapple

Hadn't they heard a man called Leon Trotsky?

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah, they had a sort of strategic amnesia about him by that point.

Molly Crabapple

So that's one thing, right? They want to claim the monopoly and strength. They want to claim like, we're like the big dicked Sabras and these like weak, emasculated ghetto Jews were all gassed. It's so disgusting. But that's one reason. But there's another reason. And the other reason is that the Bund had their number. They looked at Zionists and they said, you people are going to become ethnic. cleansing fascists. And you might be pretending to be socialists now, but we know what you're going to become. And we know what sort of state you'll make if you ever should make it. And that, I think, is the real cause of the hatred, even more than the fact that the Bund was strong. It's that the Bund looked at them and they knew what they were from day one.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah. Yeah. That's intolerable. This is surely obvious to the listeners who've listened to this conversation. This history could not be more relevant to what... you know, what Jews are kind of wrestling with right now and the kind of intergenerational conflicts that we're going through. And it's not surprising to me, as I know, your book is already in its second printing before it's even been released, because there are so many Jews, I think, that are hungry, you know, to try to find a way to relate to Jewishness and their Jewish history and Jewish tradition, which rejects the monopoly of the Zionists on those resources are on that story.

Molly Crabapple

Thank you so much. And I think... Ultimately, what the Zionists are trying to do when they sneer at the Bund, when they sneer at Jews that were murdered in the Holocaust, and when they claim that they were inevitable, is they're trying to cover up the fact that they're doing a genocide in Gaza right now, and that this genocide has spilled out to now rain hell on the entire region. They're trying to claim the past as an excuse for the present, but the truth is they got their state, and what sort of state did they get, and what has it given the world?

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah, pretty much exactly. sort of state that very prominent Bundists expected them to build. Thank you, Molly. This was amazing. Exactly as interesting and complicated and excellent as I thought it would be.

Molly Crabapple

Thank you so much, Sam. This was a joy.

Sam Adler-Bell

Thank you, listeners. Bye-bye.