Bundism and Zionism were born within weeks of each other in 1897, and in Molly Crabapple’s telling they hated each other from the start . Her history of the General Jewish Labour Bund, Here Where We Live Is Our Country, follows the secular socialist party that bet on staying: on fighting for a better world in the lands where Jews already lived, alongside their neighbors. The case against that bet is the one Sam, hosting alone, puts to her late in the conversation, the Zionist rejoinder that “those who stayed, they died” . Crabapple’s answer carries the last stretch of the episode: in her view the Bund was not a failure but was defeated .
Key Topics
- Crabapple sets out the three oppressions of Jews in the Tsarist Empire , from which the Bund’s founders concluded that “the Jewish worker was oppressed both because he was a worker and because he was a Jew” , and says three Bundists were among the 11 founders of the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party .
- She says the Bund saw Zionism as “capitulation to the same bigots that wanted to kick Jews out of their home” , a view that peaked when Theodor Herzl met Vyacheslav von Plehve, the minister many Jews blamed for the pogroms .
- Sam explains doikayt, Yiddish for “here-ness” , the commitment Crabapple describes as fighting “for a better and more beautiful world alongside the other people who were in the land” , and which she calls “an unintentional precursor” to the Palestinian concept of sumud .
- Her great-grandfather, the painter Sam Rothbort, whose Itka the Bundist Breaking Windows first led her to the Bund , was a tannery apprentice in Volkovysk drawn in by the town’s first strike , and he reached America in early 1904 .
- In 1905, she says, the government answered the revolution with “800 clearly coordinated pogroms” , and in 1917 the Bund was “at its stupidest” , backing the war while Rafael Abramovich warned that without a separate peace “Lenin is going to be put in charge” .
- In independent Poland, in Crabapple’s account, the Bund built “a beautiful alternate world” , fought the colonels’ antisemitic regime alongside the Polish Socialist Party , and swept the Jewish vote in 1939 .
- In the Warsaw Ghetto, she says, the Bund refused the left Zionists Zivia Lubetkin and Antek Zuckerman’s call for a united combat group ; only after the deportations to Treblinka did the Jewish Combat Organization of left Zionists, communists and Bundists launch what she calls “the first urban revolt in occupied Europe” .
- Crabapple argues that “Zionism was able to take hegemony because the whole world decided to betray Jewish refugees” ; Sam reads Henryk Erlich’s 1933 warning that Jewish nationalism “would show its sharp teeth and nails” , and Crabapple says Zionists hate the Bund because it “had their number” .
Notable Quotes
"Are you aware that in Russian Poland, thousands of our Jewish boys and girls pray to God not to lead them again out of Egypt, but to help them free Egypt?"Meyer London, read by Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 24:38
"Revolution without exodus is what here-ness comes down to."Sam Adler-Bell, on doikayt, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 24:54
"I compared it to doing necromancy. I literally did go to people's graves and take graveyard dust and light candles in front of it."Molly Crabapple, on her research, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 41:05
Outline
- 0:00:00 — Introducing the Bund
- 0:05:22 — A book seven years in the making
- 0:08:38 — Three oppressions
- 0:12:14 — From reading circles to a mass party
- 0:17:53 — Bundism and Zionism, born in 1897
- 0:22:08 — Doikayt: here-ness
- 0:27:39 — Sam Rothbort, from painter to tannery striker
- 0:37:26 — Researching the Bund
- 0:41:39 — 1905 and the Lower East Side
- 0:47:00 — 1917, Lenin and Abramovich
- 0:56:25 — Interwar Poland and the fight against fascism
- 01:01:37 — The Warsaw Ghetto and the uprising
- 01:14:18 — “Those who stayed died”
- 01:19:40 — The Bundists were right
Mentioned Resources
People
- Alexander Erlich (son of Henryk Erlich, who reached the United States and tried to keep the Bund alive there)
- Antek Zuckerman (Dror activist who with Zivia Lubetkin first proposed a united Jewish fighting organization in the Warsaw Ghetto)
- Artur Zygielbojm (Bund city councilman in Warsaw who urged Jews to resist the ghetto, then represented the Bund in London)
- Baruch Charney Vladeck (former Bundist who became a New York City alderman and, in Crabapple’s phrase, the father of the city’s public housing)
- Chaim Weizmann (Zionist leader who later became the first president of Israel)
- David Ben-Gurion (Zionist leader and Israel’s first prime minister)
- Edward Said (Palestinian-American literary scholar and critic)
- Emanuel Ringelblum (historian who organized the underground archive of the Warsaw Ghetto)
- Erwin Rommel (German field marshal whose North African campaign the British stopped at El Alamein in 1942)
- Georgy Gapon (Russian Orthodox priest who led the St. Petersburg workers’ procession to petition the Tsar in January 1905)
- Henryk Erlich (Bund leader who helped create the Petrograd Soviet in 1917 and led the party in interwar Poland)
- Irena Klepfisz (poet and child survivor of the Holocaust whose father was the chief bomb maker of the Warsaw Ghetto’s fighters)
- Isaac Bashevis Singer (Yiddish novelist and short-story writer, winner of the Nobel Prize in Literature)
- Joseph Stalin (Soviet leader during World War II)
- Józef Piłsudski (marshal and founding father of independent interwar Poland, who died in 1935)
- Leon Trotsky (Russian revolutionary and Bolshevik leader)
- Marek Edelman (Bundist commander in the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising who survived the war and wrote about it)
- Meyer London (Jewish socialist labor lawyer on the Lower East Side who raised money for the Bund and later served in Congress)
- Molly Crabapple (artist, journalist and activist, author of Here Where We Live Is Our Country and the episode’s guest)
- Najla Said (writer and actor, the daughter of Edward Said)
- Rafael Abramovich (leader of both the Bund and the Mensheviks, and author of a Yiddish memoir)
- Sam Rothbort (painter born in Volkovysk, Molly Crabapple’s great-grandfather and a Bundist in his youth)
- Sidney Hillman (Bundist before he emigrated, later an American labor leader)
- Sofia Dubnova (Bundist poet and memoirist, one of the main characters of Crabapple’s book)
- Theodor Herzl (founder of political Zionism)
- Vladimir Jabotinsky (founder of Revisionist Zionism and the Beitar youth movement)
- Vladimir Lenin (Bolshevik leader and antagonist of the Bund)
- Vladimir Medem (theorist and leader of the Bund)
- Vyacheslav von Plehve (Russian minister of the interior in the early 1900s, whom many Jews held responsible for the pogroms)
- Zivia Lubetkin (Dror activist and a founder of the Jewish Combat Organization in the Warsaw Ghetto)
- Zohran Mamdani (New York City politician whose coalition Crabapple cites as solidarity across difference)
Organizations
- Bolsheviks (Lenin’s wing of Russian social democracy, which took power in October 1917)
- General Jewish Labour Bund (secular Jewish socialist party founded in Vilna in 1897, the episode’s subject)
- Home Army (main Polish underground army of World War II, loyal to the government in exile in London)
- Irgun (Revisionist Zionist paramilitary organization of Mandate Palestine)
- Jewish Combat Organization (Warsaw Ghetto fighting organization of left Zionists, communists and Bundists)
- Mensheviks (moderate wing of Russian social democracy, long allied with the Bund)
- Polish Socialist Party (main socialist party of interwar Poland and the Bund’s closest non-Jewish ally)
- Red Army (army of the Soviet Union)
- Russian Social Democratic Labour Party (Marxist party founded in 1898 that later split into Bolsheviks and Mensheviks)
- Satmar (Hasidic dynasty with a large community in Brooklyn)
- Solidarity (Polish independent trade union movement of the 1980s)
- Zionist Congress (assembly of the Zionist movement, first convened by Theodor Herzl in Basel in 1897)
Places
- Auschwitz (Nazi concentration and extermination camp in occupied Poland)
- Germany (whose armies occupied the Bundist borderlands in World War I, and later the Nazi state)
- Israel (the state founded in 1948)
- Lodz (Polish textile city with one of the largest industrial working classes in the Russian Empire)
- Lower East Side (Manhattan neighborhood at the center of Jewish immigrant life and socialism around the turn of the 20th century)
- New York City (center of American Jewish life, where Bundists fled after 1905)
- Odessa (Black Sea port of the Russian Empire)
- Pale of Settlement (western provinces of the Russian Empire to which Jews were legally confined)
- Palestine (the land the Zionist movement set out to settle)
- Poland (the country where most of the Bund’s story takes place)
- Red Vienna (Vienna under its Social Democratic city government from 1919 to 1934)
- Russian Empire (the empire of the Romanov tsars)
- Saint Petersburg (capital of the Russian Empire, renamed Petrograd in 1914)
- Treblinka (Nazi extermination camp in occupied Poland)
- Vilna (now Vilnius in Lithuania, the city where the Bund was founded in 1897)
- Volkovysk (small town in the Pale of Settlement, now in Belarus, and Sam Rothbort’s birthplace)
- Warsaw (capital of Poland, which before the war had the largest Jewish population of any city except New York)
- Warsaw Ghetto (Nazi ghetto in occupied Warsaw from 1940 to 1943, the largest in Europe)
Works
- Bread and Matzah (Sofia Dubnova’s English-language memoir, published privately by her family)
- Here Where We Live Is Our Country (Molly Crabapple’s 2026 history of the Bund, seven years in the making and illustrated with her own portraits)
- Itka the Bundist Breaking Windows (memory painting by Sam Rothbort of a young woman throwing a rock through a window at night in Volkovysk)
- New York Age (Black newspaper published in New York)
- October Manifesto (Tsar Nicholas II’s decree of October 1905, which promised civil liberties and an elected Duma)
- Reds (Warren Beatty’s 1981 film about John Reed and the Russian Revolution)
- The Making of Jewish Revolutionaries in the Pale of Settlement (scholarly history of Jewish radicalism in the Tsarist Empire)
- Two Revolutions, The Story of a Generation (Rafael Abramovich’s Yiddish memoir)
Concepts
- Anti-Zionism (opposition to Zionism and to a Jewish state)
- Doikayt (Yiddish for “here-ness”: the Bund’s principle that Jews should fight for a better life in the lands where they already lived)
- Neoconservatism (movement of former liberals and leftists who moved right from the 1960s on)
- Ostjuden (German term for the Jews of Eastern Europe, often used with contempt)
- Pogrom (organized attack on a Jewish community)
- Revisionist Zionism (right-wing current of Zionism founded by Vladimir Jabotinsky)
- Settler Colonialism (colonialism in which settlers replace or displace a native population)
- Yiddish (language of Eastern European Jews and the medium of the Bund’s organizing, press and schools)
- Zionism (movement for a Jewish state in Palestine)
Events
- Nakba (expulsion and flight of Palestinians in 1948, with the founding of Israel)
- Russian Revolution of 1905 (a year of strikes, mutinies and uprisings across the Russian Empire)
- Russian Revolution of 1917 (the February revolution that brought down the Tsar and the Bolshevik seizure of power in October)
- The Holocaust (Nazi genocide of European Jews)
- War in Gaza (Israel’s war in Gaza following the October 7 attack, which the speakers call a genocide)
- Warsaw Ghetto Uprising (armed revolt of the ghetto’s Jewish fighters in April and May 1943)
- World War I (the war of 1914 to 1918)
- World War II (the war of 1939 to 1945)
Closing
Crabapple recovers a mass Jewish politics that bet on solidarity in the lands where Jews already lived, which Sam offers to Jews hungry for a relation to their history that “rejects the monopoly of the Zionists on those resources” .