Did Zionism go wrong, or was it wrong from the start? Benjamin Moser’s Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History answers with a gallery of Jews who opposed, or came to oppose, a Jewish state, and Moser comes to it from inside: raised a Reform Zionist in Houston, he says he would have called himself a liberal Zionist until his first trip to Palestine, in 2016 . With Matt Sitman and Sam Adler-Bell he reads his very different subjects as one lineage whose shared enemy, he says, is “the racial conception of Judaism” . The last half hour turns to a tough review that set his book beside Omer Bartov’s, and to the line Moser draws against it: in his words, Israel did not go wrong, “Israel was wrong” .
Key Topics
- Matt, raised in a fundamentalist Christianity that was “Christian Zionist, actually” , hears ex-evangelical language in Moser’s word “deconstruct” , and Moser likens Zionism to a grand hotel where “You can stay there forever unless you ask one question”: whether Israel has a right to exist .
- Moser presents Aaron Samuel Tamares, the Orthodox “sensitive rabbi” of a forest shtetl in eastern Poland , who in his telling saw the Zionists trying to turn a religious people “into just another ugly little quote-unquote nation” ; Sam describes the contempt of Herzl’s circle for the Jews of the Pale , and Moser the Zionist ideal of “muscle Jews” .
- Sam, drawing on Carl Schorske’s Fin-de-siècle Vienna, calls Herzl “a racial nationalist and a romantic” whose project was tied to European colonialism , and notes that Arab nationalism grew alongside it ; Moser calls that movement anti-colonial and Zionism “pro-colonial” .
- Moser tells the story of Jacob Israël de Haan, the Dutch gay poet who emigrated to Palestine in 1919 , came to sympathize with the Arabs and was shot leaving a synagogue by an assassin who, Sam says, was hired by the Haganah .
- After that week’s Israeli election, where Sam says the opposition will not govern with the Arab parties , Moser argues, with Maxime Rodinson on settler colonialism and Avi Shlaim on the archives , that “Zionism is not something that’s reformable” .
- In 1943 Congregation Beth Israel in Houston split over its board’s anti-Zionist principles, among them “Our race is Caucasian” , a fight Sam reads partly as respectability politics and Moser as “a very obvious class conflict” , before Sam argues that in America, unlike Iraq and Egypt, “The anti-Zionists were wrong about what would happen” .
- Moser argues that the “slightly coded” subject of Hannah Arendt’s Eichmann in Jerusalem was collaboration between certain Zionists and certain Nazis , and says the ADL asked every synagogue in America to denounce her from the pulpit on Yom Kippur .
- Moser says no British paper reviewed the book for a month and no London bookshop would host a launch ; of Isaac Chotiner’s review in The New Yorker, which Matt says reads even small errors as “a pattern” , Moser argues that the magazine is liberal Zionism summed up , a point Sam qualifies for some of its writers .
Notable Quotes
"I'm smuggling the intellectual history and the political history into these people's lives."Benjamin Moser, on writing biography, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 10:23
"Have we been suffering for 18 centuries just in order to catch up with Bulgaria?"the Chafetz Chaim, quoted by Benjamin Moser, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 31:59
"Germany no longer suffered as previous generations had from collective guilt. It suffered instead from collective guiltlessness."Benjamin Moser, read by Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:33:12
Outline
- 0:00:01 — Introducing the book
- 0:09:48 — Why biography
- 0:12:25 — October 7 and the origin of the book
- 0:15:36 — Leaving Zionism
- 0:20:44 — The food bank: liberal Zionism
- 0:23:44 — Feeling one’s way out: Palestine, 2016
- 0:28:52 — Aaron Samuel Tamares and the muscle Jews
- 0:39:32 — Herzl, race and colonialism
- 0:52:13 — Jacob Israël de Haan
- 0:57:43 — The Israeli election
- 01:02:13 — Hyman Judah Schachtel and Beth Israel
- 01:19:15 — Hannah Arendt and the Eichmann trial
- 01:29:48 — Reception, and Germany
- 01:35:17 — The New Yorker review
- 01:49:38 — Honor, hygiene and “September 1, 1939”
Mentioned Resources
People
- Benjamin Moser (American writer and biographer, author of Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, the episode’s guest)
- Aaron Samuel Tamares (Orthodox rabbi of a shtetl in eastern Poland and an early religious critic of Zionism)
- Adolf Eichmann (Nazi SS official who organized deportations in the Holocaust and was tried and executed in Israel)
- Ahdaf Soueif (Egyptian novelist and founder of the Palestine Festival of Literature)
- Avi Shlaim (Iraqi-born Israeli-British historian, one of Israel’s “new historians”)
- Bari Weiss (American journalist and editor, founder of The Free Press)
- Benjamin Netanyahu (Israel’s prime minister)
- Carl Schorske (American historian, author of Fin-de-siècle Vienna)
- David Ben-Gurion (Zionist leader and Israel’s first prime minister)
- David Remnick (editor of The New Yorker)
- Edmund White (American novelist, author of A Boy’s Own Story)
- Gore Vidal (American novelist and essayist)
- Hannah Arendt (German-American political theorist, author of Eichmann in Jerusalem)
- Hyman Judah Schachtel (Reform rabbi of Congregation Beth Israel in Houston)
- Isaac Chotiner (American journalist and staff writer at The New Yorker, best known for his interviews)
- Jacob Israël de Haan (Dutch poet, lawyer and journalist who emigrated to Palestine as a Zionist, turned against the movement and was assassinated)
- Jonathan Greenblatt (chief executive of the Anti-Defamation League)
- Maxime Rodinson (French Marxist historian and orientalist)
- Molly Crabapple (artist, journalist and activist, author of Here Where We Live Is Our Country)
- Nan Goldin (American photographer and activist)
- Omer Bartov (Israeli-American historian of the Holocaust and of genocide)
- Philip Roth (American novelist)
- Susan Sontag (American writer and critic, subject of Moser’s Pulitzer Prize-winning biography)
- Theodor Herzl (founder of political Zionism)
- Vladimir Lenin (Bolshevik leader)
- W. H. Auden (English-American poet)
Organizations
- Brit Shalom (Zionist group of the 1920s and 1930s that advocated a binational state in Palestine)
- Congregation Beth Israel (Reform synagogue in Houston, the oldest in Texas, which split over Zionism in 1943)
- Equator (online magazine where Moser published an essay on American Jews and Israel)
- General Jewish Labour Bund (secular Jewish socialist party founded in Vilna in 1897)
- Haganah (Zionist paramilitary organization in Mandate Palestine)
- Palestine Festival of Literature (annual literary festival held in Palestine)
- The New Yorker (American weekly magazine)
Places
- Germany (the country of the “collective guiltlessness” described in Moser’s Nan Goldin chapter)
- Houston (Texas city where Moser grew up)
- Iraq (home of a Jewish community older than Islam)
- Israel (the state founded in 1948)
- Lower East Side (Manhattan neighborhood at the center of Jewish immigrant life around the turn of the 20th century)
- New York City (center of American Jewish life)
- Pale of Settlement (western provinces of the Russian Empire to which Jews were legally confined)
- Palestine (the land the Zionist movement set out to settle)
- Poland (country of Tamares’s shtetl)
- Russian Empire (empire of the Romanov tsars)
Works
- Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History (Moser’s 2026 book of twelve biographical portraits of Jews who opposed, or came to oppose, a Jewish state)
- A Boy’s Own Story (Edmund White’s 1982 coming-of-age novel)
- Eichmann in Jerusalem (Hannah Arendt’s 1963 report on the trial of Adolf Eichmann)
- Fin-de-siècle Vienna (Carl Schorske’s 1980 study of politics and culture in late 19th-century Vienna)
- Is Zionism’s Moral Crisis About Roads Not Taken or Original Sin? (Isaac Chotiner’s review of Moser’s book in The New Yorker)
- Israel: What Went Wrong? (Omer Bartov’s book on Israel’s history and the war in Gaza)
- Mad Men (American television drama about a 1960s New York advertising agency)
- Operation Shylock (Philip Roth’s 1993 novel)
- September 1, 1939 (W. H. Auden’s poem written at the outbreak of the Second World War)
- Sontag: Her Life and Work (Moser’s 2019 biography of Susan Sontag, which won the Pulitzer Prize)
- The Jews in Their Land (illustrated book on Jewish history in the Land of Israel, once common in American Jewish homes)
- The World After Gaza (Pankaj Mishra’s 2025 book on the war in Gaza and the memory of the Holocaust)
- Why This World (Moser’s 2009 biography of the Brazilian writer Clarice Lispector)
Concepts
- Anti-Zionism (opposition to Zionism and to a Jewish state)
- Antisemitism (hostility to Jews)
- Arab Nationalism (movement for Arab self-determination and independence from foreign rule)
- Banality of Evil (Arendt’s phrase for the unremarkable, bureaucratic character of Eichmann’s evil)
- Christian Zionism (Christian support for a Jewish state, often on eschatological grounds)
- Conscious Pariah (Arendt’s term for the Jew who chooses to stand outside society’s power)
- Dual Loyalty (the charge that Jews owe allegiance to another nation)
- Liberal Zionism (support for Israel as a Jewish state combined with liberal criticism of its policies)
- Liberalism (the tradition of individual liberty and constitutional government)
- Muscle Jews (the ideal of a physically strong and martial Jew, set against the supposed weakness of the diaspora)
- Ostjuden (German term for the Jews of Eastern Europe, often used with contempt)
- Pogrom (organized attack on a Jewish community)
- Reform Judaism (liberal Jewish movement that sought to reconcile Judaism with Enlightenment universalism)
- Settler Colonialism (colonialism in which settlers replace or displace a native population)
- Yiddish (language of Eastern European Jews)
- Zionism (movement for a Jewish state in Palestine)
Events
- Eichmann Trial (1961 trial of Adolf Eichmann in Jerusalem)
- October 7 Attack (Hamas-led attack on Israel of October 7, 2023)
- The Holocaust (Nazi genocide of European Jews)
- War in Gaza (Israel’s war in Gaza following the October 7 attack)
- World War I (war of 1914 to 1918)
- World War II (war of 1939 to 1945)
Closing
It airs a Jewish dissent from Zionism that, as Matt puts it, has not had its due, and lets Moser make and defend his case in his own words.
← The Bund: Fighting Fascism, Fighting Zionism (w/ Molly Crabapple) · KYE Live: Neocons, the Far Center, and the Politics of Jewish Reaction (w/ Andrea Long Chu & David Klion) →