Did Zionism go wrong, or was it wrong from the start? Benjamin Moser’s Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History answers with a gallery of Jews who opposed, or came to oppose, a Jewish state, and Moser comes to it from inside: raised a Reform Zionist in Houston, he says he would have called himself a liberal Zionist until his first trip to Palestine, in 2016 . With Matt Sitman and Sam Adler-Bell he reads his very different subjects as one lineage whose shared enemy, he says, is “the racial conception of Judaism” . The last half hour turns to a tough review that set his book beside Omer Bartov’s, and to the line Moser draws against it: in his words, Israel did not go wrong, “Israel was wrong” .

Key Topics

  • Matt, raised in a fundamentalist Christianity that was “Christian Zionist, actually” , hears ex-evangelical language in Moser’s word “deconstruct” , and Moser likens Zionism to a grand hotel where “You can stay there forever unless you ask one question”: whether Israel has a right to exist .
  • Moser presents Aaron Samuel Tamares, the Orthodox “sensitive rabbi” of a forest shtetl in eastern Poland , who in his telling saw the Zionists trying to turn a religious people “into just another ugly little quote-unquote nation” ; Sam describes the contempt of Herzl’s circle for the Jews of the Pale , and Moser the Zionist ideal of “muscle Jews” .
  • Sam, drawing on Carl Schorske’s Fin-de-siècle Vienna, calls Herzl “a racial nationalist and a romantic” whose project was tied to European colonialism , and notes that Arab nationalism grew alongside it ; Moser calls that movement anti-colonial and Zionism “pro-colonial” .
  • Moser tells the story of Jacob Israël de Haan, the Dutch gay poet who emigrated to Palestine in 1919 , came to sympathize with the Arabs and was shot leaving a synagogue by an assassin who, Sam says, was hired by the Haganah .
  • After that week’s Israeli election, where Sam says the opposition will not govern with the Arab parties , Moser argues, with Maxime Rodinson on settler colonialism and Avi Shlaim on the archives , that “Zionism is not something that’s reformable” .
  • In 1943 Congregation Beth Israel in Houston split over its board’s anti-Zionist principles, among them “Our race is Caucasian” , a fight Sam reads partly as respectability politics and Moser as “a very obvious class conflict” , before Sam argues that in America, unlike Iraq and Egypt, “The anti-Zionists were wrong about what would happen” .
  • Moser argues that the “slightly coded” subject of Hannah Arendt’s Eichmann in Jerusalem was collaboration between certain Zionists and certain Nazis , and says the ADL asked every synagogue in America to denounce her from the pulpit on Yom Kippur .
  • Moser says no British paper reviewed the book for a month and no London bookshop would host a launch ; of Isaac Chotiner’s review in The New Yorker, which Matt says reads even small errors as “a pattern” , Moser argues that the magazine is liberal Zionism summed up , a point Sam qualifies for some of its writers .

Notable Quotes

"I'm smuggling the intellectual history and the political history into these people's lives."
Benjamin Moser, on writing biographyasserted#
Benjamin Moser, on writing biography, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 10:23
"Have we been suffering for 18 centuries just in order to catch up with Bulgaria?"
the Chafetz Chaim, quoted by Benjamin Moserreported#
the Chafetz Chaim, quoted by Benjamin Moser, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 31:59
"Germany no longer suffered as previous generations had from collective guilt. It suffered instead from collective guiltlessness."
Benjamin Moser, read by Sam Adler-Bellreported#
Benjamin Moser, read by Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:33:12

Outline

  • 0:00:01 — Introducing the book
  • 0:09:48 — Why biography
  • 0:12:25 — October 7 and the origin of the book
  • 0:15:36 — Leaving Zionism
  • 0:20:44 — The food bank: liberal Zionism
  • 0:23:44 — Feeling one’s way out: Palestine, 2016
  • 0:28:52 — Aaron Samuel Tamares and the muscle Jews
  • 0:39:32 — Herzl, race and colonialism
  • 0:52:13 — Jacob Israël de Haan
  • 0:57:43 — The Israeli election
  • 01:02:13 — Hyman Judah Schachtel and Beth Israel
  • 01:19:15 — Hannah Arendt and the Eichmann trial
  • 01:29:48 — Reception, and Germany
  • 01:35:17 — The New Yorker review
  • 01:49:38 — Honor, hygiene and “September 1, 1939”

Mentioned Resources

People

Organizations

  • Brit Shalom (Zionist group of the 1920s and 1930s that advocated a binational state in Palestine)
  • Congregation Beth Israel (Reform synagogue in Houston, the oldest in Texas, which split over Zionism in 1943)
  • Equator (online magazine where Moser published an essay on American Jews and Israel)
  • General Jewish Labour Bund (secular Jewish socialist party founded in Vilna in 1897)
  • Haganah (Zionist paramilitary organization in Mandate Palestine)
  • Palestine Festival of Literature (annual literary festival held in Palestine)
  • The New Yorker (American weekly magazine)

Places

  • Germany (the country of the “collective guiltlessness” described in Moser’s Nan Goldin chapter)
  • Houston (Texas city where Moser grew up)
  • Iraq (home of a Jewish community older than Islam)
  • Israel (the state founded in 1948)
  • Lower East Side (Manhattan neighborhood at the center of Jewish immigrant life around the turn of the 20th century)
  • New York City (center of American Jewish life)
  • Pale of Settlement (western provinces of the Russian Empire to which Jews were legally confined)
  • Palestine (the land the Zionist movement set out to settle)
  • Poland (country of Tamares’s shtetl)
  • Russian Empire (empire of the Romanov tsars)

Works

  • Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History (Moser’s 2026 book of twelve biographical portraits of Jews who opposed, or came to oppose, a Jewish state)
  • A Boy’s Own Story (Edmund White’s 1982 coming-of-age novel)
  • Eichmann in Jerusalem (Hannah Arendt’s 1963 report on the trial of Adolf Eichmann)
  • Fin-de-siècle Vienna (Carl Schorske’s 1980 study of politics and culture in late 19th-century Vienna)
  • Is Zionism’s Moral Crisis About Roads Not Taken or Original Sin? (Isaac Chotiner’s review of Moser’s book in The New Yorker)
  • Israel: What Went Wrong? (Omer Bartov’s book on Israel’s history and the war in Gaza)
  • Mad Men (American television drama about a 1960s New York advertising agency)
  • Operation Shylock (Philip Roth’s 1993 novel)
  • September 1, 1939 (W. H. Auden’s poem written at the outbreak of the Second World War)
  • Sontag: Her Life and Work (Moser’s 2019 biography of Susan Sontag, which won the Pulitzer Prize)
  • The Jews in Their Land (illustrated book on Jewish history in the Land of Israel, once common in American Jewish homes)
  • The World After Gaza (Pankaj Mishra’s 2025 book on the war in Gaza and the memory of the Holocaust)
  • Why This World (Moser’s 2009 biography of the Brazilian writer Clarice Lispector)

Concepts

  • Anti-Zionism (opposition to Zionism and to a Jewish state)
  • Antisemitism (hostility to Jews)
  • Arab Nationalism (movement for Arab self-determination and independence from foreign rule)
  • Banality of Evil (Arendt’s phrase for the unremarkable, bureaucratic character of Eichmann’s evil)
  • Christian Zionism (Christian support for a Jewish state, often on eschatological grounds)
  • Conscious Pariah (Arendt’s term for the Jew who chooses to stand outside society’s power)
  • Dual Loyalty (the charge that Jews owe allegiance to another nation)
  • Liberal Zionism (support for Israel as a Jewish state combined with liberal criticism of its policies)
  • Liberalism (the tradition of individual liberty and constitutional government)
  • Muscle Jews (the ideal of a physically strong and martial Jew, set against the supposed weakness of the diaspora)
  • Ostjuden (German term for the Jews of Eastern Europe, often used with contempt)
  • Pogrom (organized attack on a Jewish community)
  • Reform Judaism (liberal Jewish movement that sought to reconcile Judaism with Enlightenment universalism)
  • Settler Colonialism (colonialism in which settlers replace or displace a native population)
  • Yiddish (language of Eastern European Jews)
  • Zionism (movement for a Jewish state in Palestine)

Events

Closing

It airs a Jewish dissent from Zionism that, as Matt puts it, has not had its due, and lets Moser make and defend his case in his own words.


← The Bund: Fighting Fascism, Fighting Zionism (w/ Molly Crabapple) · KYE Live: Neocons, the Far Center, and the Politics of Jewish Reaction (w/ Andrea Long Chu & David Klion) →