Colonialism in which settlers replace or displace a native population. In episode 01 Sam uses the term in passing to describe Zionism, against the Bund's socialist internationalism. In episode 02 it does more work: Benjamin Moser traces Zionism's early description of itself as colonial, sets it against the anti-colonial Arab nationalism of the same years, and, drawing on Maxime Rodinson, uses the theory of settler colonies to explain why Israel will not govern with its Arab citizens' parties. Start at about 49 minutes in episode 02.
Across the episodes
Appears as a ready description of Zionism, set against the Bund's internationalism without needing explanation
In the Bund episode the term is already Sam's shorthand for the Zionist side, used to reject the claim that the Holocaust settled the argument with the Bund.
Sam, having just read Henryk Erlich's 1933 warnings about Jewish nationalism, arguing to Molly Crabapple that the Bundists were right.
"the sort of long debate between internationalist socialists like the Bundists and Zionist settler colonialists, that's bullshit for the reasons you've described."Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 1:21:00
Becomes an explanatory theory, traced from Zionism's own early colonial vocabulary to a structural law that, on Moser's account, rules out reform
Moser's evidence that the colonial label was Zionism's own before it was its critics', and that the movement only later began to call itself indigenous.
"Zionism starts out as an explicitly racial, colonial, imperial ideology. You know, there's this famous letter that Herzl writes to Cecil Rhodes and says, well, you know, we're also colonists."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 49:14
Moser explains the bitterness of the conflict by timing: a settler project arrived just as the Arab world hoped to throw off colonial rule.
Answering Sam's point that Arab and Jewish nationalism grew up at the same time.
"Zionism was pro-colonial and it was about moving. people out of Europe into a non-white part of the world. And that's why the clash is so bitter, because Zionism creates a settler colony in the heart of the Arab world."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 51:32
The theory is brought in to answer a practical question raised by the Israeli election: why the opposition will not form a government with the Arab parties.
"But the theory of settler colonialism that I think, you know, Rodinson is the one who really articulates this in my book,"Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:00:23
Moser generalizes from comparison: a structural law, not a policy choice, which is why he argues that Zionism cannot be reformed.
"They actually are acting out a pretty ironclad law of settler colonies that you can see in comparative perspectives. Racism and nationalism always triumph."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:00:47
Connections
Sam sets the Bund's internationalist socialists against the Zionist settler colonialists.
Moser says Zionism creates a settler colony in the heart of the Arab world.
Moser contrasts anti-colonial Arab nationalism with pro-colonial Zionism.
Moser cites Herzl's letter to Cecil Rhodes: we're also colonists.
Moser credits Rodinson with articulating the theory in his book.