Point at a sentence to see when it was said, and click the time to listen from there.Tap a sentence to see when it was said, and tap the time to listen from there.

Matthew Sitman

All right.

Introducing the book

Matthew Sitman

Welcome, listeners, to episode 147 of Know Your Enemy. I'm Matt Sitman, your podcast co-host, and I'm here as always with my great friend, Sam Adler-Bell. Hello, Samuel.

Sam Adler-Bell

Hi, Matt.

Matthew Sitman

Well, we do not want to delay with this intro, but this episode, it'll probably be at least a little controversial. We had on our friend Benjamin Moser, Ben, who is the author of a book that came out recently, Anti-Zionism, a Jewish History. And we had a long conversation with him about it. It was just a bracing conversation. This book we read that Ben wrote, it was material I had never encountered before. And that meant it was tricky to talk about in the sense of, this is a little out of at least my comfort zone, but it was a kind of thrilling book to read in a sense. It was so provocative and polemical at points, but deeply researched in multiple languages. And Ben is just a brilliant guy.

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, yeah, luckily, this is not out of my comfort zone. It's almost my happy. place to be talking about Jewish Zionism and the history of Israel. But this book that Ben's written is, it's a series of 12 biographical sketches of Jewish anti-Zionists. Not all of them started out as anti-Zionists. Many of them started out with quite a lot of enthusiasm for the Zionist project, but all of them ended up in a place of profound discomfort, disdain, contempt moral aversion to Israel and the colonial enterprise of Israel.

Matthew Sitman

Some religious, some not. It's very different kinds of people in very different times and places.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah, some communists, some Jews from the Arab world, some Jews from Europe. And so you get a kind of full spectrum version of the side of the story of Israel, which is the dark side of the story. And I think Ben did a really great job with it. As listeners may know, Ben Moser's also the Pulitzer Prize winning author of his Susan Sontag biography.

Matthew Sitman

Sontag, her life and times.

Sam Adler-Bell

And he also wrote a very compelling biography of the writer Clarice Lispector.

Matthew Sitman

Why This World, a biography of Clarice Lispector. So Ben is a biographer in many ways, and that comes through in the form of the book.

Sam Adler-Bell

And there's so much in this book that we didn't even get to talk about, even though we talked to Ben for so long. You know, I mean, one thing that I wish we had you gotten to discuss a little bit more is the phenomenon of sort of internal critics of Zionism, which didn't really come up because there really were Zionists who put the Arab question at the center of their critiques from the beginning and advocated for a binational state with equal rights for Jews and non-Jews. That didn't really come up. So for those of you listeners who are thinking about Brit Shalom and the kind of cultural Zionists, that's not in this conversation, but that's because there's too much to discuss when it comes to the history of Zionism.

Matthew Sitman

Yes. And there's one chapter that we didn't get to discuss. The destruction of the Jewish community in Iraq that had gone back thousands of years.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah.

Matthew Sitman

That essentially, you know, within years, a couple of decades, you know, at the most, essentially destroyed, no longer extant. I mean, the destruction of religious communities that existed for, we're talking like BC, you know, a thousand years before Islam was founded. Right. This Jewish community existed in Iraq. and the testimony of someone who left there when he was young, him and his Jewish family.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah. And became himself a Israeli historian of Zionism and did incredible work undermining some of the foundational myths of Zionism. Anyway, I mean, this book is full of those kinds of stories. Ben, as listeners will hear, has a very strong moral aversion to the whole project. And I suspect there's probably some listeners who will find that position overly strident. But I will say here that the book he's written comes with receipts. And if you do read it, I think you'll find that that stridency is justified.

Matthew Sitman

Yes. And this, I think, will come through in the conversation, too. This is a book that, at the very least, even if you disagree strenuously with where Ben and more or less Sam and I land at the end of this, this is a side of the story worth airing. And it has not received the airing I think it is due. And so that's one reason we wanted to have a long conversation with him about it. This book has not been reviewed as extensively as it should. It doesn't mean it's not popular. People are buying it and reading it. But it's kind of been officially erased from the discourse in some ways.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, yeah. And for listeners who may have read some of the tough reviews that it did get in certain outlets, we do talk to Ben about one review in particular. which was very tough and produced some controversy. And if you want to know how Ben Moser feels about his review in The New Yorker, you will hear it. You will hear it and then some in this conversation.

Matthew Sitman

Yes, but I was proud to have Ben on and proud to put out this conversation. Agree or disagree with it? Well, shall we get some housekeeping items?

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah.

Matthew Sitman

As always, we're grateful to our partners at Dissent. They sponsor the podcast. And one thing that means is if you subscribe to Know Your Enemy on our Patreon at Patreon. com slash Know Your Enemy for ten dollars a month you not only get access to all of our bonus episodes in the Know Your Enemy discord but you get access to a free digital subscription to descent so please consider subscribing and getting access to all of it but of course if you just won the bonus episodes you can also subscribe at our Patreon for five dollars a month and get all of those and i think uh the next uh one of those will do it will be our what the hell happened with these midterms. Yeah. So the rankest of all rank fundatory, midterm discourse. I mean, I'm anxiously awaiting the results and it might not be the most important election in our lifetime. It feels pretty important. Given just how deranged and degraded Trump seems right now and the kind of flailing of his administration, this will be really important to how that plays out. So subscribe if you want to hear that conversation and many others.

Sam Adler-Bell

Profound implications for the future of the MAGA movement and American conservatism. So yeah, we will be talking about that.

Matthew Sitman

And we'll find out what the American people really think about all this talk about guys' asses.

Sam Adler-Bell

I think that's the best thing he's doing on the trail.

Matthew Sitman

That's why he's leaning into it. What's like talking about some guy's ass is better than Iran or inflation.

Sam Adler-Bell

America is much, much more gay than is regularly acknowledged by the conservative movement. Well, as always, we want to thank our intrepid producer. Jesse Brenneman, who did a great job putting this episode together, this very long, complicated episode. And Will Epstein, who does the music for the show.

Matthew Sitman

All right. Well, shall we get to it?

Sam Adler-Bell

Yes.

Matthew Sitman

Here's our conversation with Benjamin Moser about his provocative new book, Anti-Zionism, A Jewish History. Enjoy. All right, let's get started. We are very, very pleased to welcome to the Know Your Enemy podcast, our friend, Benjamin Moser. Hello, Ben.

Benjamin Moser

Hi there.

Matthew Sitman

Where are you calling in from, so to speak?

Benjamin Moser

I'm calling in from a hotel room in London.

Matthew Sitman

Are you prone?

Benjamin Moser

I am in prone position. I'm in a very, very comfortable bed. Crisp white sheets with a high thread count.

Matthew Sitman

You don't write in bed, do you? Like Walker Percy, one of my favorites. There are these great photos of him with notebooks and pencils lying in bed lounging, writing his novels.

Benjamin Moser

No, I do not. I'm just on this very long book tour. So anything I can do without having to get out of my hotel or my bed, I'm very happy to do.

Matthew Sitman

Well, we're honored by that, Ben. Thank you for that vote of confidence. It means I'm very comfortable with you guys. Well, since, Ben, you mentioned you're on your book tour, we are here to discuss your controversial, brilliant, I found just a read that was... Bracing is one of the words that comes to mind. Your new book, Anti-Zionism, A Jewish History, it came out when?

Benjamin Moser

September 22nd.

Matthew Sitman

A little over a month old, and you finally are making time for us here on Know Your Enemy. This is the real conversation. This is the one I'm sure you've been excited for the whole time.

Benjamin Moser

I have. I have. Ever since we had that wonderful dinner last year, I've wanted to do this.

Sam Adler-Bell

I wasn't at this dinner. I wasn't invited to this dinner, which I am holding against you both. But Ben, we met at the home of Know Your Enemy, friend of the show, and a mutual friend of all of ours.

Benjamin Moser

Jasper Nathaniel, who has just been beaten up in Palestine.

Sam Adler-Bell

Again, that's what is always happening to Jasper. You know, I was thinking, you know, it's a month out from your book coming out, but right now is a very appropriate time to be having this conversation for several reasons. One, there were elections in Israel on Tuesday, so two days ago, which I actually want to talk about a little bit. But. There were also elections in Brazil where the result was much more encouraging. And you also have a connection to... Brazil, because of your first biography, which I love so much, the Clarice Lispector book.

Benjamin Moser

That's true. And don't forget, there was another election the same day in another country I have a connection to from another book, which is Serbia, which was very connected to my book on Susan Sontag.

Sam Adler-Bell

Wow, I didn't put that together. I was trying to get the Sontag connection in here, but that is it.

Benjamin Moser

I'm there ahead of you. And it was a great day in a time where we've really needed some great days. We've really needed some encouragement.

Matthew Sitman

That is wild that all three of your books have some kind of relationship to these three elections we just mentioned. Ben, we're just going to get right into your book here because we have so much to discuss.

Why biography

Matthew Sitman

Your book, Anti-Zionism, A Jewish History, it is organized essentially with biographical chapters. You start with an introduction that's autobiographical, but you also talk about Theodor Herzl and then Aaron Samuel Tamares, Edwin Montagu, Hannah Arendt is on this list. And to start off, I just wanted to ask you how you arrived at this particular form for the book, why it took this shape of biographical sketches. Of course, there's more than biographical sketches. There's a lot of intellectual political history here.

Benjamin Moser

Well, that's the answer, what you just said. I'm smuggling the intellectual history and the political history into these people's lives, which is actually, you mentioned my books on Sontag, for example. That's a book that's basically about metaphor. But if you say this book is basically about metaphor, nobody's going to read it. Those books are actually all about different forms of intellectual history and about ideas. And the thing that's interesting about ideas for me is that ideas are not just ideas. They're not abstractions. They have real life and death results in our lives.

Sam Adler-Bell

As we say on the right, Ideas have consequences.

Benjamin Moser

This is true, but this is true. And I think that the more you can dress them in mortal flesh, the more compelling they become. And I think people are just naturally attracted to reading about other people, interesting people. I certainly am. And so I think I just wanted to show that Zionism is not an idea. It's a thing that actually kills people and that breaks people's bones. So that's just the format. I like reading about people. I like learning about people. I like interviewing people, actually. So I like anything that lets me go to Cairo and talk to a bunch of old communists. That's fun for me.

Matthew Sitman

And it helps you understand the ideas, I'd wager, right? Like where they came from, how they developed, what someone thought before, and then what they maybe thought after. We love doing biographical episodes on this podcast precisely for that reason. And I think it's one reason. your book appealed to me, that format. It does kind of, not to try it out of cliche, but it does bring the ideas to life. And I was wondering too, when you started working on this, because I counted what, 11 languages you did research in, the bibliography, there's a lot of intellectual work that went into this that I want to underscore here at the start.

Sam Adler-Bell

Not to mention the interviews. I mean, the interviews with the children of some of these anti-Zionists that you write about, it must have taken a lot of work.

October 7 and the origin of the book

Benjamin Moser

Yeah, the origin story... is I've always wanted to write about Palestine, always. And I've always thought, how do you write about Palestine in a way that's new and original that people don't know? This is like the most over-covered square inches of the whole world. So how do you contribute something that's new? How do you make a book that's going to not only be a history or an intellectual journey, but also something that I would hope would actually contribute? to the cause of a free Palestine, which is so dear to my heart. So on October 7th, you know, I was in the middle of another book, but I thought I've got to do it now because immediately on October 7th, if you know Israel and you know Zionism, you knew exactly what they were going to do. Everyone knew. I don't think I knew that it was going to be this depraved and this horrific, but I did know something depraved and horrific was about to happen. So I started thinking about you anti-Zionist Jews, because I think that if you are in the Palestinian movement, particularly in the Jewish Palestinian movement, whatever you want to call it, whether it's JVP, whether it's the encampments, whether it's any Palestine meeting with three people in a basement, you know that lots of these people are Jewish who are involved in this.

And you know that they always have been. And you learn through this kind of solidarity work, whether it's promoting BDS or whether it's trying to get different articles in the media or whether it's trying to help a family in Palestine, you know, get their child medical service or whatever. You just know this and then you learn from the elders and the movement. Someone will say, oh, you know, so-and-so is also anti-Zionist, some Jewish figure from the past that you might not have known that about them. And then I think just as Jews always kind of know who's Jewish. Jewish anti-Zionists definitely know who's an anti-Zionist.

Sam Adler-Bell

Right? That is true. There's an enormous amount of effort also put into convincing young Jews that every Jew is a Zionist. And if they're not, there's something wrong with them. And so part of what happens when you get involved in this sort of activism is that these kinds of historical figures who had these insights at different times become these kind of ports in a storm for... I think, young Jewish anti-Zionist.

Benjamin Moser

I always compare this to gay kids kind of thinking I'm the only lesbian in eighth grade. And then you think everybody's going to hate me. I'm going to come out of the closet and I'm not going to have any friends left and my family's going to hate me. And, you know, in some cases, unfortunately, that's true. But then once you do come out of the closet, you realize, oh, actually, like the people that don't reject me are actually the cooler people. But you have to get there. And it's a kind of stepping out of the expectations of your community, of your family, of your school. I mean, it's different for everybody because not everybody grows up in a heavily Zionism environment. But I certainly did. And mine was light compared to some people. You know, I didn't go to Jewish school. I was like very kind of middle class American reform. But we were Zionists. Everybody was Zionist as far as I knew.

Leaving Zionism

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, you have this great motif in the first chapter of the Ibsen horror. the narrative, which appears in Ibsen's plays, but not only there, of a kind of journalist or relative, some admirer who resolves to compose a warm homage, but in the course of his research discovers a hideous, unpunished crime. And there's a sense in which that is a fear and anxiety and a tendency of the biographer, which you are, but it's also, I think, a position that many Jews find themselves in when they start to find out what Israel really is about.

Benjamin Moser

Yeah, you lift up the rock and you see the vermin beneath. And there's something really dark about that moment, I think. And I think everybody in my book has this moment. And I think everybody I know and the people that I speak to all the time and that write me every day, they all tell me about this moment. Because I think it's quite emotionally wrenching to realize not only that it's wrong. I mean, I would say it's not like... Coming from a family of Republicans and then realizing, well, actually, I'm pro-choice and I think that everybody should have universal health care. It's much more emotionally wrenching than that. And it's really horrifying. And it really, in a strange way, makes you question everything about your education, about your family.

Matthew Sitman

Ben, that is so interesting to me because I am someone who grew up in a Republican house and is now. pro-choice, embolize everyone, should have universal health care. And I have rejected the fundamentalist Christianity I grew up with, which was Christian Zionist, actually. Like, we are three people who were raised Zionist here in a strange way. And I can say one of the words you used in that autobiographical introduction to your book was deconstruct. And it really caught my eye. I mean, deconstructing your Zionism, the kind of inherited beliefs, because that is a word a lot of ex-conservative evangelicals use. They're deconstructing their evangelicalism. And I wanted to ask you to describe the experience of becoming anti-Zionist, because I've found leaving the worlds that I did, changing my mind the way I did, there are moments where you question everything, because it's like your sense of stable reality is upended, the world you thought you knew, the kind of morality you thought you were adhering to or believed in. When those things go up, it is disorienting, and it does make you kind of question, am I the one who's wrong here?

Benjamin Moser

Well, I like that you... call attention to the word deconstruction because Zionism is this vast edifice. It is a building, and it's a building built out of bullshit. It's something that is not built on any foundation besides racism and nationalism. But if you look at it from the outside, if you've always inhabited it, it looks quite comfortable. And in fact, I use the metaphor, it's like a great hotel. where there's a good concierge and the room service gets there right on time and the heating is perfect, you know, there's no draft coming in, there's no beeping lights on the TV, everything is very comfortable.

You can stay there forever unless you ask one question. And the question in this case is, does Israel have a right to exist? That's what gets the call to security and gets you kicked out of the comfortable hotel. And I think that nobody really wants that. I think people want to be challenged. They want to grow. They want to learn. But they really don't want to be kicked out of the hotel. And so I still feel a kind of nostalgia for Zionism. I remember this book that I write about there as well. It was called The Jews in Their Land.

Sam Adler-Bell

I recognize this book.

Benjamin Moser

I think every Jewish grandmother had this book in their living room. And I can look at that and I can think, I would love to go back to where I would be able to look at even that title, The Jews in Their Land, and be able to feel the sort of pride and the kind of... security that that offered. But this is why I say, you know, you grow up, you put aside childless things. And I quote that as I said, a Jewish writer said that. Matt, you probably know who the Jewish writer was. Yes. I'm kind of trolling.

Sam Adler-Bell

That's not a reference that gets missed by friends of Matt Sitman or people who talk to him for several hours every week.

Benjamin Moser

Well, but a lot of Zionism is about sort of allusions to religious figures, religious names that come out of our tradition as Jews. but also as Christians, that presume ignorance, right? They presume you think that the state of Israel founded in 1948 is the same thing as the Israel in the Bible, or the Israel in the prayers. And they do this quite a lot. So I'm sort of making fun of the ignorance that is required to sustain this imposter.

The food bank: liberal Zionism

Sam Adler-Bell

You know, there's another metaphor that you've used that I thought is a little bit more ambiguous, but in some ways even more... attractive to me for that reason, which is in your Equator piece from, when was that from?

Benjamin Moser

It was from exactly a year ago today, because today is the first anniversary of the founding of Equator.

Sam Adler-Bell

Okay. Yes. Well, I love that piece. And one of the things you say in describing the way that your family related to Israel and therefore the way you did is this passage. Israel was like a hospital or a university or a park. And I think that most Jewish Americans looked at Israel with the same kind of benevolence with which they might view a dog shelter or a food bank, which is to say that they were happy it existed, willing to help, grateful for a brief tour, but not overly interested in its inner workings. And I do think not only the fact of the benevolence, but also of the kind of normalcy and lack of curiosity. I think that's also one of the things that preserves. the edifice of liberal Zionism in particular, because it exists in our cultural, emotional, and religious architecture in an unimposing way. I mean, that's not true anymore at all. But I think that there have been times in my life where it seemed that the Jews around me, in America in particular, relating to Israel is just like, you know, one of those good things that's out there. I'm not going to move there. I might visit, but it's just kind of just this natural, comforting fact. in the world.

Benjamin Moser

Well, this is true. And I think this is what, for the younger folks out there listening to us, this makes me feel like I'm 9,000 years old.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yes, I bet younger listeners are thinking, how could you possibly have regarded Israel in that way?

Benjamin Moser

And yet, this is one of the things that this is why I start off with this description of universal Zionism. And I always emphasize it wasn't just Jews. So Matt, when you say that Christian fundamentalists were obsessed with Zionism. They loved Zionism. I always point out there's more members of Christian Zionist organizations in the United States alone, 40 million, than there are Jews in the entire world. There's only 15 million Jews in the world. So this is a story that was very appealing to a lot of people. It didn't seem controversial in that way. What I do emphasize is that Israel was controversial. Israel did all sorts of things that were very unappealing and quite brutal, and we did know about them. And we didn't like them. But as Americans, and I think this applies to any other country as well, we saw our own country doing all sorts of horrible stuff, but didn't mean that we thought America should go away. You know, it was just like, we didn't want Ronald Reagan to be president or George Bush to be president. And that's a very different thing. So when I talk about my journey from liberal Zionism to anti-Zionism, I really, I think that's a big leap. And I think it's a leaped at a lot of people. have a hard time making and some never do and never will but everybody in my book as a journey like that.

Feeling one’s way out: Palestine, 2016

Matthew Sitman

Ben, in your journey, I was thinking about this just a few moments ago when you mentioned coming out as gay. I've often said that I feel like I'm part of the last generation that might have read their way out of the closet. You know, you encounter Edmund White, or you encounter Gore Vidal.

Benjamin Moser

Oscar Wilde.

Matthew Sitman

Oscar Wilde. I mean, I do remember feeling so ashamed of A Boy's Own Story when I bought it at a Barnes & Noble, Ed's great coming out novel. But I was wondering if you had a similar experience reading any of the figures in this book, before we maybe talk about some of them more specifically, you know, that experience of reading your way out of liberal Zionism.

Benjamin Moser

Oh, it's different. I think it's, I felt my way out of liberal Zionism. Because intellectually, I did understand from a pretty young age, I understood the Palestinian argument. I understood that injustice had been done to them. I might have thought that the injustice was inevitable. I might have thought that it was ancient history. I might have thought. we were on our way to solving this problem, as we were always told in my childhood and youth, there was this peace process. There was this negotiation. There was Oslo. There was Madrid. There was this. There was that. So I think I was able to think, well, okay, well, this isn't fair. This isn't great. But so are so many other things. And we were from a progressive time. Another thing that makes me feel like I'm 9,000 years old. We didn't think the planet was going to burn next summer. specifically.

Sam Adler-Bell

We were capable of convincing ourselves that things might get better.

Benjamin Moser

But things had gotten better. This is something I really do like to emphasize, that if you're a middle-class American, as I was, all these things were happening that sort of made you think. All this injustice in the world is going away. The Soviet Union goes away. South Africa goes away. The dictatorships in Latin America go away. Northern Ireland went away. All this stuff went away. And the whole time we were hearing about the peace process, and we thought, well, you know, okay, it's bad, but it doesn't mean it's always going to be bad. And we've seen other things happen that were really positive. So it wasn't just Pollyanna, you know, it was really our historical experience, which I feel like Agamemnon. I mean, just so old to say this, that the world felt like it was getting better, but it was. And so when I say I felt my way out of that, Bye. intellectually understood that there had been this injustice. But until I actually saw the injustice, and this was way after this period of progress had ended, when I went to Palestine for the first time and actually saw it from the Palestinian perspective and not from the Jewish perspective, I was so appalled. And the other night, one of the things I'm here in London for was to do an event at the School of Oriental and African Studies here at the University of London with Ahdaf Soueif, who's the great Egyptian writer.

And who was the founder of PalFest, the Palestine Festival of Literature. She's the one who took me with PalFest to Palestine on this journey. And this was 2016, so I'm 40 by that point. That's quite late, actually. And I say in the book that I look weird in these pictures.

Sam Adler-Bell

You sort of suggest that the internal process is reflected on your outward appearance. What's happening to you emotionally and psychologically is visible in the way your face and your body looks.

Benjamin Moser

I look insane in these pictures. My hair is terrible. My clothes look weird. I'm kind of bloated. And I didn't know this at the time. You know, I saw it in retrospect. And as I was talking about this the other night with Ahdaf, she noticed that too. She noticed after she saw me looking more normal that something had happened to me in Palestine. And it did. And so that's why I say I felt my way out of it. I felt like I just can't. believe what I'm seeing.

Matthew Sitman

Would you have called yourself some kind of liberal Zionist up until that point, however attenuated?

Benjamin Moser

Yeah. Although even after, I think that Zionism was so in my mitochondria that I have seen things I've written. So in my Susan Sontag biographies, for example, I used Zionistic language that I wouldn't use now. But no, I think it was just, I felt stunned by it. One thing I always emphasize is you can't imagine how horrible it is until you've seen it. You can't imagine the oppression. It's worse than South Africa. You know, all the South African leaders would say this. Nelson Mandela said this. Desmond Tutu said this. Oliver Tambo said this. South Africa was never anything like this. Jim Crow in the south of the U.S. was never like this. You know, you never had something like Gaza in Alabama, you know, where they carpet bombed an entire city of millions of people. So. that feeling is quite paralyzing. And that's why I'm very happy I managed to write this book because I always wanted to write something about it. But it's not only that it's overwritten, it's almost, it's like returning to the scene of a crime.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah. Well, I think that talking about some of the figures in your book will draw out even more of the texture of that crime.

Aaron Samuel Tamares and the muscle Jews

Sam Adler-Bell

And so let's do that. I think because it's the first one and it is distinctive, I think in a particular way, Aaron Samuel Tamares, who called himself in his writing, the sensitive rabbi, who has an orthodox religious opposition to Zionism at the turn of the 20th century. Could we talk about him a little bit? I think what distinguishes him, which is perhaps obvious, is that Many of the other figures that you talk about here are not particularly religious. And their opposition to Zionism comes from, well, maybe they're a communist, maybe they're anti-colonial third worldists. They come to their Zionism from somewhere other than religious conviction. And so that distinguishes Rabbi Tamares. So could you talk about him a bit?

Benjamin Moser

So I grew up not knowing any anti-Zionists at all, not even really knowing this concept. except for the Orthodox. And the way this was presented to me was, well, they're waiting for the Messiah to show up and then they're going to all go back to Israel. And, you know, like I'm from Houston, Texas, like Jewish people in Houston were not waiting for the Messiah. That just felt weird. And it felt kind of exotic and kind of bonkers. We didn't really know Orthodox people. You know, most people we knew were Reform or Conservative. But I was very interested in why the Orthodox were. opposed to Zionism. So Tamares is a guy who lives in a tiny, tiny village in the middle of a forest in eastern Poland. Now it's on the border between Poland and Belarus. So he's like the classic shtetl rabbi. And he's extremely learned, and he's extremely volcanic. You know, he even says the lava of his volcano poured itself across the Jewish world. You know, he uses these metaphors like this. He starts out quite curious about Zionism because he's very keen on Judaism. He really thinks that Judaism is not only a religious obligation, there's all these things you have to do as a religious Jew, but that all these things, as strange as they may look or sound, also have these practical applications as well.

And in fact, God has preserved the Jews by giving us these commandments and laws. All right, that's a pretty standard view, but he's enthusiastic about Zionism because He thinks that Judaism has an alternative to offer the world in a time of civilizational meltdown. He says, yeah, you know, these modern people, they can build a bridge and they can build a railway, but they actually aren't attacking the eternal human problems, which Judaism is. And so if we return to Judaism, we'll have these tools to rebuild humanity in a better way. So the First World War comes, that entire European world gets blown to smithereens. And Tamares sees... The Zionists, I think he says they're licking their teeth at the banquet of spoils. He sees that they're trying to remake this religious people with this unique heritage into just another ugly little quote-unquote nation. And he's extremely offended by this. There's actually a quote that I have in that chapter from another rabbi who says, Have we been suffering for 18 centuries just in order to catch up with Bulgaria?

Sam Adler-Bell

Bulgaria always catches a lot of strays from anti-Zionists. It's always like, what do we want? It'd be Bulgaria?

Benjamin Moser

Well, that's true because, you know, in the time that Herzl's writing and thereafter, all these Eastern European nations are coming into being. So you have Czechoslovakia as independent. You have Hungary as independent. You have the breakup of all the Russian empire eventually with all these countries that come into being. And, you know, Herzl thinks of the Jews as just another Hungarians or Romanians or something. And Tamares says, That is not who we are. We are not a ethnic people. We are a religious people. You know, he sees that in order to become a nationalist people, you're going to have to get rid of Judaism. Because of course, the central commandment of Judaism is thou shalt not kill. So anytime you put that into a place and you give it an army and a navy and a general, you're going to kill people. And just on that level, it's offensive. But I think Tamares is, he was such a... university for me, because I really learned a lot about the beauties of Jewish thought and about Jewish pacifism as well.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, it is very interesting. I think it's one of the things that even young anti-Zionists today and Zionists today wouldn't know about the founding generation and even before the founding, I mean, with Herzl, like that these were profoundly irreligious people. The Zionists of the first and second and third generation were not you religious Jews.

Benjamin Moser

No, and they looked down on Jewish religion. They actively were anti-Semitic. I mean, this is something that's very important to emphasize just how much these writings are drenched with contempt for Jewish history, for Jewish suffering, for Jewish weakness as they see it.

Sam Adler-Bell

Scholasticism, the insularity.

Benjamin Moser

They don't like the Jewish language in the case of Eastern Europe, which is Yiddish.

Sam Adler-Bell

Herzl didn't speak Yiddish or Hebrew.

Benjamin Moser

No, of course not. I mean, Herzl didn't have his son circumcised. Herzl was very anti-Jewish. He didn't like the Jews as they were. And I think he had this vision of what the Jews could be if only they had more machine guns.

Sam Adler-Bell

And if they would work the land and in factories.

Benjamin Moser

If they would duel. He was very into dueling.

Sam Adler-Bell

And duel, yeah, instead of reading books and being lawyers.

Benjamin Moser

And Tamares says all this stuff that makes us look weak. Okay, sure, we've had this pogrom and that pogrom and this disaster and that disaster, and yet we're still here. So God has preserved us in all these ways. Even when it looks like he's not preserving us, we have to trust in God's providence because where are all those people who persecuted us now? Where are those people from the 8th century who had all these castles and palaces and guns? They're gone. Nobody's ever heard of them. But the Jews are still here.

Sam Adler-Bell

The other important thing about Herzl and his coterie was that they also looked down their noses very much at Eastern European Jews, the Ostjuden. They thought of the Jews from the pale as truly these... backward, deformed, unenlightened people.

Benjamin Moser

Well, Tamares says they looked at them as hunchbacks. And there's a lot of this language of abuse in early Zionism, of looking at the diaspora as degraded and pathetic.

Sam Adler-Bell

Unmanly.

Benjamin Moser

Well, that's what I was going to say. It's basically faggoty, I guess is the technical term for it. You know, they were not manly. They were kind of feminine. They kind of were limp-wristed. They're going to make real men out of them. So you have, if you look at the graphic art, from early Zionism, it looks like Leni Riefenstahl. It's all these big muscular guys, like tanned in the sun of Palestine.

Matthew Sitman

Contrasted with the deformed diasporic freak.

Benjamin Moser

That's right.

Matthew Sitman

I mean, Ben, it does put you in mind of, to elaborate the gay metaphor, the aspects of gay culture that got really into steroids and bodybuilding in the wake of AIDS.

Benjamin Moser

It's very similar. Although that was sort of a sexual turn on as well.

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, I wouldn't underestimate the libidinal. factors with Zionism either.

Benjamin Moser

No, it was very important. Well, they called them muscle Jews.

Matthew Sitman

I was rewatching the episode of Mad Men where Sterling Cooper, the Israeli tourist office, asked them to help promote travel to Israel. And they said, well, how could we pitch this? And one of the people who works with Sterling Cooper goes, well, I can say one thing. The Jews there don't look like the Jews here.

Benjamin Moser

That's very telling.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, this is what several Philip Roth books are about, precisely this dynamic. You know, when you meet your Israeli cousin who's tanned and strong and calls you a queer.

Benjamin Moser

Exactly. And also the other side of that comparison is the misogyny, which goes into it very, very deeply. And it's something that a lot of people today, you know, Jewish women who are anti-Zionist, get all sorts of extremely violent misogynistic abuse.

Sam Adler-Bell

Oh, you support Hamas, they would kill you and rape you, blah,

Benjamin Moser

This is a very close. common thing. And, you know, actually gay people get this as well. Oh, well, they're going to throw you off the roof and stuff like this. It's all very common, but it goes back. It's very deep because they always called us self-hating Jews. You know, the anti-Zionists are the people who hate themselves. But in fact, I see that they are deeply ashamed of Jewish culture and Jewish life. And then I see anti-Zionist Jews as the real Jews who are actually true to our tradition.

Sam Adler-Bell

I do want to say something about that as relates to the religiosity. question because the thing is that in the moment of the founding of Zionism, the turn of the 20th century, there was a revolt against the religiosity of the rabbis and in some cases, people's parents, literal or figurative, which was not just the Zionists. I mean, the communists were doing that, the socialists were doing that, the anarchists were doing that, the Bundists were profoundly anti-religious. I mean, there was a kind of revolt across. Europe, across Jewish communities, young people across the whole world of Jewish life against the kind of hidebound rituals and laws of the parents.

Benjamin Moser

Well, this was very common, not only among Jews. I mean, this was a whole generation to the 19th century of people who were like, you know, this was true of Christians. This was certainly true of Muslims as well, although we rarely hear about them in this context. But, you know, a lot of people were trying to reinvent the wheel. Thinking like, okay, well, that was fine back in the old days when everybody thought that religion was just an inevitability and that we all sort of believed in the same things. But now we're modern. You know, in my family, I think it was my great-great-grandparents said that they were religious until the first copies of Darwin arrived in their city. That was a moment for people where they thought, we're modern scientific people. We don't believe in all this abracadabra anymore. And so that opens up a space for people to fill. And so someone like Tamares is saying, well, you know, don't fill it with this stuff. Like don't fill it with socialism, for example, because socialism also is violent. It's also corrupt. It also leads to death and destruction.

Herzl, race and colonialism

Benjamin Moser

Whereas you really actually should return to Judaism, because if you actually look at Judaism properly, you'll see that we have a tradition that can offer solutions to these problems and not just this kind of revolutionary bravado.

Sam Adler-Bell

And that's what really distinguishes him from the other characters in your book. But there's one other thing I wanted to get in here, which is that what therefore distinguishes Zionism from these other... revolts of the young against the old ways, these kind of manifestations of an enlightenment rethinking of the relationship of Jews to the political and religious and cultural world, is, I think, nationalism. I mean, I think you describe at some point Zionism as a 19th century ideology derived from Christian eschatology and German racial nationalism. It reminded me of Carl Schorske, who refers to Zionism. as a fusion of imperialism and romanticism in Fin-de-siècle, Vienna, right? I mean, Herzl is a racial nationalist and a romantic in a profound way who sees his project as inherently, necessarily, and strategically tied to the fortunes of European colonialism.

Benjamin Moser

Oh, and he says this very, very clearly, and it's... One of the many moments for which you can sort of perversely be grateful to Zionism for letting it all hang out, you know? I mean, they said all these things. It was never hidden away. So it's a weird mix of things, but I think it makes sense up to a certain point if you consider, again, the lack of manliness, the wanting to be part of the modern world, the wanting to participate, but also the sense of frustration to which it appeals. And I think it still does.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, I think at that time, it was also the sense, certainly this is Herzl's self-narrative, but I think it's true of many of the early Zionists who sort of just saw like, well, the project of Jewish emancipation in Europe was going very well. And now it's not going quite as well. Maybe it's the pogroms in the pale. Maybe it's Karl Lueger in Austria, the birth of antisemitism as a political ideology. And so people go, oh, well, I'm not really sure this liberal project of us becoming fully assimilated Europeans, assimilated Germans, assimilated Austrians is really going to work out.

Benjamin Moser

Right. And this is a legitimate observation. And I think everybody understands that. And I think there's nothing wrong with understanding it. But what the anti-Zionists were always saying is, is this the alternative? They were saying, you think it's bad now, just wait. This is going to bring absolute catastrophe. not only to the Palestinians, of which even the most racially charged early Zionists were very much aware. You know, they sort of pretended they were going to this land without a people for people without a land. But of course, they knew very well that the Palestinian people were there. But that all required a kind of sleight of hand to say, oh, this is the solution for that. So the people in my book are always saying, that's not the solution. Rather, the solution is a return to Jewish. observance, which is Tamares's solution, whether it is quite a conservative solution, like I do talk about the reform objections to Zionism, which are very interesting, which is in the case I write about in America, we are Americans, we have a different religion.

Matthew Sitman

Yeah, I did want to ask about Tamares, especially given that this is one of the truly religious figures in your book. What else would you say about the specifically religious vision that Tamares offers?

Benjamin Moser

Well, so the classic definition of the Jews comes from Baghdad from Saadia Gaon, who is a famous rabbi who's actually born in Egypt and lives most of his life in Baghdad. And he says in the 10th century, he says, our nation is only a nation through its Torah. So we're not like the Ruthenians or the whatever, you know, we are a religious nation. And a lot of what Tamares tries to emphasize in his writings, what's so interesting about them is just how practical they are. This is something that you often find among Jewish religious people, is that it's very hard to be a religious Jew. The whole point of being a religious Jew, according to them, is that it's burdensome. It's burdensome. It's everything you eat, everything you put on your body, every word you say. I mean, it's so burdensome that one of the people I quote, the guy who says the thing about Bulgaria, the Chafetz Chaim, who's a famous 19th century, late 19th century, early 20th century rabbi, who writes a famous... text about speech rules in Judaism and about speaking ill of others. And he basically concludes that you can actually never say anything ever about anything or anyone.

It's actually kind of a wise move for most people. But Tamares thinks that it's not really a burden, it's actually a kind of liberation and that it offers a vision of a spiritual life, a life dedicated to God. And also it offers an idea of heroism. And this is what's so interesting about these kind of muscle Jews. The Jewish hero that Tamares and others postulate is meek. He's quiet. He's discreet. He's charitable. And they understand that this sort of heroism, the effort to be that sort of person, is much more demanding than the effort required to be. you know, a soldier.

Sam Adler-Bell

I have to agree. It reminds me of that line. I think it's from Operation Shylock where, you know, the fake Roth, the diasporic revolutionary Roth, he says, better to be marginal neurotics, anxious assimilationists and everything else that the Zionists despise. Better to lose the state than to lose your moral being.

Benjamin Moser

Yes. Well, you know, Roth is an interesting figure I could have included in this.

Sam Adler-Bell

I know he would have eaten your book.

Benjamin Moser

Yeah, well, he's very, very, very anti-Zionist at certain times. I mean, I think what's interesting about him is he, you know, he has some characters are incandescently anti-Zionist and others are more sympathetic. But yeah, I mean, this is the thing. It's like, what does it mean to be a hero? Is it the heroism of a military person or is it the heroism to submit to the will of God?

Matthew Sitman

And Ben, I know this is very basic, but I think it's worth drawing out here, especially listeners like me who are relatively new to this material. You know, I'll confess that one aspect of this book that I've found so interesting is that if you had asked me, what does it mean to be Jewish? I probably would have said something like, it's like both a religious identity and an ethnic one. Like some, there's some kind of, you know, genealogical, biological and religious aspect to it. And the disavowal of nationhood and non-religious senses was so interesting to me for that reason, because I suspect a lot of people listening to this will just assume that Judaism is both some kind of religious affiliation, even if you're not a believer in one sense, but also an ethnic or racial identity of a sort.

Benjamin Moser

Well, the racial thing is what we reject.

Matthew Sitman

Yes, and I think that would be new to some listeners.

Benjamin Moser

Well, that's why it's really, I'm glad you mentioned it, because, I mean, Judaism is a big thing. It's existed for... so long in so many different countries and so many different contexts and so many different mental worlds throughout the millennia that a lot of these definitions are fair. What everybody in my book says, and they're so consistent on this, is that it's not a race. This podcast is called Know Your Enemy. And I think if you said, who is your enemy to these people, they would say the racial conception of Judaism. And It's true because racism, interestingly enough, I learned this when I was writing this book, is a word that is invented, I think, in the exact same year as two other words that we think of as words that have always existed. One of them is imperialism and the other is antisemitism. The year is 1870-1871. And what racism, imperialism, and antisemitism have in common. It's not that they are like you don't like Jews or you don't like somebody from a different part of the world because they have a different color of skin or something like that. All those things existed always. But these are scientific definitions.

These are hierarchies that they are based on social Darwinism and based on this new thing. So racism isn't just prejudice against other people. Racism is a scientific thing or pseudoscientific thing.

Sam Adler-Bell

I thought what you were going to say that all those three words have in common is Zionism.

Benjamin Moser

Well, I mean, Zionism is kind of a, it's a vector.

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, it's a very representative ideology of the moment of its birth in a profound way. I mean, I think this is one of the things I think is very interesting about Zionism. I think I've said it on the show before. Zionism emerges and becomes, you know, more of a factor, both a little too late and just in time. Because in a sense, it's a little too late for... an era of European imperialism that goes uncontested, or at least that is recognized by the world as totally legitimate. But it's just in time in the sense that if Zionism had been born after World War I, if it had been born as an ideology after Lenin and Wilson, in a sense, then it would have been seen as totally illegitimate. Once the critique of imperialism was on the rise.

Benjamin Moser

Well, that's when Zionism shifts gears because Zionism starts out as an explicitly racial, colonial, imperial ideology. You know, there's this famous letter that Herzl writes to Cecil Rhodes and says, well, you know, we're also colonists. And they call their organizations colonialist, this colonial, that. After World War I, as you say, that's when colonialism kind of goes out of fashion. So like when France and Britain take over these mandates, and there's other mandates as well, but in the Arab world. There's these four mandates that come out of the Treaty of Versailles. One is Iraq and Palestine, which is Iraq plus what we now say is Israel-Palestine plus what becomes the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. That goes to the United Kingdom. The French take Syria and Lebanon. And at that point, these are colonial regimes, but at that point, they have to kind of dress it up in this sort of more progressive, liberationist, human rights-ish clothing. But. The reason they're doing that is because, as you say, that's going out of fashion. So Zionism is quite late, you know, and Zionism has to retool itself. And that's the moment when they start saying we're indigenous to Judea and all this kind of stuff. They never said that before.

Sam Adler-Bell

They did not. I know. And the other thing that's happening, I mean, this isn't a major theme in your book, but it's implicit. And I do think it's incredibly absent from our conversations about Zionism. The other thing that's happening while Zionism is getting underway, becoming a more popular phenomenon, in the Jewish world is Arab nationalism and desire for self-determination. I mean, these movements are basically coterminous. Like, this is why it's so insane when Zionists are like, the Palestinians didn't exist until 1948, then they started calling themselves Palestinians and wanting to be a nation or whatever. You know, it's insane because actually you guys were doing the exact same thing. It's just that one movement had the backing of The most powerful nations in the world and also the people for whom the state was being created suffered the Holocaust. And one nation was not supported in that way. But Arab nationalism and Jewish nationalism were more or less coterminous movements.

Benjamin Moser

Except there's a big difference, which is that Arab nationalism was about colonized peoples trying to escape from foreign rule.

Sam Adler-Bell

It was anti-colonial.

Benjamin Moser

Anti-colonial, whereas Zionism was pro-colonial and it was about moving. people out of Europe into a non-white part of the world. And that's why the clash is so bitter, because Zionism creates a settler colony in the heart of the Arab world. And just at the moment when the Arabs are finally thinking, we're going to get rid of these regimes, you know, and the Arabs knew exactly what had happened to the rest of the Arab world and to the rest of the colonized world. I mean, look at Algeria, you know, do you think people in Palestine didn't know what the French were up to in Algeria? Of course they did. This was something that was a deep fear for people. And it was a deep fear of the Palestinians. I mean, they wrote to Herzl himself and said, leave Palestine out of this.

Jacob Israël de Haan

Benjamin Moser

Go somewhere else.

Matthew Sitman

Well, Ben, I did want to get in at least one more homosexual reference. The third chapter is titled Murder on a Jaffa Street, Jacob Israël de Haan from the Netherlands. Could you briefly tell listeners about this chapter? I was just fascinated by it. This kind of gay poet who moves to Palestine.

Benjamin Moser

De Haan is One of these figures that is almost more of a 19th century figure than a 20th century figure in that he's just this incredible polymath. He is this restless kind of figure who comes out of an extremely orthodox home. So, you know, a lot of the early Zionists come out of these homes where they can't really believe in the old religious world of their parents. And yet they still are Jews and they want to be Jews. But they're not sure what that means. They're not really religious believers anymore. So what does this mean? So De Haan comes from a family like this. He is most famous in the Netherlands, and this is how I knew who he was, for writing the first gay novel in the Dutch language, which was... 1901. This is a very early novel. It's actually a really good novel. And it's really interesting how he writes about this relationship as if it's the most normal thing in the world. You know, it doesn't have that pioneering feel to it. He just writes this novel. And I think that's his personality. He's just kind of who he is. He becomes a lawyer. He becomes a human rights activist. He becomes a very prominent journalist. He's a poet. He's a great traveler. So he goes to Russia. during the First World War, and he writes about the prison system in Russia and how ghastly it is.

During the First World War, he gets so shocked and disillusioned by the slaughter in Europe, and he really says, you know what, the Jews need to get out of here. There is nothing good about Europe. European culture has sent these people to their bloody deaths by the tens of millions. I mean, you know, this is just not something we want to be part of. We need to have our own thing as Jews. We need to get out of here and go to Palestine. So he goes to Palestine in 1919 as the first Dutch Zionist to immigrate to Palestine. And very early on, he figures out, even before he gets to Palestine, I mean, this happens actually in Cairo, he writes a letter back to a friend in the Netherlands, and he basically says, there's a lot of Arabs here. Which, when I tell this story, everybody kind of laughs, but I think it's a very eloquent story because it tells a lot about the solipsism of Zionism. and of the Jews in general, who are often engaged in these intramural debates that are quite important and quite relevant. But like, ultimately, when you're talking about Zionism, you're talking about the Palestinians, right? You're not even really talking about the Jews, ultimately.

Sam Adler-Bell

So, I mean, de Haan, his sympathies for the Arabs grows. He also becomes sort of a lawyer for the Orthodox, right? The Palestinian Jewish community who have complaints about the Zionist settlers. And... So tell us what happens to him.

Benjamin Moser

Well, so de Haan, and one thing that is interesting about his being gay is that he actually has relationships with Palestinian men. And this is extremely rare among Zionists to have any kind of interactions of any nature with Palestinians. Because Zionism in Palestine is really about segregation. It's about keeping people out. So from the very beginning, you know, you have segregated hotels in Tel Aviv. Palestinians aren't even allowed to live in Tel Aviv and in the other Zionist colonies. And people, there's a story in the chapter about Maxime Rodinson, the French scholar that I write about, where he goes to an Arab village, which is right next to this kibbutz. And everybody in the kibbutz is astonished that he's gone into the Arab village. And they've lived there for 10 years and they've never set foot in the Arab village. So de Haan, I think because of his sexuality, also does have this access to Palestinians. And he gets to know them. You know, as you do when you date somebody from a different background. Anyway, making a very long story short, they kill him. Three shots to the chest as he's walking out of a synagogue where he's praying for the soul of his recently deceased father.

Sam Adler-Bell

And this is an assassin who's hired by the Haganah, right? I mean, it's literally the Zionist militia has him killed.

Benjamin Moser

This is authorized by a man who becomes the second president of the state of Israel. He's the first Jew killed by Jews in Palestine. This didn't exist before, just as terrorism didn't exist in Palestine before the arrival of the Zionists. So it's a very dark story, and it's quite a gracing story because de Haan sort of knows they're going to kill him. And like a lot of the people in my book, he decides that it's still worth speaking out, even with the threats he's getting, even with the sewage that gets thrown at him. He gets spit upon on the street. which is a theme that you see throughout my book. Is it physical spitting on people is one of the discrete charms of Zionists?

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, there's nothing worse than a Jew who sees the brutality, the crimes that are being committed and not only like expresses, but works on behalf of the Arabs. And that's just intolerable.

Benjamin Moser

And to this day, I mean, this is what we are all facing, I think on so many different levels.

Sam Adler-Bell

I'm glad you mentioned the present.

The Israeli election

Sam Adler-Bell

Obviously that is... true of what we've been seeing for the past three years. But in this election, I was saying this to Matt before we got on with you, there's a sense of like, oh no, Isaac Chotiner, the Netanyahu coalition didn't get enough votes to unseat him. They got slightly fewer. Too bad, we can't do anything about it. Meanwhile, the Arab parties, you know, the Arab citizens of Israel voted in Massive numbers, more than sufficient if the... supposedly anti-authoritarian parties were willing to form a coalition government with the Arab parties, but they won't. They will not do it. And this is this vaunted Israeli democracy. Liberal Zionists will say, oh, it's bad in the occupied territories. But Arab citizens of Israel have full rights, which of course they do not. But it's like they can vote, but their representatives are treated as inherently illegitimate. And just today, Netanyahu went on X, the X platform, and said, oh, the Arabs stole the election. They're trying to steal the election. Shin Bet and the police need to bring the truncheon down on the Arabs for stealing the election. Of course, he's saying that because he wants to further stigmatize them so that his opposition doesn't feel that they have the space to form a government with them, which they don't want to do anyway.

Matthew Sitman

It's almost the Israelis stop the steal.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah. Well, I mean, it's worse because it's literally just like their votes do not matter. They don't count. And all of these supposedly liberal Israelis who are so concerned about the authoritarian threat posed by Netanyahu and Smotrich and Ben-Gvir, all these liberal Zionists who were so proud of the judicial reform protests, they're so against Netanyahu. He's the worst thing that's ever happened. He's the only thing that's wrong with the country. Even though he's the only thing that's wrong with the country, it's not feasible. It's not imaginable that his opposition could form a coalition government with the Arab parties, which just voted to preserve. the remnants of Israeli democracy and to promote what's left of their rights within this society. And I just find it so disgusting.

Benjamin Moser

Well, I think the mistake is covering it as if it is an actual election in a democratic country. I mean, South Africa had elections. The Confederate States of America had elections. It doesn't mean that these are what we think of as democratic countries. And I think that one of the things that I felt that I learned a lot from when I was writing this book was... Why is that? Why was Israel and Zionism incapable of reform? Because you would think just on a practical level, politicians, they want to be in power. So there's a very obvious, easy way to do it. Why don't you just take the Arab votes and form a coalition with them? Why is that impossible? But the theory of settler colonialism that I think, you know, Rodinson is the one who really articulates this in my book, although other people do it in other places. It's just that it is. inherently racist. It's inherently expansionist. So, you know, they're always conquering Lebanon or Syria, and they're always invading new sheep farms in Palestine. Everywhere they go, they're always trying to expand. They're threatening Egypt. They're threatening Jordan. They actually are acting out a pretty ironclad law of settler colonies that you can see in comparative perspectives. Racism and nationalism always triumph.

Avi Shlaim postulates that There's a real question in the historiography of Zionism and of Israel, which is that why couldn't Israel make peace? Because they said, oh, the Arabs hate us, they hate Jews, they'll never make peace. You go into the archives, you see that like for year after year and decade after decade, all the Arab governments around them are actually trying to make this problem not be a problem. They're trying to solve the problem. And they can't and they won't and they refuse. And of course, they lie about it. They say it's all the Arabs' fault. but It's the nature of Zionism. It's the nature of this thing. And that's why, again, to come back to this contrast between liberal Zionists and anti-Zionists, this is very important because you realize that Zionism is not something that's reformable. It's not something that can be improved on. It's not a question of giving people rights. It's something that's fundamentally flawed.

Sam Adler-Bell

And just for listeners, Avi Shlaim, he's the subject of your sixth chapter, who's this originally Iraqi Jewish historian who was one of... the new historians who kind of disrupted the existing Zionist, you know, mythology about 48 and about Arab intransigence and so on.

Benjamin Moser

They dismantled a lot of the edifice and they did it from within Israel and from within Israel's own archives.

Hyman Judah Schachtel and Beth Israel

Sam Adler-Bell

Could we move to talking about Hyman Judah Schachtel, who is this reform rabbi who opposed Zionism during World War II as the head of a synagogue in Houston.

Benjamin Moser

Yeah.

Sam Adler-Bell

And I think this chapter is incredibly important. We kind of referenced it earlier. What was... reform Judaism in America's attitude towards Zionism before 1948. And I think this is also a forgotten part of the story.

Benjamin Moser

Yeah. I mean, this is something that for me was completely new, even though I knew this story. In 1943, the middle of the Holocaust and the Second World War, the largest synagogue in the American South, Beth Israel of Houston, Texas, the oldest synagogue in Texas, it actually dates to before Texas joined the Union. So it dates to the Republic of Texas. You know, if you know sort of reformed Jews in these kinds of cities, these are the most respectable, the most middle class. These aren't people that are looking for a fight, right? This is like the establishment of the Jewish world. And in the middle of this war, the synagogue cracks up. And I actually think it's the only funny chapter in my book because it's just so... crazy the kinds of stuff that they start throwing at each other in the middle of all this catastrophe.

Sam Adler-Bell

There's kind of a pathetic quality to it. On the world stage, you know, the Judeocide is taking place. World War II is happening. And meanwhile, in Houston, Jews are accusing each other.

Benjamin Moser

Of being Nazis.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah.

Benjamin Moser

This was a really important thing. And this thing becomes a huge national story. So it reaches the New York Times, it reaches Time magazine, it reaches things like Jewish Houston intro. tribal fights don't usually make it that far.

Matthew Sitman

That was one of my favorite lines in this chapter, Ben, when you were like, how did this story end up in the New York Times and Time magazine?

Benjamin Moser

Well, so I'm from Houston and actually my grandparents left the anti-Zionist synagogue and went to the Zionist synagogue. So I grew up in the Zionist synagogue. Of course, by the time I came along, every synagogue was a Zionist synagogue and this whole thing had been totally swept under the rug. And then when I found this archive of what had actually happened, I was absolutely astonished. And I'll leave that to readers who want to read the actual story of it. But what was so interesting to me about it was, what was the attitude of the Reform Jews to Zionism? And why? And this is something that's very, very deep in Reform Judaism. It's not a side issue. It was actually the whole point of Reform Judaism was to get rid of everything tribal about Judaism. Everything that had to do with what garments the priest could wear and, you know, and all these weird prayers that people didn't like. Like there was a prayer, there still is a prayer that the Orthodox say every day. You say, thank God who did not make me a woman. So all these kinds of things, this kind of stuff that they looked at as medieval and they looked at as tribal, they wanted to get back to the center of what they saw as Jewish belief, which was basically monotheism with this. ethical component to it that derives from the prophets and that derives from the Jewish scholars and sages.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, Reformed Judaism is really the movement of Jewish rabbis seeking a compromise with Enlightenment liberalism and universal values.

Benjamin Moser

Exactly. Now, I grew up thinking that Reformed Judaism was just like for Jews who didn't want to do that much. You know, it was kind of a light form of Judaism.

Matthew Sitman

The Episcopalianism to Catholicism.

Benjamin Moser

It was absolutely the Episcopalianism. And actually, in terms of class, in terms of education, in terms of what these people looked like and what neighborhoods they lived in.

Matthew Sitman

It's not a flippant comparison.

Benjamin Moser

No, no, no, no. It's absolutely right. And of course, Episcopalianism as well, like Reform Judaism, it's kind of easy to think of it that way. But I was quite excited to discover the Reform writings about Zionism and how they absolutely hated tribalism. So they're coming at it from a very different perspective from Tamares and the Orthodox. But they think that. What this is going to do is establish Jews as a foreign nation that doesn't really belong there. You know, you think you're living in Texas, but actually you should really be living in Palestine. Well, believe me, people in Texas do not want to move to Palestine. You know, this is crazy. It's never crossed anybody's mind. Jews were always extremely patriotic Americans, as they were in most countries, you know, even the countries that persecuted them. The Jews in Texas and in the U.S. knew they had it really good. They thought of themselves as a church. This is the word that they use quite a lot. You know, just like you can be Catholic and you can be American, or you can be Episcopalian, you can be American, you can be Jewish and you can be American. We're not a separate nation. We are a community of religious believers. Our nation is the United States of America. Our flag is the stars and stripes.

Matthew Sitman

But I just want to read, you reproduce this in your book, but in 1943, September 1943, the Board of Trustees of Beth Israel approved basic principles. There were seven of them. And the second one, which you'll tell us about the controversy it unleashed, but I want to read it because the language is so American in so many ways. This is the second. principle. We are Jews by virtue of our acceptance of Judaism. We consider ourselves no longer a nation, but we are a religious community, and therefore, we expect neither a return to Palestine nor a restoration of any of the laws concerning the Jewish state. We stand unequivocally for the separation of church and state. We are neither a nation, a nationality, nor a race. Our religion is Judaism. Our nation is the United States of America. Our nationality is American. Our flag is the stars and stripes. Our race is Caucasian.

Benjamin Moser

Yes. So this is very interesting. I'm glad you read it because this is so boilerplate in reformed synagogues and had been for a hundred years. And one of the things in this smear campaign that ensues, the last phrase, which says our race is Caucasian, the Zionist critics, they really focused on that and they compared them to the Ku Klux Klan. They compared them to Jim Crow. And so the Zionists are saying this, and these people, you know, the lady who owns the dress shop in Houston, Texas, that's offensive to her because her son is probably off fighting the Germans in the American army. You know, I mean, these are people who really are threatened by this. And Schachtel, the rabbi I write about, says it was very obvious at the time that the phrase about being Caucasian meant we were not a separate race, which is what Hitler was trying to make us. And who else was trying to make us into a separate race were the Zionists. And what's really interesting is that the chapter about Houston is placed between the chapters about Cairo and Baghdad. And the Jews in the Arab world were absolutely terrified of the same things that the American Jews were, which is that you're a separate nation.

You don't really belong here. You need to get the hell out of here and go off to Palestine. This is at a time where anti-Semitism was vastly more common than it was. comes. And it's funny that you read this and you think, oh, all these crazy people in Houston yelling at each other. But in fact, this exact same debate with these exact same words almost is being held throughout the entire Jewish world. And in the case of Iraq and of Egypt, the dire predictions, which is that racializing the Jews and setting us up as a separate nation, a separate nationality, we don't really belong here, that that would bring catastrophe to their communities. And in fact, you know, the Jews of the Arab world are wiped out by Zionism. So it could have happened in Texas. Like, why not?

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, I think that's exactly what's so interesting about this chapter. I mean, so for one thing, when I was reading this, I initially sort of felt like in some fundamental way, this debate is more about what it means to be an American than it is about Zionism. And in some respects, the reformed Jews who were anti-Zionist were more or less anti-Zionist Be- Because they believed that assimilation and the kind of religious pluralism of the United States was the right path for them. And that Zionism posed a threat. Because if suddenly there's a Jewish state, then maybe their neighbors, their Christian neighbors in Texas, who had previously thought of them as just a people with a different religion, would start to see them as foreigners.

Matthew Sitman

And that they had double loyalty as well.

Sam Adler-Bell

Exactly. Dual loyalty.

Matthew Sitman

You can't have dual loyalty until there's another place.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yes. Therefore, there's an element of this, I think, which is a form of respectability politics, in a way, because it was more the new immigrants to Texas, in particular from the Russian Empire, who tended to be lower class than the Jews who were already there, who spoke Yiddish, or who had, who were more likely to be Zionist. And there was a sort of sense that the thing about Zionism was that it was this kind of embarrassing Eastern European ideology, which was going to excite the anti-Semitism of the community around them. And so the Zionists were saying like, oh, you guys don't want to betray any sympathies for the Zionist cause because you're a assimilationist and you want to be seen as Americans first and Jews as a religious matter. And I think that... that Schachtel's response to the white supremacist smears is right and true. And I think he's, he's on solid ground there, but you can understand where you would look at this and say, oh, well, you just want to be white. And the thing about the Zionists is that they're a reminder of some kind of like otherness that Jews actually probably do have in some way. So I had, I kind of had this thought that like, there's a respectability politics motivating the reform.

Benjamin Moser

Well, I would put it another way, which is that there is a very obvious class conflict here. Between people who have been established in the United States, and it's not that they thought of themselves as Americans. They really were Americans. They didn't speak English. They spoke English. They had lived in Texas, in this case, for several generations. By 1943, you know, if I think of my own family, they had been in Texas for four generations by that point.

Sam Adler-Bell

They had a lot more in common with their Christian neighbors than they did with Jews from the pale.

Benjamin Moser

They did. And, you know, if you imagine that position, they're sympathetic to these people. And they want to help them and they're welcome to come to the synagogue and to the schools and all that. But they find this all kind of weird and kind of foreign. And I think that's a debate that's taking place all over the Jewish world at the same time. The Jewish population of Texas triples within one decade. And my great-grandparents were very involved in something called the Galveston Movement, which was about trying to bring Jews from Eastern Europe to Texas, but not only to Texas, but to the American West. Because they actually were afraid of anti-Semitism in the East. And they thought, well, you know, if you put all these people in Texas or Colorado or somewhere.

Sam Adler-Bell

They've never met a Jew. It'll be fine.

Benjamin Moser

Well, no, but I mean, there was, you know, the biggest slum in the world at this time was the Lower East Side. And that was a Jewish slum. And there were all the problems that are associated with drugs and crime and poverty and prostitution.

Sam Adler-Bell

And communism.

Benjamin Moser

Well, and that's the other thing that I was going to say. These people were Americans, the Jewish community of Texas. They were capitalists. You know, they were basically either you were a lawyer or you were a doctor or you had a business. And so these people were not communists, even if they were generally what we would probably consider liberal Democrats now. You know, they were on the left, but they weren't leftists. And they had succeeded very well in America. They were extremely loyal to America. It was the greatest country in history for the Jews. And they felt very uneasy by this. And they also felt like, why should we give up our principles for a bunch of these loudmouth immigrants?

Sam Adler-Bell

I think the thing that's so interesting about this chapter to me is that unlike in Iraq and Egypt, where in some ways the fears that the anti-Zionists expressed came to pass, they really were othered. They really did have to leave. In some cases, they were forced to leave because the... Israeli Secret Service set off bombs. But indeed, it was the case that Zionism produced an otherness and conflict between Israel and the nation that they had called home that made it intolerable or impossible for them to stay where they lived. In America, it didn't happen, right? The anti-Zionists were wrong about what would happen. Assimilation was not disrupted by the advent of a Jewish nation state. And so... Even Schachtel, who writes really, actually, I think incredibly compellingly in the pre-48 period, in those years that you're describing in this chapter, against Zionism from the principle of liberal universalism and against the idea of Jews as a race. Nonetheless, he himself becomes a Zionist, right? Because what happens is that assimilationist Zionism of the reform persuasion ceased to exist because it was unnecessary.

Turned out, in America, Jews could be Zionist, assimilated, American, and even foot soldiers of white Western empire, you know? So that now you see at reformed synagogues, they have the American flag and they have the Israeli flag. And it's no problem.

Benjamin Moser

Yeah, if they even have the American flag at this point.

Sam Adler-Bell

But that's what makes the chapter so interesting because to me, it's like in most situations, the anti-Zionists were right about what was going to happen. And in this case, they weren't exactly right. And as a result, they were able to accommodate themselves with Zionism and with America and with the imperial project that both these nations came to engage in.

Benjamin Moser

So I want to put a little asterisk next to that, because so far, yes, I think that these things about dual loyalty, about the nation within the nation, all this kind of stuff and all the hatred and the resentment that that can provoke. I think this is still an open chapter.

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, I mean, you're on Know Your Enemy. So we're paying very close attention to the fact of real rising anti-Semitism on the right, which is also anti-Zionist.

Benjamin Moser

Right. And it's because, and I mean, there's lots of forms of this taking place. But one of the things that I am so shocked by, we're seeing this in Michigan now, is that these Jews are going on to CNN and the New York Times and saying, I'm not voting for Abdul El-Sayed because he's not good for Israel. even though he'd be good for America. And this is dual loyalty.

Sam Adler-Bell

That's what we call not good for the Jews.

Benjamin Moser

So that's what I'm saying. I think that we might not want to celebrate the triumph of this viewpoint just yet, because I think that those predictions, that if you read them and you look at what's happening now, and you look at, you know, the Jonathan Greenblatt's of the world, speaking of Know Your Enemy.

Sam Adler-Bell

He's actually personally. My number one enemy, I think. Not rationally, but I kind of hate him more than any person in the world. I hate him so much.

Benjamin Moser

Well, no, but I mean, they really do care more about Israel than they care about the United States.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, I think there's two... things that this chapter makes me think about. One is because of how it ends up with reformed Judaism becoming just as Zionist as anybody else, it suggests the kind of consonance between the imperial instincts of America actually can be totally harmonized with the imperial practice of Zionism. And so there's that. But on the other hand, what this chapter suggests is a moment where it seems like actually perhaps America at its best, in its actual kind of universal, multiracial democracy sense, which is very rarely achieved, but a very admirable aspiration, is incompatible with Zionism. And I mean, I profoundly believe that. And I do think that part of what's going on in American politics right now, the reason that anti-Zionism has come to be seen as totally commonsensical to a lot of younger people who are just encountering the idea for the first time, in this particular historical context is that they go, wait a second, this is not a democracy. This is an apartheid state. There are people who are, as I said before, in the occupied territories deprived of the right to have rights. This is a racial ethnic superiority ideology.

This is what we're taught even in grade school in the South, like in the most conservative places in the country, we're taught that this is wrong.

Hannah Arendt and the Eichmann trial

Matthew Sitman

Well, Ben, you know, we can't go through every chapter of this book. But I think one that we should touch on at least briefly, it's about Hannah Arendt. This was a case where I came to this chapter knowing more about Arendt than anyone else in the book. And I was still pretty shocked, I would say, by the extent of the campaign against her while she was working for The New Yorker, covering the Eichmann trial in Israel. And then the book, Eichmann in Jerusalem, the smear campaign, the kind of vicious attacks on her. For her reporting in that book, I wanted you to just talk to us a little bit about that. Why was Eichmann in Jerusalem so explosive? Why did it get her in so much trouble?

Benjamin Moser

Well, this is sort of a mystery that I am proud of having unveiled because I read Eichmann in Jerusalem, I think, in college. And I remember reading this book and thinking, OK, well, you know, that's interesting. But I came across references to this. Zionist hate campaign. People saying this was the ultimate Zionist hate campaign against this person. And I thought, like, what was it about this book? Well, the subtitle is The Banality of Evil. And what she means by that is basically that Eichmann is a completely unremarkable person. He doesn't even hate Jews that much. He's kind of a very mediocre bureaucrat outside of these modern machines of mass slaughter. You know, he would have been a provincial police campaign in in some small town in Germany. And that actually you could have taken this guy out and you could have put in a hundred other people in his place and it wouldn't have mattered. These people would have died anyway. So this is, you know, what the banality of evil kind of means. And it becomes a cliche and, you know. But like, what was it about this book that made them go bananas?

Sam Adler-Bell

Because you could imagine it's just like, you know, like on the surface and I think in sort of public memory, the reason people would say, oh, this book was badly received was because it was making the Holocaust into something that's more banal. at a time when it was supposed to be something absolutely ontologically evil.

Benjamin Moser

Well, they were also trying to establish it as unique.

Sam Adler-Bell

But I think that you discover that it's more than that.

Benjamin Moser

Well, that's putting it mildly. So I go back, it's been 30 years since I read this book, or however long it's been since I read this book. And I read it and I thought, oh, Hannah, what she's saying, and she's saying it quite clearly, but it is slightly coded as well. But what she's really writing about in this book... is the fact, which is abundantly documented, that certain Zionists and certain Nazis worked extremely well together, and that they had basically the same views of the Jews, which we've discussed before, which is that there's this foreign race that needs to get out of Europe. That was something they agreed on, and that Zionism had quite cannily used the catastrophe that overcomes the Jews of Europe in order to profit for their Thank you. little colonial venture in Palestine. So that's what she's really saying. And then you go back and you look at this hate campaign, which goes on for years. So she publishes the book in 1963. She dies in 1975, so 12 years. And when she dies, she's almost unmentioned in the Jewish press. She's such a pariah.

Matthew Sitman

This is one of the greatest philosophers in the world, someone of real stature in our public life.

Benjamin Moser

And she's a Jewish refugee from Germany. So trying to make her into the public enemy number one is kind of weird. So what is going on here? So that's what I try to address in that chapter.

Matthew Sitman

Yeah, it's really incredible.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, I also reread that book in the past probably three years. And I had the same experience of being like, wow, she is so irreverent about the Israelis. She's a thinker who just really despises bullshit. Bullshit, groupthink, charades, a kind of like performance being put on for ideological purposes. So the whole trial to her is deeply distasteful because not only is she suggesting that, look, there's actually a lot that these ideologies have in common. There were literal moments of collaboration. She's also just suggesting that what Ben-Gurion wants from this trial is to baptize. the relatively new state of Israel in the waters.

Benjamin Moser

Well, waters is one way of putting it. Blood is another way of putting it.

Sam Adler-Bell

The blood, yes, the blood of the Holocaust. And it's so transparent that she just finds it to be completely disgusting. And so do I. And so do I. And I think one of the things that she also points out, but that has been documented in even greater detail in Pankaj Mishra's book, The World After Gaza, is that... Survivors in Israel were not really treated as these like living saints in the way that we would imagine they were before the Eichmann trial. You know, certainly from the beginning, there was a sense of like the reason we are justified in founding this state is because of what happened to the six million. But there was also a lot of anxiety and even contempt for the survivors because there was a sort of sense of, well, you went like lambs to the slaughter. You're the weak Jews of the diaspora who didn't come here like you should have. So you would have survived if you had just come here, you idiots. But you didn't fight. You didn't fight enough.

Benjamin Moser

Well, and this is the same thing we talked about earlier. You weren't masculine enough. You weren't tough enough. And this is something that, you know, this is something that recurs in Zionism. It's a real contempt for Jews. They didn't actually care about Holocaust survivors, but they understood, Ben-Gurion understood very clearly. just how useful the Holocaust was as a propaganda thing. So Arendt describes this famous moment, I quote, where she says, the trial was interrupted for advertisements from the Glickman Corporation.

Matthew Sitman

Even, Ben, you point out that like the prosecutors, right, were given access to the press, like in just like the nature of the trial itself was a spectacle, not like a actual legal trial in important key ways. And Ben, I just wanted, because I think it's important, could you just you briefly mention a few of the aspects of the campaign against her, the playbook? You might say that they ran against Arendt.

Benjamin Moser

Well, it's very interesting that, first of all, it's the same people always. So the ADL, the Anti-Defamation League, run by your friend Jonathan Greenblatt now, sent out a circular to every synagogue in America to denounce Hannah Arendt from the pulpit on Yom Kippur.

Matthew Sitman

Oh my goodness. unbelievable.

Benjamin Moser

Well, and the language of it, she's a self-hating Jew. Who has not heard that one? Who has not heard kapo? Which for people who don't know what a kapo is, it's basically a Jew who during the Holocaust was basically helping other Jews get thrown into the ovens.

Sam Adler-Bell

But also if you haven't been called one, then you're not doing the work.

Benjamin Moser

You're not doing the work. So it's a very ritualized hate campaign. It's almost like in Shirley Jackson's story, The Lottery, where they all go out there and they draw a lot. And, OK, they're going to stone, you know, Mrs. Jackson today. And this is really how they proceeded with an insane amount of focus. And it really took her utterly by surprise.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, I think the other thing that I think in terms of what offended her, too, about the trial, I forgot about this point. but She was offended that he was being tried for crimes against the Jews. Because for Arendt, the Holocaust was a crime against humanity perpetrated on the body of the Jewish people. Like, not a narrow tribal injury that should be avenged by a representative body of that tribe. And I do think that gets to the core. of her complaint. And the Zionists just recognize, they recognize, you know, in a way that other people reading the book wouldn't necessarily, that this is a profound threat to our understanding of what this state is about and what the Jews mean, what the Jews are.

Benjamin Moser

Yes. And she has a lot of these objections that I think she thought of as principled objections to aspects of this trial and aspects of this performance, even though It's interesting, and I do point out, she did think that Israel had a right to try him. She thought that the death sentence was justified. So she's not 100% anti this thing. I mean, she is sort of, you know, talking about these questions. But I couldn't understand why she needed to be eliminated. And the reason is they have never wanted to discuss Zionist collaboration with the Nazis.

Matthew Sitman

Exactly. You know, one of the things about Arendt, and this might transition us to some of the reception of your book, Ben, Anti-Zionism, Jewish History, so far, is that one of the great emphases of Arendt's thought is on, well, the nature of thinking, right? She actually, I think, might have been published posthumously, but like thinking, acting, judgment, like what it meant to actually think and not fall into mindlessness, right? That's a core aspect of her work. And you can see it applied in this particular case. And it struck me that part of the fury against her, the aim taken at her, was in some ways a resistance to actually thinking about seeing and thinking about what's actually happening.

Benjamin Moser

That's absolutely right. It's one of the reasons she's such an interesting and fun. She's actually quite a fun person to read because you see this mind working. It's actually not dissimilar to Susan Sontag, who had a lot of respect for her, is even when she's wrong about stuff. She's interesting. She's thinking about it. She's showing you why she thinks this and why she doesn't think it. And another concept that I love that I bring back in the book time and again is the concept of the conscious pariah. So this is the person, the Jewish person in this case, who really chooses not to be part of the society of power and money and glory and gold, but who thinks there's a value that stands outside of society and looks. from a slightly different angle.

Matthew Sitman

Yes, and I'm not comparing you to Arendt necessarily, but now that this book has been out in the world for a month, I'm very interested in the tenor of the replies, both public and private, perhaps.

Reception, and Germany

Matthew Sitman

What can you tell us about the reception of your book?

Benjamin Moser

Well, it's been absolutely fascinating. I feel like we're in revolutionary times. We really are. I'm here in the UK. I just got a review in The Guardian, which is a very good review, but for a month, I did not get one review in any paper in this country. I got very few reviews in the U.S.

Matthew Sitman

So just not reviewed at all?

Benjamin Moser

Nothing. And when I was writing about Vermeer or something, you know, everybody in the official press wanted to talk to me. When I was writing about Susan Sontag, everybody was interested. Sometimes they loved it, sometimes they hated it, but they wanted to talk about it. So that's been very telling. And I'll give you another example. In the city of London, I could not find a single bookshop to host a launch event for this book. Not to toot my own horn, but, you know, I'm a middle-aged Pulitzer Prize winner.

Sam Adler-Bell

You're stamped.

Benjamin Moser

But it was very revealing. And that's on the one hand. On the other hand, I've never had as much publicity for anything I've ever done in my life. People are so grateful for Jewish voices who are speaking out against this because we've seen who gets platformed and who gets platformed to the Zionists. And we're out here screaming ourselves till we're blue in the face. saying, this is not everybody, this is not us, this is not who we want to be. And we don't get that kind of attention. But luckily, we're in this completely new world of media that, I mean, this podcast, you know, there's a lot of podcasts. There's so many things on YouTube. There's so many things on different corners of the internet that I'm learning about now. And they have tens of millions of listeners.

Sam Adler-Bell

So do we, so do we.

Benjamin Moser

I know you do, particularly, but that's who I meant. No, but really though, if you add it all up. It's an incredible space, and it's not the space that I was brought up to care about.

Sam Adler-Bell

Right, You know, this reminds me, we had, of course, our friend Molly Crabapple on the show when her book about the Bund came out, and I wrote about her in The Guardian. And I wondered about that book. Like, obviously, this is a book that's made precisely for me. This is the kind of thing that I want to read. But is this going to really have a big impact? And she's gone through like four printings of that book. It's a huge success because they're like your book. There is a deep hunger for this alternative side of the story of Jewish Zionism. And it's not surprising to me that you're getting a lot of attention from people who maybe aren't the gatekeepers, the parvenus. You're getting attention from elsewhere.

Benjamin Moser

And it's an incredible amount of attention. I mean, I really can't. It's almost dizzying. I mean, I I'm like. 400 emails behind or something crazy. And it's every single day. I get requests from the entire world. It's being translated in like 30 countries. So, I mean, there's something that's all these books. I think, you know, Molly and there's been so many others as well. Like we have known if we're in this fight that we have a public. And we also know that there's a lot of people in the establishment media who are very determined for us not to reach that public.

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, I did have a question about Germany. Has your book been reviewed in the German press? Because I did think one of the most acute moments in the Nan Goldin chapter was where you talk about this kind of depraved German philo-Semitism that is one of the things on the world stage that really unnerves me, like more than anything else. You write in the book, this is your discussion of kind of how Germany tried to destroy Nan Goldin. Germany no longer suffered as previous generations had from collective guilt. It suffered instead from collective guiltlessness. German media politicians and cultural bureaucrats seemed to agree that being German meant having internalized the quote-unquote lessons of the Holocaust so deeply that they were immune to racism, so deeply that the descendants of Nazis could presume to censor and cancel the descendants of Jewish victims of the Nazis. This right had accrued to them not despite their Nazi background, but because of it. That is exactly. what's so fucked up about Germany these days. And I have a friend, Tobi Haslett, who was living in Berlin, and I saw him maybe a year or two ago, and I was asking him about this phenomenon. And he was saying that it really is the case that the German cultural elite feel that they have unique access to the truth of antisemitism because of the Holocaust.

Benjamin Moser

Yeah.

Sam Adler-Bell

That they should be the arbiters. You should ask the Germans if you need to know whether something's genocidal or whether something's anti-Semitic because they know better.

Benjamin Moser

Well, again, I go into this in great detail in the chapter about Nan Goldin. But even that, I do try to emphasize that this is not German public opinion. This is German elite opinion. If you ask normal people in Germany, do you think that if you see a picture of a child sleeping on the grave of her slaughtered mother because she has nowhere else to go? How do you feel about that? Well, Germans are going to feel exactly the same way that Japanese people or Brazilians are going to feel about that. And it's a uniquely weird media environment, a political environment. But it's not. I mean, if you actually strip all the BS away, they're doing this to us in every country. I mean, there's all sorts of efforts to shut down Palestinians, to shut down anti-Zionist Jews, to shut down people like Francesca Albanese.

The New Yorker review

Benjamin Moser

I mean, it's a global.

Matthew Sitman

Ben, speaking of some of the official gatekeepers, the kind of elites in the media, many of whom have not had this book reviewed, one place that did was The New Yorker. Isaac Chotiner reviewed it. I'm sure many listeners will know him for his often great interviews, including after October 7. He's been indispensable. But he offered some criticisms of your book that I am interested in your response to. He points out small errors, things like context for certain quotes. a fact here, a fact there, translation of a German word at one point. But he says even Moser's mundane mistakes suggest a pattern, an eagerness to endorse whatever claims he thinks will strengthen his case.

Benjamin Moser

Well, people have their opinions and that is their right. And certainly, obviously, when you write a book called Anti-Zionism, A Jewish History, you know you're going to get a lot of stuff thrown at you. It's not like, wow, somebody didn't love my book. I'm shocked. But I think it is very illustrative, and I think it's very important for people to understand the context in which consent for genocide has been manufactured and how this fits into that. I don't want to make it too personal. about me, But it's almost a classic case study in how things like Gaza can happen. So maybe we can step back just a tiny bit and kind of explain where we're coming from. Because this show is also called Know Your Enemy. My enemy is liberal Zionists. And I want to be clear about who they are. When I say I was a liberal Zionist, I don't even think that's quite accurate because I think in the trajectory of my... Thinking about this, I've evolved away from certain ideas, but liberal Zionism is not about evolution. It's a fixed thing. It's a position. It's where you say Israel is somewhere that has a lot of problems, but we hope that we can fix these problems.

You don't say that Israel and Zionism are the problem. So what is liberal Zionism? I mean, if I were to sum it up in three words, they would be the New Yorker. Even more than the New York Times, which is so biased and so kind of doltish at this point. It's much more than like if you talk about CBS with Bari Weiss, like that's very transparent, it's very clumsy. The New Yorker is chic, you know, it has a patent of sophistication to it. And I think people believe the stuff they read there in a way they don't believe the Times or CBS. Because they sort of think it's trustworthy, and that makes it actually even more important to the liberal Zionist ecosystem. So, I mean, my theory about why the New Yorker is so important is because I think it performs being upset about Gaza so convincingly.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah, I think that's true. It's certainly not true of everybody who writes there. Incredible writing and reporting about the genocide has been published there, but I think Remnick himself, he is in his person. the like last stand of the liberal Zionist.

Benjamin Moser

Absolutely. And I want to be fair also to like a lot of the people who work there, many of whom honestly are my friends and people I respect. And I know they're upset about this genuinely. That's absolutely true. But we're talking about institutions. I think that's what I really want to get to here. We're talking about an institution that can stand for so many of our institutions. The number one and number two, I would say, are the Democratic Party and the New York Times. These are places where you know there's a lot of good Democrats. There's a lot of good people at The New York Times. They feel exactly the way I do about this. But we're looking at institutions. And The New Yorker, I think, has made things worse and not better. Because you said the reporting that they've done, sure. But I think by allowing those dissenting voices, they're masking this deep complicity on an institutional level. So just to like circle in a little bit more. into this question.

Why did they ask this guy, right? I mean, they could have asked any number of other people because as I said, they have these other people. I mean, they could, there's lots of anti-Zionist Jewish people there, like Becca Rothfeld, there's like M. Gessen, there's a lot of people who've done all this reporting. I mean, God forbid they could have asked an Arab or a Palestinian, but they get the guy whose main claim to fame, you mentioned his good interviews. I will. put a little asterisk besides that and say, good interviews that embarrass people that liberals don't like. And the way he does it is basically by interviewing people and then transcribing the calls really unfavorably. So every time you say, uh, like, meh, he puts that in there.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, I will say that in his defense, he did do a pretty good job with some of the Biden foreign policy people who really are Among the great contemptible villains of this genocide.

Benjamin Moser

But that's the point. But those are comical villains. Those are people who've committed genocide. So it's easy for them. And everybody like us is going to read that and say, oh, I'm glad he got that guy. You know, but like people have been clapping at him for years because he was dunking on the right. You know, and I consider these people right. But he's literally just cheating. I mean, anybody who's ever done an interview knows, and I've done thousands. I mean, you know, these books I've written, like the Sontag book has. hundreds of interviews in it. It's just not the way it works, you know. But when it's people that liberals don't like, they clap, you know. And there's all these jokes about like, oh, don't pick up the phone if it's Isaac Chotiner, like the Jewish space laser who's going to come zap you from the...

Sam Adler-Bell

I haven't heard that. Yeah,

Benjamin Moser

I just made that one up.

Sam Adler-Bell

I'd like to be described that way.

Benjamin Moser

But like, the point I really want to make is that he has done softball interviews before and it's not always like this. and For example, and I would like to put for example in like 24 point font here. When I see this person's name, I think of one thing. It was an extremely important piece. And that's why I remember it. This was December 2023. And it was called How Hamas Used Sexual Violence on October 7th. For someone who has this stunning wit, this was a piece that was so gullible and malicious that I think it kind of stands alone in the annals of professional shame. And I remember scratching my chin at the time, this is only a few weeks after October 7th, and just thinking, this sounds crazy. This sounds deranged. It was really an important piece because it laundered a huge... amount of propaganda that was so transparently propaganda that you had to kind of wonder how this got published. But then in this piece, Mr. Jewish Space Laser himself says that the author of the report confesses, and later there's a lot more investigation into this, saying they didn't interview anyone to create this report about the supposed mass rape. There's no forensic evidence. There's no photographic evidence. There's no video evidence.

There's just no evidence. And like, if you know anything about Israel, you know how every inch of that country is so relentlessly surveilled that like, wait, there was a mass rape of all these women and there's no footage of it. So it was just really something that strained credibility. And then even actually this Israeli organization, which I think was called Physicians for Human Rights in Israel, they even actually eventually walked back this piece and distanced themselves from it. Now, this is extremely important because... As we all remember, the rape stories and the depictions of Palestinians as these bestial human animals, you know, as Yoav Gallant called them, this was really, really important. And to have it in The New Yorker was really important. And it wasn't important for right-wingers. It was important for liberals.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, these stories had an effect on me, I'll be honest. The things that were reported were absolutely horrifying. And they were reported in outlets that I trusted. There was the New York Times piece. There was this. And they were shown.

Benjamin Moser

to be transparent fraud.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yeah, there was overstatement, there was fraud, there was real problems with the sourcing. I mean, as you're saying in that interview, she says, we didn't interview any of the victims. I mean, it really was shown to be part of a propaganda project.

Benjamin Moser

But it was so obvious. There was this woman named Ahad Ha'am Ziv. I don't know if you remember her. She was in the media a lot. And she was saying she was too sensitive to talk to people. It was just too raw and it was too painful. And she even admitted that these claims had no sources. This piece had links to people who have been known to make these extremely exotic claims about October 7th. And a lot of this stuff was debunked within 10 minutes of going onto the internet.

Sam Adler-Bell

I mean, it's not like reports of sexual violence are in and of themselves ridiculous. I mean, just to be clear, some of the most harrowing specific allegations were debunked. And the claim of systematic sexual violence on 10-7 has not been substantiated. But a U.N. investigation did say there were reasonable grounds. quote unquote, to believe sexual violence took place. And meanwhile, obviously, we know that Palestinians have been subject to rape and sexual assault by Israeli soldiers and prison guards. And we know that because some of those incidents were caught on camera.

Benjamin Moser

Okay, maybe I shouldn't say it's so obvious. Be this as it may, the New Yorker has never amended this piece. They have never corrected it. They have never removed it from the website. Chotiner has not done this. And so what I'm just trying to say is this wasn't a Bari Weiss. job. This was a centerpiece of a campaign to manufacture consent for a genocide. And so that's just to try to say who the person was that wrote this about my book. And this is the person who's appointed himself judge, jury, and executioner. And then it comes in, if you read it, I haven't really studied it super forensically because I looked at it and I knew exactly what it was, but it has all these personal attacks on me. And this is somebody I've never met.

Sam Adler-Bell

I think that the overall... thing that's really interesting about the piece, and I think you've already alluded to this, is that it is a review that sets your book against Omer Bartov's Israel, What Went Wrong. And I think that that is really the central thing, is that your book, based on the arguments of anti-Zionists from very different time periods and for different reasons, relentlessly document and show that Zionism was a crime from the beginning. And Omer Bartov... I think he's a very admirable person, and I think that him calling the genocide a genocide was very important, given his academic work on the Holocaust. But there's a profound difference between your book and his book, which is that you don't think there was a time where it was good and it went wrong.

Benjamin Moser

Absolutely.

Sam Adler-Bell

And Isaac Chotiner is also someone who thinks there was a time when it was good and it went wrong.

Benjamin Moser

That's where I'm trying to go with this windy, long explanation, because this piece doesn't have anything to do with my book. The title of it is,

Matthew Sitman

Is Zionism Moral Crisis About Roads Not Taken or Original Sin?

Benjamin Moser

So this is why I'm trying to say, what is liberal Zionism? And I agree with you. I don't have a problem with Omer Bartov. I actually have a lot of respect for him. And he's done a lot of important work. But I don't think Israel went wrong. I think Israel was wrong. And this is a view that is not a degree further from the liberal Zionist view. It's the exact opposite of the liberal Zionist view. And so I just, you know, he says all this stuff about how I'm like mentally ill and it's all Jewish psychodrama. I mean, he calls me childish. Listen, I... have become really sensitive to what I find sort of homophobic dog whistles in pieces about me. And this thing about, oh, it's a psychodrama. Oh, he's being really dramatic. He's really emotional. Like, you know, when Black people say, like, the word articulate is kind of a racial dig, which I wouldn't necessarily hear. But then they say, no, no, no, they always say that. It's like, oh, you're Black, but you can also read and write, you know? Like, I get a lot of that stuff about, like, oh, he's emotional. And it says, psychodrama. Do you think I'm wrong about that?

Sam Adler-Bell

I don't think so. No. I mean, I, hey, it's your experience.

Matthew Sitman

It's your experience. Ben, I, as the homosexual, I think you're onto something there. And if I was written about in that way, I think my antennae would pick up on the same things.

Sam Adler-Bell

Can I say something about the accusation of there being psychodrama here? I mean, I sent you that piece, Ben, that I wrote after 10-7 about my grandfather. And I think that But like, the thing is, I mean, your book describes in its first chapter. the intense emotional experience that you went through in deconstructing your Zionism. And I think it's no good, it's no use to pretend like there isn't personal and emotional stakes to this situation. I mean, it should be personal and emotional to anyone to see dead children on our phones every single day for several years. It should be intensely emotional to suggest that having emotional investments in this question is a problem, you know, it's disqualifying, is insane. But I think also, I think that the Jews, we should talk about ourselves less.

Benjamin Moser

I know a guy who wrote a piece with a title similar to that.

Sam Adler-Bell

Yes, your Equator piece is right. Your book about anti-Zionist Jews somewhat undermines that argument. But no, what I'm saying is that there are emotional, psychic, and personal familial stakes to these sorts of questions. And it simply can't possibly be disqualifying for us to feel that way. I mean, look, maybe I would be thinking clearly about the world if I had not had the experience of people who I admired, who were the sources of my moral instruction, who were otherwise progressive, liberal, fair-minded, tolerant people, had not lied to me about this horror.

And a lot of people... have that experience and we can react to that experience in ways that are productive and counterproductive. I see it all the time. I see the counterproductive, I see the productive, but it's no use to pretend it's not there.

Honor, hygiene and “September 1, 1939”

Benjamin Moser

Well, I don't ever pretend it's not there. And one of the concepts I was raised with was honor. There's things you just don't do. And a lot of these are quite classic. You know, you don't lie, you don't cheat, you don't steal. Okay. I mean, you don't need any kind of Judaic background to have this, but a lot of it was that you don't support, you don't vote for, you don't speak out in favor of anything that could be considered racist or that would disrespect the memory of the victims of racism or of the six million or any of that. When I think about the worst thing I could do in terms of my family, the worst thing that I could do would be to help manufacture consent for a genocide. And the other idea which is related to this was hygiene. You don't besmirch yourself. with dirty people. My grandmother, I remember this so well, she would literally not touch people she considered unclean, morally unclean. I mean, she would, I remember this moment at my bar mitzvah when this person that she thought was financially corrupt, which he was, extended his hand to shake her hand and said, congratulations, Mrs. Moser. And she stood there with her hands folded in front of her. She wouldn't touch people that she thought were unclean.

And so I think that the Jews who have contributed to this, who have given their intellectual support, who have done the sorts of things that have made this genocide possible. I don't want to hear from them. I don't want to see them. I don't want to touch them. And those people coming to sit in judgment of me, of Molly Crabapple, of all these people who are out there every day getting our faces slapped. because we're protesting a genocide, you want to come for my footnotes? Fine. I don't want to hear from you. I don't want to see you. I don't want to breathe the same air as you. I consider you treif. And I think that there is a sort of tendency that's a class tendency also among writers and journalists and everybody knows each other and all that, not to draw these lines, but I do draw these lines and I don't apologize for it. I'm not perfect. I mean, of course, you know, I've done things that are good and bad, but I haven't betrayed the memory of the six million. I have not dirtied the name of my father. And I know that sounds old fashioned. I love it. Well, you know what? Not everybody can say that.

Sam Adler-Bell

It's a personal code. It's integrity.

Benjamin Moser

I have a code. I try very hard to live up to it. I've never done anything that I would consider to be dirty in the moral sense.

Sam Adler-Bell

Well, let me say something about you, Ben Moser. I think you've done a real service by writing this book. I think it's unbelievably... compelling. It was enraging. And I'm so happy that you came on the show to talk about it with us.

Benjamin Moser

Absolutely a pleasure.

Matthew Sitman

Ben, can I add to Sam's praise? In particular, what I'm about to read is a real compliment to you. I mean it. Sam knows this coming from me. What I'm about to read is as high a compliment as I can give. But it occurred to me while you were talking about what I called your personal code. And it's Auden's great poem, September 1st, 1939, the last two stanzas. which I shall read as a homage to you here. All I have is a voice to undo the folded lie, the romantic lie in the brain of the central man in the street and the lie of authority whose buildings grope the sky. There is no such thing as the state and no one exists alone. Hunger allows no choice to the citizen or the police. We must love one another or die. Defenseless under the night, our world in stupor lies, yet dotted everywhere, ironic points of light flash out wherever the just exchange their messages. May I, composed like them of eros and dust, be leaguered by the same negation and despair, show an affirming flame.

Thank you, Ben Moser, for using your voice to undo the folded lie.

Benjamin Moser

Wow, I'm so touched and teary-eyed. that I'm very glad we don't have video.

Matthew Sitman

Well, that's why I saved this for the end, Ben.

Benjamin Moser

Well, you've embarrassed me in the best possible way.

Matthew Sitman

Good. That's what we try to provide. Thank you so much, Ben, for this book, for being generous with your time. And I hope everyone listens to this.

Benjamin Moser

If you want to listen to gay emotional people who are a little bit highly strong.

Matthew Sitman

Sometimes. Sometimes. They wear ironic points of light. Yeah, yeah. One more time for listeners.

Sam Adler-Bell

The book is Anti-Zionism, A Jewish History by Benjamin Moser. Thank you so much.

Benjamin Moser

Truly my pleasure.

Matthew Sitman

Thank you, Ben. Thank you, Sam. Thank you, listeners. Bye-bye. Bye.