Isaac Chotiner's review in The New Yorker of Benjamin Moser's Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, read alongside Omer Bartov's Israel: What Went Wrong?. Sam Adler-Bell flags it at the start of episode 02 as a tough review that produced controversy, and in the last half hour Matt Sitman puts its criticisms to Moser. Moser treats it as a case study in liberal Zionism, and Sam frames the dispute through the review's title, as the gap between thinking Israel went wrong and thinking it was wrong from the start. Start with episode 02 at about 95 minutes, where Matt introduces the review.
Across the episodes
Enters as the hostile notice the hosts promise from the first minutes, and becomes the occasion for the episode's sharpest argument over liberal Zionism
The review is set up from the episode's introduction as the conversation's main point of conflict.
"we do talk to Ben about one review in particular. which was very tough and produced some controversy."Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 4:33
Matt presents the review as the exception: one of the few mainstream notices of a book he says has been largely ignored.
"one place that did was The New Yorker. Isaac Chotiner reviewed it."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:35:25
The review's central charge, as Matt relays it: small factual and translation errors taken as evidence of motivated reasoning.
"But he says even Moser's mundane mistakes suggest a pattern, an eagerness to endorse whatever claims he thinks will strengthen his case."Isaac Chotiner, read by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:35:50
Moser's opening concession before he moves from the review's criticisms to the politics behind it.
"Well, people have their opinions and that is their right."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:35:59
Sam's reading of the review's design: the pairing of the two books is the argument, with Bartov as the acceptable critic and Moser as the one who goes too far.
"is that it is a review that sets your book against Omer Bartov's Israel, What Went Wrong."Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:45:25
Sam places the reviewer on Bartov's side of the divide the pairing draws.
"And Isaac Chotiner is also someone who thinks there was a time when it was good and it went wrong."Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:46:08
The title states the alternatives the discussion turns on, read out by Matt as Moser reaches for it.
"Is Zionism Moral Crisis About Roads Not Taken or Original Sin?"Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:46:22
Moser accepts the review's framing but claims the second alternative, which he says puts him at the opposite pole from liberal Zionism rather than just beyond it.
"But I don't think Israel went wrong. I think Israel was wrong."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:46:37
Connections
Matt introduces Chotiner as the reviewer and names his criticisms.
The magazine Moser calls the essence of liberal Zionism.
Moser's book is the review's subject, set beside Bartov's.
Sam says the review sets Moser's book against Omer Bartov's.
The last half hour of episode 02 is Moser's response.