person
also known as Chotiner

An American journalist and staff writer at The New Yorker, best known for his interviews. In episode 02 he appears as the author of the New Yorker's review of Benjamin Moser's Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, which the introduction flags as tough and controversial and which takes up most of the episode's last half hour. Matt introduces the review and its main criticism; Sam then reframes the dispute as one between two readings of Israel's history, one in which it went wrong and one in which it was wrong from the start. Start at about 95 minutes.

Across the episodes

02

Enters late, as the reviewer the last half hour answers, first credited by the hosts as an interviewer and then placed on the far side of the went-wrong and was-wrong divide

Matt gives the reviewer a standing before the critique, so the dispute is framed as one with a respected interviewer whom the show's listeners already know.

Matt turning from the book's lack of reviews to the one major outlet that did review it.

"one place that did was The New Yorker. Isaac Chotiner reviewed it. I'm sure many listeners will know him for his often great interviews, including after October 7. He's been indispensable."
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:35:25

The review's central charge, as Matt puts it to Moser: the individual slips are minor, but the review reads them as evidence of a method.

"He points out small errors, things like context for certain quotes. a fact here, a fact there, translation of a German word at one point. But he says even Moser's mundane mistakes suggest a pattern, an eagerness to endorse whatever claims he thinks will strengthen his case."
Isaac Chotiner, read by Matthew Sitmanreported#
Isaac Chotiner, read by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:35:40

Sam keeps the interviewer's record in view, crediting the adversarial interviews with officials of the Biden administration that he counts among the war's worst actors.

"I mean, I will say that in his defense, he did do a pretty good job with some of the Biden foreign policy people"
Sam Adler-Bellasserted#
Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:40:10

Sam moves the disagreement off the footnotes and onto frameworks: the review measures Moser against a Holocaust historian's account of a project that lost its way.

"is that it is a review that sets your book against Omer Bartov's Israel, What Went Wrong. And I think that that is really the central thing,"
Sam Adler-Bellasserted#
Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:45:25

Sam places the reviewer on Bartov's side of the divide, which explains the review as a clash of positions rather than of facts.

"And Isaac Chotiner is also someone who thinks there was a time when it was good and it went wrong."
Sam Adler-Bellasserted#
Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:46:08

The review's own title already poses the choice the hosts draw out: a contingent wrong turn, or a flaw present from the founding.

Matt supplying the title as Ben begins to give it.

"Is Zionism Moral Crisis About Roads Not Taken or Original Sin?"
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:46:22

Connections

writes forThe New Yorker

Matt introduces him as the New Yorker writer who reviewed Moser's book.

His review of Moser's book, whose title Matt reads out.

Matt summarizes the review's charge that small errors add up to a pattern.

set alongsideOmer Bartov

Sam places the reviewer with Bartov's view that Israel was once good and went wrong.