An Orthodox rabbi (1869-1931) of a shtetl in eastern Poland who signed his writing "the sensitive rabbi", and the first of the figures Benjamin Moser and the hosts take up from Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History. Of all the book's subjects he is the one whose objection to Zionism is religious: he began curious about it, then broke with it after the First World War, arguing that the Jews were a religious people rather than a nation and that a state with an army would betray the commandment against killing. The discussion also draws out his pacifism, his answer to the Zionist contempt for diaspora weakness, and his warning against socialism. Start at about 29 minutes, and continue at 43 minutes for his religious vision.
Across the episodes
Enters as the book's first and most religious figure, the one through whom the conversation reaches an Orthodox, pacifist Judaism that stood against Zionism, socialism and the cult of strength alike
Sam sets Tamares apart from the rest of the book: where others come to anti-Zionism through communism or anti-colonialism, his ground is Orthodox faith.
"Aaron Samuel Tamares, who called himself in his writing, the sensitive rabbi, who has an orthodox religious opposition to Zionism at the turn of the 20th century."Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 28:58
Moser places him in the shtetl world the early Zionists held in contempt, far from the cities and movements where the Zionist argument was being made.
"So Tamares is a guy who lives in a tiny, tiny village in the middle of a forest in eastern Poland. Now it's on the border between Poland and Belarus. So he's like the classic shtetl rabbi."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 30:13
Tamares begins as a sympathizer, seeing in Zionism a vehicle for Judaism's ethics, so his story follows the book's recurring pattern of an admirer who finds the crime.
Moser summarizing Tamares's early writing.
"he's enthusiastic about Zionism because He thinks that Judaism has an alternative to offer the world in a time of civilizational meltdown."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 31:08
The break comes with the First World War: Tamares reads Zionism as opportunism among the ruins of Europe, and as a demotion of a religious people to an ordinary nation.
"The Zionists, I think he says they're licking their teeth at the banquet of spoils. He sees that they're trying to remake this religious people with this unique heritage into just another ugly little quote-unquote nation."Aaron Samuel Tamares, quoted by Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 31:40
The core of the objection: if Jewish peoplehood is religious, nationalism does not fulfil Judaism but replaces it.
Answering Herzl's picture of the Jews as one more nationality, like the Hungarians or Romanians.
"And Tamares says, That is not who we are. We are not a ethnic people. We are a religious people."Aaron Samuel Tamares, quoted by Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 32:37
His pacifism follows from the same premise: a state needs armed force, and armed force breaks the commandment at the centre of the religion.
Moser laying out Tamares's reasoning.
"Because of course, the central commandment of Judaism is thou shalt not kill. So anytime you put that into a place and you give it an army and a navy and a general, you're going to kill people."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 32:52
For Moser personally Tamares is a teacher, the figure through whom a Reform-raised writer found a Jewish pacifist tradition he had known only as Orthodox eccentricity.
"he was such a... university for me, because I really learned a lot about the beauties of Jewish thought and about Jewish pacifism as well."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 33:06
Against the Zionist charge of weakness, Tamares makes survival the proof: the persecutors' castles and empires are gone and the Jews remain.
"And Tamares says all this stuff that makes us look weak. Okay, sure, we've had this pogrom and that pogrom and this disaster and that disaster, and yet we're still here."Aaron Samuel Tamares, quoted by Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 34:29
Tamares as a contemporary witness to the founders' disdain for the Ostjuden, which Moser then generalizes to early Zionism as a whole.
Answering Sam's point that Herzl's circle looked down on the Jews of the Pale.
"Well, Tamares says they looked at them as hunchbacks. And there's a lot of this language of abuse in early Zionism, of looking at the diaspora as degraded and pathetic."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 35:12
His case reaches beyond Zionism to every secular revolt of his generation: the space left by lost faith should be filled with Judaism, not with revolutionary politics.
"And so someone like Tamares is saying, well, you know, don't fill it with this stuff. Like don't fill it with socialism, for example, because socialism also is violent."Aaron Samuel Tamares, quoted by Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 39:04
The positive side of his thought: the demands of the law, which others describe as a weight, he treats as freedom.
"But Tamares thinks that it's not really a burden, it's actually a kind of liberation and that it offers a vision of a spiritual life, a life dedicated to God."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 44:19
Tamares's counter-ideal to the muscle Jew: a heroism of restraint that, in Moser's reading, asks more of a person than soldiering does.
"The Jewish hero that Tamares and others postulate is meek. He's quiet. He's discreet. He's charitable."Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 44:35
Connections
Moser presents his opposition as religious: a nation of Torah remade into a nation like any other.
Against Herzl's picture of the Jews as one more Eastern European nationality, Tamares insists they are a religious people.
His meek, discreet, charitable hero is Moser's counter-image to the Zionist cult of strength.
A forest village in eastern Poland, now on the Belarus border.
The first figure Sam and Moser discuss from the book.