concept

The ideal, associated with Max Nordau, of a physically strong and martial Jew, set against the supposed weakness of the diaspora. In episode 02 it comes up in the discussion of the early Zionists' contempt for diaspora and Eastern European Jews: Benjamin Moser and the hosts read it as a project of remaking Jewish manhood, follow it through early Zionist graphic art, Mad Men and Philip Roth, and set against it Aaron Samuel Tamares's ideal of the meek religious hero. Moser returns to it in the Arendt discussion to explain the early Israeli attitude to Holocaust survivors. Start at about 34 minutes.

Across the episodes

02

Enters as early Zionism's picture of the remade Jew, is traced through art, television and fiction, and returns later as the root of the contempt shown to Holocaust survivors

Moser traces the ideal to Herzl's dislike of the Jews as he found them: the project was to make a different, armed Jew.

"Herzl was very anti-Jewish. He didn't like the Jews as they were. And I think he had this vision of what the Jews could be if only they had more machine guns."
Benasserted#
Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 34:09

The ideal needed a foil, and Sam names it: the Jews of the Pale, whom Tamares says the Zionists saw as hunchbacks.

"The other important thing about Herzl and his coterie was that they also looked down their noses very much at Eastern European Jews, the Ostjuden."
Sam Adler-Bellasserted#
Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 34:56

Moser reads the project as a matter of gender: the diaspora was cast as effeminate and Zionism as a cure for its manhood, which is why he and Matt keep drawing gay parallels.

"they were not manly. They were kind of feminine. They kind of were limp-wristed. They're going to make real men out of them."
Benasserted#
Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 35:29

The visual evidence: Moser likens early Zionist graphic art to the body aesthetics of fascist film.

"if you look at the graphic art, from early Zionism, it looks like Leni Riefenstahl. It's all these big muscular guys, like tanned in the sun of Palestine."
Benasserted#
Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 35:35

Moser supplies the movement's own name for the ideal, agreeing with Sam that desire played a part in it.

Following Sam's remark not to underestimate "the libidinal factors with Zionism".

"No, it was very important. Well, they called them muscle Jews."
Benasserted#
Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 36:07

Matt's pop-culture echo: in Mad Men, the contrast becomes an advertising pitch for travel to Israel.

"The Jews there don't look like the Jews here."
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 36:25

In American Jewish fiction the ideal shows up as a family scene, the diaspora Jew put down by the Israeli.

"this is what several Philip Roth books are about, precisely this dynamic. You know, when you meet your Israeli cousin who's tanned and strong and calls you a queer."
Sam Adler-Bellasserted#
Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 36:29

The counter-ideal: Tamares's quiet, discreet, charitable hero, which Moser says is harder to live up to than being a soldier.

"And this is what's so interesting about these kind of muscle Jews. The Jewish hero that Tamares and others postulate is meek."
Benasserted#
Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 44:31

Moser carries the ideal forward to Israel's early treatment of Holocaust survivors, whose fate it blamed on a failure of manhood.

Responding to Sam on the contempt survivors met in Israel before the Eichmann trial.

"Well, and this is the same thing we talked about earlier. You weren't masculine enough."
Benasserted#
Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 1:24:42

Connections

imagined byTheodor Herzl

Moser says Herzl pictured what the Jews could be with more machine guns.

defined againstOstjuden

Sam says Herzl's circle looked down on the Jews of the Pale as backward and deformed.

echoed inMad Men

Matt recalls an ad pitch for Israel: the Jews there don't look like the Jews here.

echoed inPhilip Roth

Sam says several Roth books turn on meeting the tanned, strong Israeli cousin.

Moser sets Tamares's meek, charitable hero against the muscle Jew.