work

Philip Roth's 1993 novel, in which a double of the author preaches "diasporism", a return of Israel's Jews to Europe. In episode 02 Sam recalls a line spoken by that double, prompted by Benjamin Moser's account of Aaron Samuel Tamares's ideal of the meek, unwarlike Jewish hero. Moser then says Roth is a figure he could have included in his book. Start at about 45 minutes.

Across the episodes

02

Surfaces once, from memory, as a novel's voice for the diasporism the book's religious anti-Zionist argued from faith

Sam hears Tamares in Roth's double: the novel's diasporist would also choose moral integrity over statehood, though he speaks as a secular writer and not a rabbi.

Prompted by Moser's description of Tamares's quiet, charitable hero; Sam introduces it with "I think it's from Operation Shylock".

"the fake Roth, the diasporic revolutionary Roth, he says, better to be marginal neurotics, anxious assimilationists and everything else that the Zionists despise. Better to lose the state than to lose your moral being."
Philip Roth, quoted by Sam Adler-Bellreported#
Philip Roth, quoted by Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 45:05

The novel leads Moser to name Roth as a writer his book of Jewish anti-Zionists left out.

"Roth is an interesting figure I could have included in this."
Benasserted#
Ben, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 45:19

Connections

written byPhilip Roth

Sam recalls the line from Roth's double, the "fake Roth".

Sam is reminded of the novel by Tamares's ideal of the meek hero.