The American novelist and essayist is mentioned by Matt in both episodes he hosts. In episode 02 Vidal is one of the authors Matt says his generation might have read its way out of the closet with. In episode 03 he is Midge Decter's adversary: Matt cites Vidal's reply to "The Boys on the Beach", collected as "Pink Triangle and Yellow Star", and reads its title as a question about whom American Jews would ally with. Start with episode 03 at about 37 minutes.
Across the episodes
Named in passing as a formative read, part of Matt's own history rather than the argument
Vidal enters the series as a formative read, part of the literary route out that Matt offers as a parallel to leaving Zionism.
"I've often said that I feel like I'm part of the last generation that might have read their way out of the closet. You know, you encounter Edmund White, or you encounter Gore Vidal."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 2 (2 Nov 2026), 23:50
Steps forward as the neoconservatives' sharpest gay critic, whose answer to Decter supplies both a framing question and the panel's best joke
Vidal is named as the respondent to Decter's Fire Island essay, the gay writer answering the neoconservative.
"a response to this piece was written by Gore Vidal in the nation."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 37:24
The collected title pairs the Nazi badges for gay men and for Jews, which is the whole of Vidal's argument in a phrase.
"but it was eventually, you know, republished under the title Pink Triangle and Yellow Star."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 37:30
Matt reads Vidal's title as a question about Jewish neoconservatives' choice between solidarity with other outsiders and the defense of middle-class normalcy.
"And I thought that's so striking because it kind of says like, who are the yellow stars kind of aligning themselves with in our politics? Other outgroups?"Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 37:36
Vidal's comic retort to Decter's remark about lesbians' mastiffs turns her observation back on her and her husband.
"if I was a lesbian on Fire Island and I saw two Podhoretzes waddling towards me with Leviticus in one hand, and Freud in the other. I'd want to protect a dog."Gore Vidal, quoted by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 45:19
Connections
Vidal's reply to Decter, first published in The Nation and later collected under this title.
Vidal's essay responds to Decter's 1980 Commentary piece on Fire Island.
Matt names White and Vidal as the writers his generation might have read its way out of the closet with.
Vidal's retort pictures two Podhoretzes waddling down the beach.