work

Gore Vidal's reply to Midge Decter's 1980 Commentary essay "The Boys on the Beach". It first appeared in The Nation in 1981 as "Some Jews and the Gays" and was later collected under the title used here, which sets the Nazi badges for homosexuals and Jews side by side. In episode 03 Matt brings it in after reading from Decter's 1987 letter defending her essay, first for what the title implies about Jewish neoconservatives' alliances, then for one of Vidal's jokes. The passage starts at about 37 minutes.

Across the episodes

03

Enters as the counterpunch to Decter's essay, and its title becomes the panel's way of putting the episode's question about which outgroups Jewish intellectuals chose to stand with

Matt reaches for the title rather than the argument: the pairing of the two badges is itself the rebuke, since it names a shared persecution that Decter's essay ignored.

Closing Matt's reading from Midge Decter's letter to Howard Meyer.

"a response to this piece was written by Gore Vidal in the nation. And I forget what its original title was, but it was eventually, you know, republished under the title Pink Triangle and Yellow Star."
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 37:24

The title becomes the hinge of the episode's question about Jewish reaction: once Jews entered the postwar mainstream, did they stand with other outsiders or with the order that had admitted them?

"who are the yellow stars kind of aligning themselves with in our politics? Other outgroups? Or they've seen themselves more as kind of the guardian of middle-class normalcy,"
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 37:39

Vidal's answer to Decter's remark about lesbians and their mastiffs turns her observation back on her, casting the Podhoretzes, armed with scripture and psychoanalysis, as the threat on the beach.

Matt recalling the essay after mentioning Decter's description of lesbians' dogs.

"if I was a lesbian on Fire Island and I saw two Podhoretzes waddling towards me with Leviticus in one hand, and Freud in the other. I'd want to protect a dog."
Gore Vidal, quoted by Matthew Sitmanreported#
Gore Vidal, quoted by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 45:19

Connections

written byGore Vidal

Matt credits Vidal with the reply, first printed in The Nation.

Vidal answered Decter's Commentary essay on Fire Island.

Matt recalls Vidal's picture of 'two Podhoretzes' on the beach.