work

Midge Decter's essay in the September 1980 issue of Commentary about the gay men she encountered at Fire Island, where her family spent its summers. In episode 03 Matt reads from a 1987 letter in which Decter defended it, David corrects the story of how she came to write it and describes her real objection, and Matt recalls Gore Vidal's answer. The essay serves the panel as an early instance of the neoconservative turn to sexual politics that the far center continues in its own campaigns about gender. Start at about 34 minutes.

Across the episodes

03

Becomes the episode's main evidence that neoconservatism was a cultural politics as much as a foreign policy, read first through its author's own defense and then corrected and widened by David

The essay is introduced at second hand, through the correspondence it provoked, which frames it from the start as the center of a controversy.

Matt introducing the letter he owns from Decter to the lawyer Howard Meyer.

"But it was a response to an essay that Midge Decter wrote in 1980 for Commentary titled, The Boys on the Beach. And this was Midge Decter going to Fire Island."
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 34:50

Matt's first framing casts the essay as reportage by an outsider, the shocked visitor, a framing David soon corrects.

"walking around observing and writing this kind of shocked and at times, you know, appalled, offended at what she saw there piece for Commentary."
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 35:03

Seven years on, the author's own defense opens with a denial in capitals, which Matt plays for comedy before the letter turns darker.

"She starts with the boys on the beach is not homophobic. Capital N, capital O, capital T."
Midge Decter, read by Matthew Sitmanreported#
Midge Decter, read by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 35:20

The correction changes what kind of essay it is: not a field report by a visitor but a regular's complaint about her own resort, a grievance from inside.

David offering "one brief factual correction to Matt".

"Midge did not actually go to Fire Island, like, on assignment to check it out. The Podhoretz family had been vacationing there for years,"
Davidasserted#
David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 38:17

In David's reading the essay's real subject is heterosexual men: gay display is offensive because it reminds husbands of the freedoms they gave up.

David summarizing the argument of Decter's essay.

"Her real objection was that the gays, by showing off their phalluses, she really does get into this, and doing all kinds of drugs and drinking and partying,"
Davidasserted#
David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 38:42

The detail sets up Vidal's retort, and with it the panel's turn from analyzing the essay to mocking it.

Following Sam's remarks on Decter's book The New Chastity.

"I will say one of the funnier bits in Midge's Boys on the Beach was her noticing that lesbians had big like mastiffs with them all the time."
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 45:07

Connections

written byMidge Decter

Decter's 1980 essay for Commentary on gay life at Fire Island.

published inCommentary

Matt says Decter wrote it for Commentary in 1980.

The essay records Decter's view of the island's gay summer culture.

Decter's 1987 letter opens by insisting the essay is not homophobic.

Gore Vidal's reply, which Matt recalls for its jokes about the essay.