Point at a sentence to see when it was said, and click the time to listen from there.Tap a sentence to see when it was said, and tap the time to listen from there.
The live taping
Matthew Sitman
All right, welcome listeners to episode 148 of Know Your Enemy. I'm Matt Sitman, your podcast co-host, and I'm here as always with my great friend, Sam Adler-Bell. Hello, Sam.
Sam Adler-Bell
Hi, Matt.
Matthew Sitman
Dreary, rainy weekend here in New York, which is fitting because the episode we're about to share, we recorded it a couple weekends ago on a very rainy Sunday.
Sam Adler-Bell
Oh my God, it was pouring. That's right.
Matthew Sitman
Which is to say, we're sharing the live taping we did, the live episode we did recently at Jewish Currents Live. the big festival that Jewish Currents, the great magazine, the lefty Jewish magazine, puts on. And we were very proud to be a part of it. And so that's the episode this week.
Sam Adler-Bell
Yeah, we were in a big room with a bunch of fantastic people. And we were talking about neoconservatism, Jewish reaction, and the far center, which you'll learn what the far center is by listening to this episode. But basically, we were doing some neoconservatism and trying to figure out who the real heirs to neoconservatism are today.
Matthew Sitman
Yes. And to do that, we were joined by two of our great friends. One is a past Know Your Enemy guest, our friend David Klion. He is a columnist at The Nation and a contributing editor at Jewish Currents. And of course, he is writing a book about the legacy of neoconservatism. And we've been keeping our powder dry. Like, we know this book of his is coming out. So he will be on again, I'm sure, to talk about that book. But here's a little preview in this conversation.
Sam Adler-Bell
Yeah, exactly. We were also joined by another friend of ours, Andrea Long Chu, who's a Pulitzer Prize winning critic for New York Magazine, and an incredible writer, one of my favorite writers. And she has a forthcoming book that's about the phenomenon of the far center.
Matthew Sitman
It's kind of her coinage in a way, or she's doing a lot with it.
Sam Adler-Bell
Kind of, you know, these bewildered and or agitated liberals who move to the right or to the center. for various reasons, which is a big phenomenon in our public life. And kind of the core figure who ties this whole conversation together is Bari Weiss, who is both really kind of genealogically and intellectually, if we can even use that word, neoconservative, but also a really, you know, kind of prominent representative of the phenomenon that Andrea defines in her work.
Matthew Sitman
Yes. So we're not going to title the episode this, but this is kind of the backstory of Bari Weiss, zooming way out.
Sam Adler-Bell
We should say a couple things about this recording. For one thing, it was recorded in a big echoey room, and the audio that Jesse got, he had to do some doctoring on. So if it's not the pristine audio quality coming from our high-quality microphones that you're used to, you'll have to just imagine yourself at the Brooklyn Academy of Music and enjoying it that way. It's like an audience tape.
Matthew Sitman
It's a bootleg. It's almost a bootleg. It's actually, it's like now Bob Dylan putting out the official versions of bootlegs.
Sam Adler-Bell
I think Jesse actually used both a tape from the room and from the soundboard. So it's what Grateful Dead nerds would call a matrix tape.
Matthew Sitman
Yes, yes. And Sam, I'm glad you mentioned the audio because for some reason as well, Jesse cut out all the uproarious laughter at our jokes in the room. Yeah, I know.
Sam Adler-Bell
He really turned off the laughter way, way, way down in the mix. I mean, I guess it was kind of distracting just how they were hooting and hollering and screaming the whole time. But yeah, you won't hear any of that.
Matthew Sitman
Yeah, all the people yelling, Matt, Sam, we love you. We love you.
Sam Adler-Bell
There's one other thing I want to say about it, which is that the first voice you'll hear once we're done with this introduction is Mark Krotov from n+1, who's introducing the panel. So don't be alarmed. But Mark is such a sweetie pie and he says some really nice things about us. So that's probably why Jesse left it in.
Matthew Sitman
Well, thank you again to our friends at Jewish Currents. We had a great time doing this episode. It was really fun. hanging out with David and Andrea and you, Sam, and a couple hundred of our closest friends. So thank you for the invite, Jewish Currents, and listeners, patronize them if you aren't already. We'll put in a link to the show notes. Well, speaking of lefty magazines, as always, we're grateful to our partners at Dissent. One thing they do by sponsoring the podcast is if you subscribe to Know Your Enemy on our Patreon at Patreon slash Know Your Enemy for $10 a month, You not only get access to the Know Your Enemy Discord, which we recently did a live conversation with about the midterms, and all of our bonus episodes, you get a free digital subscription to Dissent. Recently, they made the incredible decision to add Sam to the editorial board.
And of course, for $5 a month, you get access to all of our bonus episodes. We just put out a barn burner on the midterm elections. So if you're wondering what we think about that, subscribe.
Sam Adler-Bell
I have one other Dissent announcement. This episode's coming out Monday morning. So if you're listening to this on Monday and you have no evening plans, at 7 p.m. on Monday, November 16th, which is today, if you're listening to this right when this episode came out, I'm doing a panel discussion. on the 50th anniversary of Irving Howe's masterpiece, World of Our Fathers, The Journey of the East European Jews to America and the Life They Found and Made at the YIVO Institute for Jewish Research in Manhattan. So if you want to come hang out with me, also some great historians, Tony Michels, Hasia Diner.
Matthew Sitman
Yes, I'm going to try to come as well. And listeners, that kind of topic or prompt for Sam Adler-Bell, in baseball terms, we call that... A hanging curveball right over the plate. So do come out. I'm sure Sam will be great.
Sam Adler-Bell
It's a fantastic book. 50 years, 1976, this book came out.
Matthew Sitman
Yes, we are Wills-pilled, but also Howe-heads on this podcast. So consider coming out for it.
Sam Adler-Bell
As always, we want to thank Jesse Brenneman, our intrepid producer, who wrangled this audio together and made it sound as good as humanly possible. And Will Epstein, who does the music for our show.
Matthew Sitman
All right, shall we get to it?
Sam Adler-Bell
Yeah.
Matthew Sitman
Here's our conversation from Jewish Currents Live with our friends David Klion and Andrea Andrea Long Chu. Enjoy. Enjoy.
Mark Krotov introduces the panel
Mark Krotov
My name is Mark Krotov, and I'm the co-editor and publisher of n+1 magazine. one of the partner organizations for Jewish Currents Live. Given the belief shared by Jewish Currents and n+1 that intellectual exchange can't only happen in print, as important as print remains, it's a particular pleasure to introduce Know Your Enemy Live, neocons, the far center, and the politics of Jewish reaction. I'm sure that many of you are already passionate Know Your Enemy fans like I am, and for the handful of you that aren't yet, it's a thrill to be with you for your moment of conversion. Know Your Enemy is so consistently good and rigorous, in fact, that it completely redeems the three scariest words in the English language. Live podcast taping.
For those of us who have lost decades of our lives to terminal degrees in Bari Weiss studies, the following conversation is a godsend. What an all-too-rare privilege to have the opportunity to think together, even if the subject is a dark... and solipsistic one. You can read the full bios of our distinguished panelists in your program, but here's a quick introduction. Sam Adler-Bell and Matthew Sitman are the co-hosts of Know Your Enemy. Andrea Long Chu is a critic at New York Magazine. She received the Pulitzer Prize for Criticism in 2023, and she's the author of Authority, an essay collection, and Females. David Klion is a contributing editor at Jewish Currents, a columnist at The Nation, and author of a forthcoming book for Doubleday about the legacy of neoconservatism. Without further ado, let's welcome Sam, Matt, Andrea, and Dave.
Matthew Sitman
Yes, well, welcome everyone to this very special episode of Know Your Enemy. I'm Matt Sitman, your podcast co-host. I'm here as always with my great friend Sam Adler-Bell and two other great friends, David Klion and Andrea Long Chu.
Alcove One and the three ages of neoconservatism
Matthew Sitman
This panel was titled Neocons, the Far Center in the Politics. of Jewish Reaction. I expect us to spend a little bit of time on all of those terms. We want to start with the first term in that title, the neocons. And we will go back to the start, which in this case is not the book of Genesis, but Alcove No. 1 at City College in the 1930s. A different kind of promised land, you might say. And the intellectuals that came out of Alcove One, where the anti-Stalinists left, not the communists in Alcove Two. But Peter Steinfels, in a book I think all of us love, it was the first book written on the neoconservatives in 1979, and one thing he said was that the formative experiences in their youth for the neocons, for the first generation of neocons, people like Irving Kristol, Daniel Bell, Nathan Glazer, was the rise of totalitarianism and the failures of socialism. The socialism, the milieu they were in to meet that moment, they thought. Those original experiences. of disappointment. Now, one of the things we'll get to is kind of how this band of intellectuals, people in reaction to these failures that I described, how they evolved over the decades, how they came so close to power, proximity to power, wielded power.
One of the things that Peter Steinfels mentions in this book is when he's talking about Irving Kristol, the godfather of neoconservatism, he described it this way. If Horatio Alger had written about intellectuals instead of newsboys. He would have wrote a book about Irving Kristol titled Irving, the Editor, or From Alcove One to the President's Dinner Table. I think that is partly the story that David's going to tell us in a moment. But one of the other things that I think is key to consider when you think about the neocons, the original generation, those who came out of Alcove One, they're still with us in many ways, as we'll show you. But one of the other scholars I'm sure we'll all draw on is Justin Vaïsse, a French scholar, who wrote a book called Neoconservatism, Biography of a Movement. And he describes the first age as liberal intellectuals in dissent. This is the people Irving Kristol, Daniel Bell, Nathan Glazer, people who wrote for a publication like The Public Interest, who took aim at the great society, its excesses, its failures, as they understood it. This is mostly the 50s and 60s. The second generation, which I think comes in more in the 70s, these were the Scoop Jackson Democrats, and we associate them with defense intellectuals like Richard Perle or Paul Wolfowitz.
They were the ones who, in 1976, really wanted Scoop Jackson to be the Democratic standard bearer. And as a kind of play off of the McGovern campaign, like Come Home America, they said, Come Home Democrats. And then the third age of neoconservatism, Vaïsse describes as the National Greatness Conservatives. And these are kind of the fail sons, you might say, of the prior generations associated with the Iraq War, but also magazines like the Weekly Standard. Now, David, I want you to fill in this story a little bit. And I'm interested in kind of the way they argued. Kind of what would you say are some of the key characteristics of neocons in terms of their preoccupations, rhetorical modes, and kind of maybe you will take the story a little closer to the present.
David Klion
Yeah, well, first of all, thank you all for being here.
Dynasties, networks and Bari Weiss
David Klion
This is very emotional for me, actually, because one of the first things I wrote about the neocons was a piece about Norman Podhoretz for Jewish Currents very early in its revival, I think 2017. Shortly after which, I went on... one of the first episodes of Know Your Enemy with Matt and Sam to talk all about Norman and his wonderful first memoir making it. Norman belongs to that original first generation, although he's a bit younger and did not go to City College, he went to Columbia. And one thing I explore in my forthcoming book is the interesting differences temperamentally between where Norman is coming from and where the Alcove One intellectuals, including most notably Irving Kristol, are coming from and how those have echoed down to the present. also through their wives, who were both prominent neoconservatives, Gertrude Himmelfarb, the historian of Victorian England, who was married to Irving Kristol, and Midge Decter, who Matt knows all about because he has this wonderful letter about her homophobia, I think.
Matthew Sitman
I hope that letter makes an appearance.
David Klion
Yes, he's mentioned it on the podcast before, was the wife of Norman Podhoretz, and then their son is John Podhoretz, the current editor of Commentary magazine, and Irving and Gertrude's son, is Bill Kristol, who... Lately, you may know, is a super woke guy at the Bulwark who does fundraisers for Haitian immigrants in Ohio.
Sam Adler-Bell
Also a Know Your Enemy guest.
David Klion
Also a Know Your Enemy guest, and who literally wants to abolish ICE. And who is, I would say, the only person in America to, in the same week, mourn his friend Dick Cheney and endorse Zohran Mamdani for Mayor. But Bill Kristol was for a long time more famous as the main founder and editor of the Weekly Standard. I am taking a version of Justin Vaïsse's rubric, his three ages, in the structure of my book. I treat them all a little differently, but my first section of six is basically his first age. Then in my second section, I'm doing the women of that era, because Vaïsse has very little to say about them. Third section is basically his second age, and the fourth section is basically his third age. Then I do a section that's about the liberals, basically, the fellow travelers, people at the New Republic, people who might be at the Atlantic now. I think some of these people will come up in what Andrea has to tell us, too, when we get to the far center. And my sixth section, tentatively called The Successors, centers on Bari Weiss, who Mark Krotov, who introduced us, and I both went to Columbia with 20-some years ago. But not only Bari Weiss. I'm very interested in making the case that Bari is the latest iteration of this neoconservative story to the extent that it still coheres.
And I should say it's never totally coherent. many of the people who have been described as neoconservatives over the years, have been skeptical of the term. For instance, Daniel Bell and Daniel Patrick Moynihan, who were both identified by Peter Steinfels as, along with Irving Kristol, like the two most important neoconservative intellectuals in the 70s, he didn't think much of Norman Podhoretz. Those two guys were always Democrats, and they always insisted they hated the term neoconservative. Daniel Bell, whenever he would hear the term and hear it defined at the time, he would say, that's just Irving.
Matthew Sitman
David,
David Klion
a great question.
Matthew Sitman
Line of Irving Kristol when he was asked to define neoconservatism was these are just the normal opinions like of an average American adult He described this he said this was normalcy. Yeah His particular...
David Klion
I take the view that neoconservatism is less properly defined as a dogma or doctrine or a simple proposition like, let's go invade Middle Eastern countries and convert them to democracy. It has encompassed a bunch of doctrines, including that one, but is better understood as a series of relationships and networks and generations. And so if you'll indulge me just a minute, I want to go into the mode of... Charlie from It's Always Sunny with the corkboard. You've probably seen this meme before. And map out a bit why Bari Weiss is a neocon or where she's coming from that I think makes it correct to situate her in the neocon story. So Bari Weiss, born March 1984, same as me, in Pittsburgh, in a family where she grew up reading Commentary magazine. Her father, who was a former McGovernite who moved right largely over Israel, I think, very strong Commentary. She went to her first Soviet Jewry rally when she was three years old in 1987. She took nine or ten trips to Israel before college. And when she gets to college, she got involved, I think her sophomore year, in a movement to sort of de-platform Middle East studies professors there, especially a Palestinian professor named Joseph Massad. And she was doing this with her older boyfriend named Ariel Beery.
Now, that campaign actually started a little bit before Bari got to campus. And one person who was involved off campus was Daniel Pipes, who founded an organization, I believe in 2002, called Campus Watch, which was basically about this sort of McCarthyist hounding of Mideast studies professors on elite campuses. And he was coordinating with them and promoting their work to a certain extent. Daniel Pipes, of course, is the son of the neoconservative Soviet scholar Richard Pipes, who was involved in the famous Team B exercise, which I won't get into, but involved Paul Wolfowitz in the 70s. Daniel Pipes went to college at Harvard with Elliot Abrams and Douglas Feith and was friends with both of them, wrote for Commentary and the Weekly Standard. After, Bari gets her initial attention for this, including in an interview with the New York Sun, a neoconservative publication founded by a guy named Seth Lipsky, which a couple of years later gave Bari her first job in journalism. And the person who interviewed her there, a guy named Jacob Gershman, is the son of Carl Gershman, a neocon who founded the National Endowment for Democracy. Bari, after this campaign, goes to Israel and interns for the Shalem Center and for its in-house journal, Azure. The Shalem Center and Azure were founded by Yoram Hazony, who Jewish Currents has done some excellent coverage of recently, and who is the developer of the National Conservative Movement, but comes out of neoconservatism.
The money for the magazine he started at Princeton in the mid-80s, the Princeton Tory, came through Irving Kristol. And Irving Kristol was a mentor to him, as was, I believe, his wife. The Shalem Center was funded by Tikvah, which also funded Commentary, Marty Peretz's New Republic at the time, would later go on to fund Tablet, an online Jewish magazine that's gone far right and that was formative in Bari's career. And I'm sorry, I'm almost done.
Sam Adler-Bell
I hope you guys are all taking notes.
David Klion
Tikvah is now run by Elliot Abrams, one of the most prominent Scoop Jacksons and neocons, and gives money to every right-wing Jewish interest you've ever heard of, basically, including the think tank, the Kohelet Policy Forum that supports Benjamin Netanyahu's judicial reform in Israel. And Bari came back to Columbia and started a magazine there with money from the Tikvah Fund funneled through the Shalem Center, after which, upon graduation, pretty soon she ends up with the Wall Street Journal working for Bret Stephens, along with the second editor of the magazine she started at Columbia, Douglas Feith's son, David Feith, who goes on to work in the Trump State Department. That's just getting started. I hope I've convinced you that she belongs in a lineage that goes back all the way, in a sense, to City College.
Sam Adler-Bell
He really could do this all day. That was really unbelievably impressive. I mean, that's one word for it. Deranged, obsessive, but that does give us a sense of this network and this family romance, this conspiracy of sorts that the neoconservatives are in some respects.
Defining the far center
Sam Adler-Bell
I do want to bring Andrea in here because the book that you're writing, you name something called The Far Center. And one of the things I want to, you want to do on this panel is try to figure out if the far center in your judgment and in your definition are more or less just the latest generation of neoconservatives, whether they call themselves that or not. And I want to read Andrea's definition of the far center from a piece you wrote for New York Magazine, also because I just get to read Andrea Long Chu prose to her, which is fun. This is how you define the far center. A loose coalition of disillusioned Democrats, principled humanists, staid centrists, anti-woke journalists, civil libertarians, wronged entertainers, skeptical academics, and toothless novelists, all brought together by their shared antipathy to what they regard as the illiberal left. The far center is for free. speech and bourgeois institutions. It is against cancel culture, student protests, and radicalism of any kind. Yet it rejects the idea of a shared ideology or politics. Instead, its members see themselves as independently sane individuals, concerned citizens who wish only to defend civil society from the unbearable encroachments of politics. So the far center is liberal in that its highest value is freedom, but is also reactionary in that its vision of freedom lacks any corresponding vision. of justice.
Can you, Andrea, tell us a little bit more about who these people are? Name names, something they love to do, the neocons too. And then maybe we can try to figure out together whether these people are simply the latest manifestation of neoconservatism or something else.
Andrea Long Chu
Absolutely. I also want to say thank you all for being here. It's also very moving for me. I've never been a guest on this podcast. So let's see. Let's name some names up top. just to sort of paint a picture. And then actually, I have a revision to that definition that I think will hopefully be clarifying. So the term is meant to be heuristic. Far center, I think, might evoke something in the hearts of some people here without having to be defined. It is a coalition. It is not fully ideologically unified. But first of all, we're talking about an intellectual movement, not a political movement. It describes itself sometimes in political terms. It is an elite-facing movement of elites, which is not in and of itself a bad thing. That's sort of also what a magazine is, right? So I'm not saying that that per se is bad, but it will pretend not to be that, right? There are genuinely rank-and-file members of the Tea Party. There is no rank-and-file of the far center. It has people who like it, but they are fans, not participants. The participants are all... People who went to, for the most part, elite colleges, they occupy positions in academia, at legacy media, all across the hinterlands of Substack.
They have podcasts, they work at nonprofits, some of them are business entrepreneur people, but they are fundamentally, they are elites who don't like the way that they perceive other liberal elites are behaving, and they would like them to behave differently. Again, thus far, Probably still applies to us. Just saying. It's important to understand what it actually is. So, very often they have a signature issue that pulled them to the right. That might be free speech stuff on campus. That might be trans kids. That might be Palestine. It might be a bad review that they got. It's a reactionary position. Psychologically, you can get there a whole lot of ways. It only takes one thing. I know this, right, because I spent a certain amount of time getting encouraged by Red Scare fans to go on Red Scare. And it's because they saw, oh, she's a trans person who, like, doesn't think what other trans people think. They thought I was like the Thomas Chatterton Williams of trans people.
So you have the sort of identity heretics, right? Thomas Chatterton Williams, John McWhorter. Glenn Loury, Tyler Austin Harper, I would throw Jay Caspian Kang in there. You have your sort of like more traditional kind of pundits like David Brooks, Jonathan Chait. I would say Ross Douthat is now in there. I used to think of him as being sort of smart enough not to be involved, but now he's at 60 Minutes and he's writing for The Free Press and stuff. Then you've got, you have like the sort of anti-trans wing. You have Helen Lewis, you have Abigail Shrier, you have Jesse Singal. I could continue these, but I think one of the things, and this is to the correction, right? I said there are liberals and so their highest value is freedom. That, I think, is a bad definition of what a liberal is. There is a very good book by Helena Rosenblatt called you The Lost History of Liberalism. She is a liberal. She's like generally down for all of this, but she points out liberal doesn't mean having to do with freedom. Liberal means having to do with a person who is free and a person who is free in the Roman Republic, which is to say not a slave, not a woman, not a barbarian.
A person who is free has certain obligations to behave in a freedman-like way, in a gentlemanly way. They need to be generous. They need to be giving, they need to have a kind of mutual respect. So I would say the fundamental phenomenon that we're encountering with the far center, and which I think is present in the your accounts here. I think this gets ...to our whole question is an understanding that a certain kind of personality is necessary in order for liberalism to work. Liberalism assumes that we all already will behave like free people. The fact that we do not behave that way because we are not free or because we're misusing our freedom becomes a big problem that liberalism by itself does not have a good strategy for dealing with, right? We hold these truths to be self-evident. is polemical. They're saying, fuck you, we think these things should be built in. But it also is saying, we don't really have a plan for if these things aren't true, right? So I would say the far center is, it's not about freedom. It is about trying to replace politics with a certain kind of personality. And I think that that doesn't get you there all the way.
There are genuinely are liberals who believe that, who believe that we need a liberal personality, but Thank you. don't believe the next bit, which is, and we should take any steps necessary to make sure that everyone has that personality. That is fundamentally the thing that makes the far center the far center. And it's what brings together people that I would say, some of whom are very clearly coming out of that neocon tradition, some of whom are like bewildered liberals. who do not know why everyone has been yelling at them online about how they should just like listen to doctors more. But what brings them together is a sense that we need immediate, vigorous, institutional, and in some ways fundamentally illiberal change, that is seizing institutions, making them say the things we need to say, forcing kids not to transition, forcing people to detransition. We need these things in order to produce as kind of seed capital for a world where we're all nice liberals, we all have the right personality, and so liberalism can function the way it was supposed to. So I would say it's a virtue politics, or it's a dream of replacing politics with some sort of moral practice.
Sam Adler-Bell
Yeah, that's extremely helpful.
What neocons and the far center share
Sam Adler-Bell
The thing that struck me in preparing for this episode and reading Peter Peter Steinfels book and the things that we've all written about the neoconservatives and that Andrea has written about the far center is actually there are, I'm going to suggest, that there are a bunch of impulses, political and psychological, methodological, that unites the far center and this neoconservative multi-generational story that Matt and Dave just put out there. And I'm going to lay them out, and we can pick up any of the ones you want to talk about and problematize or agree with or whatever. And here's some of the things that struck me. Neocons and the Far Center. They're scandalized by the excesses of youthful radicalism, especially directed against Israel and in support of racial justice. In a sense, the neocons had 1968 as the pinnacle of the insane radicalism of the youth, the radicalism of the black power movement and the Zionism of certain anti-colonial movements that were rising up at that time. The far-centrists had 2020 when they looked out in the world and they saw. Young people have gone crazy and they also now have the post-October 7th Palestinian Solidarity Movement. They share a deep investment in Americanism. They're attracted to social scientific arguments.
They have a deep concern about feminization of the culture, infertility, figurative and literal, and impotency. Back then in the 70s, the neoconservatives were concerned about feminism and gay rights and now they're concerned about transgender people. There's an anxiety in both these traditions about... elite overproduction and influence. There's phrases from the neoconservatives like new class, Irving Kristol, but today we hear about PMC, professional managerial class radicals, and these terms index their fear that highly educated knowledge workers will become alienated from the American mainstream and embrace political radicalism. They are comfortable, as Andrea really just pointed out about the far center, with entertaining authoritarian means for preserving what they conceive of as the liberal order. I think you can see the far center's attitude towards Trump as comparable in a way to the original neocons attitude toward McCarthy and his successors. It might be necessary to have a big, strong guy run certain people out of the community on a rail in order to preserve liberalism. And they have a tendency, I think both groups, to explain political movements and developments in terms of status anxiety, which is a term for Richard Hofstadter especially, as opposed to class or economic interests. which results in a tendency to pathologize their opponents as opposed to seeing them as groups with their own political interests, economic interests, class interests.
And I think as Andrea said, You're really pointed out there's an anti-political tendency in these groups. Daniel Bell, of course, wrote The End of Ideology. And today you have the far-centrist, you know, Bari Weiss, basically wants to just lop off the ideological left and the ideological right sides of the political spectrum and that somewhere in the middle where there are reasonable people who can have reasonable conversations is where politics should take place. What do you guys think?
David Klion
All of those are correct. All of those are grounded. I'd love to elaborate on all of them. But to pick one, your reference to the McCarthy-Trump analogy is very interesting. That, I assume, is referring back to in 1952, before anyone was calling anyone a neoconservative, when Irving Kristol writes an article, I believe in Partisan Review, it might have been a Commentary, in which he talks about McCarthy at kind of the peak of the Red Scare. And he writes, I'm paraphrasing gently here, but What the average American knows about Senator McCarthy is that he's against communism. And about the average liberal, they know no such thing. And so he was taking a very precise stance here. He was not saying, I like McCarthy. None of the New York intellectuals did because he was a bore and an anti-Semite and, you know, just an unpleasant demagogic man. And these were sophisticated Jewish New Yorkers. But he was saying. you know, that he keeps the left in line. So I think that that is a very good salient point. And we can see now that, you know, a lot of the people who are traditionally thought of as neocons, notably Bill Kristol, have ended up in this actually pretty serious Never Trump posture. But others who were in that posture, and I would count Bari Weiss among them, in 2016 have ended up somewhere closer to that original Irving Bill Kristol impulse, where... They're more anti-anti-Trump.
You know, they maintain some pretense of not being for Trump, and sometimes they criticize him on certain grounds, but mostly they criticize the left for being scandalized by him. I'd say that's largely been the posture of Commentary Magazine for the last 10 years, for instance. One other thread I did want to pick up that's also related to something Andrea said, there are some episodes with the early neocons that I think almost work as, like, proto-cancellation. And another fun kind of parallel to draw. And the two that immediately come to mind, one that we discussed on our earlier Know Your Enemy episode, was the publication of Norman Podhoretz's book, Making It, in 1967. Norman was still considered a liberal, maybe even a left liberal, in good standing at that time. And he writes this memoir, which is basically about how great he is, and about how he's shamelessly covetous for status and money and influence. tea. You know, kind of makes fun of all his friends in the New York intellectuals.
Sam Adler-Bell
Crucially, he suggests that so are all the rest of them.
David Klion
Right. You just won't admit it. You have this pretense. And Lionel Trilling begs him not to publish it. Daniel Bell begs him not to publish it. Everyone begs him not to publish it. His editor forfeits the advance. He finds a new editor. He does publish it. He gets reamed out for it in the New York Review of Books, in Partisan Review, everywhere. And he's basically chased and laughed off the scene. So he gets cancelled in a sense. And like everyone he's canceled, usually, he's not really canceled at all. He remains the editor of Commentary. He remains very comfortable. He just is humiliated. And by 1970, he is an avowed conservative and has decided he's going to spend the rest of his career pissing off everyone who's mean to him. And the other example that comes up, which is a little more serious, is Daniel Patrick Moynihan publishing, well, it was an internal memo in the Nixon administration, but it got leaked, possibly by Moynihan himself. about the Negro family, essentially arguing that the reason for gaps in wealth and living standards and so on were explained not by racism, but by the lack of father figures in the Black family. And the New Left just tore them apart for this. And a few months later, Irving Kristol and Daniel Bell launched The Public Interest, which Moynihan is writing from, from the beginning. So I do think this is actually a running theme of like, the Left was mean to me, or liberal critics were mean to me, and I'm going to you know, make that my entire personality now.
Matthew Sitman
Well, no, I'm going to hop in here and Sam, your list of kind of tendencies that neocons and the far center kind of overlap, tendencies that go together. And sometimes it might be interesting to think about why they're pieced together.
Midge Decter’s letter and Fire Island
Matthew Sitman
Since it was mentioned that I have, I own this insanely homophobic letter from Midge Decter to a lawyer named Howard Meyer that she sent on April 15th, 1987. I want to read from this letter sheep growth. This letter was occasioned by this lawyer, Howard Meyer, writing to Midge Decter. I think he might have sent her a piece. But it was a response to an essay that Midge Decter wrote in 1980 for Commentary titled, The Boys on the Beach. And this was Midge Decter going to Fire Island. Believe it or not, not undercover, but walking around observing and writing this kind of shocked and at times, you know, appalled, offended at what she saw there piece for Commentary. And Howard Meyer wrote to her and listed all the ways this was homophobic. And so I'm going to read from her letter that she sent to him in reply. She starts with the boys on the beach is not homophobic. Capital N, capital O, capital T. So. Don't let anyone say she was mad about that. But it goes on and gets quite dark. She writes, the spiritual radicalism enjoined by gay rights, remember this was published in 1980, is a murderous condition. It seemed and still seems to me that black power, women's lib, and gay rights would all bring greater suffering to their supposed constituents.
The point, she went on to argue, was not to caricature homosexuals, but to say that the demand that they consider themselves normal would merely lead them to excesses of self-destruction. You may hate that point, she says, or argue with it, or flatly deny it, but that's what I was saying, that coming out of the closet would not make homosexuals love themselves more. That That cannot be achieved for any of us by fiat, but hate themselves more. You may see pride, for example, in the gay pride parade. I do not. That letter is remarkable in and of itself, but here's the thing. thing I want to note in this context, that letter was sent on letterhead from the Committee for the Free World. Now, how do those two things go together? Why is someone on the masthead of the Committee for the Free World so deeply kind of homophobic, but so exercised by that writing about it, right? We now associate neoconservatism so much with foreign policy. It's so interesting to go back to its origins, so much it was social scientific critique of, say, Great Society program. But then by this kind of into the 70s and 80s, it really picks up cultural issues and weighs in on that Midge Decter Maybe as much as any of them.
So I kind of wanted to bring that in It's like this is part of what's going on here these merging of tendencies Kind of rhetorically. There's a lot going on here. Obviously the appeal to normalcy I thought was really telling and I'll close with this a response to this piece was written by Gore Vidal in the nation. And I forget what its original title was, but it was eventually, you know, republished under the title Pink Triangle and Yellow Star. And I thought that's so striking because it kind of says like, who are the yellow stars kind of aligning themselves with in our politics? Other outgroups? Or they've seen themselves more as kind of the guardian of middle-class normalcy, sobriety, and against black power, gay rights, women's lib, all kind of bottom-up movements seeking to unsettle that normalcy that they'd come to kind of value as, I think, you know, after World War II, Jews entered the mainstream, culturally, institutionally, and otherwise. Do you guys have any thoughts about normalcy?
David Klion
I have a feeling Andrea will have better thoughts on normalcy, but I do want to offer one brief factual correction to Matt, which is, Midge did not actually go to Fire Island, like, on assignment to check it out. The Podhoretz family had been vacationing there for years, Midge was getting upset by all the open gays who were showing up on the beach and her specific grievance about them, which she mentions in the piece. They sold their house and moved to East Hampton in response to this, much as they moved from the Upper West Side to the Upper East Side in the late 70s. Her real objection was that the gays, by showing off their phalluses, she really does get into this, and doing all kinds of drugs and drinking and partying, were hard. hurting men like her husband, who are good, responsible. Giving them ideas.
They're making them realize what they've given up and staying in a kind of perpetual adolescence. And this cannot be glorified. And she said, and Gertrude Himmelfarb thought this too, told an interviewer once, you know, when we were in London in the 50s, when Irving Kristol was working for the CIA-funded Encounter magazine, they were friends with W.H. Auden. And Himmelfarb said in an interview, while after Auden was dead, that we all knew he was gay, but he would say, you know, he wasn't proud of it. He knew that was a shameful thing to be. It was like a private vice. I'm paraphrasing a little bit. And, you know, Decter too said, like, of course I have gay friends. I work in the world of little magazines and publishing, but it's one thing to be gay. It's another thing to go around saying you're proud of it and glorifying the lifestyle.
Gay respectability, nature and the family
David Klion
So I think it was the overt gay pride of Fire Island that scared her whole family off the beach.
Andrea Long Chu
You know, it's interesting because the bit about coming out isn't going to make you like yourself anymore. I don't know. That sounds true to me. And, and. Well, and it's not irrelevant, right? Because, one, Bari is gay, right? This is like a thing that we have to think about. She dated Kate McKinnon at Columbia. And she has two kids with her wife Nellie, who is also, who writes like a comedy column for The Free Press. So obviously something has shifted there, right? Like gay rights, some version of gay rights. So like Andrew Sullivan, maybe a version, normalcy, kind of respectability, whatever. has been like absorbed, you know, Andrew Sullivan, another kind of Never Trumper. He's actually very woke on Israel now that he sort of has broken there, but generally a far center person, I would say.
Matthew Sitman
Interestingly, his first book was titled what? Virtually Normal.
Andrea Long Chu
Virtually Normal, right. But I think there's an understanding to a certain point, and so Bari can have her wife and still have dinner with Trump, and They can hate trans people together. So some of that is, I guess we could say, cynical, right? That is just sort of like gay people are no longer the suitable scapegoat or something like that. But I think more deeply, there is a question of nature. Like the idea that it was not a choice, right, which is a huge part of a certain kind of mainstream gay activism. in the 90s and around marriage and all of that, was genuinely very effective. And there was like good reasons that like there were people on the left embracing this narrative as a tactical thing. I don't think it was like idiotic, but the idea that it was a natural thing, that maybe it could be explained genetically, or that at least it just must have to do with the way that you're wired, all the born this way stuff, right, is very Key because it means that you don't actually have to opt out of a more broader ideology that there are certain natural laws that govern the way that human beings are.
Namely, there are sexes. They are different from each other. They behave in different ways, in ways that biology makes them behave. The family is designed to harness the best natural impulses and curb the worst ones. Richard Reeves of Boys and Men cites studies that say that men who are married to women and have kids and have stable home lives have lower testosterone levels, right? The family is hormone therapy for men. Not even a joke. He's not joking, right? It's not a joke. There's an idea that there are certain natural realities. So Bari and Nellie, bless them. When they're going to have their second kid, they do an episode of their podcast where they go and ask several Fox News contributors what it's going to be like to have a boy because they currently have a girl. And Nellie is like, well, you know, our little girl, you know, she just started wanting like purses and frilly things that I felt bad about. I was like, why do you need a purse? And then I was like, oh, I guess I have to just accept that like that's just like what it is to like have two X chromosomes. Like they can fit because they are part of a larger system of not just acknowledging biological difference.
I think there's plenty of radical trans thought that acknowledges biological difference, but that says, and therefore we have to like build society around those differences in a way that, again, accommodates them. Which is why I think the place where the far center is the most aligned, not just the most conservative, but the most aligned with like actual far right. is on birth, the pronatalism thing, is on trans kids, is on the dissolution of the family. Those are felt to be really, really fundamental parts of society that cannot be messed with and that reflect the fear of trans women in women's restrooms. It's not a fear of trans women. They're not worried about trans women. They're worried about men. They're like, men are, by nature, bigger, more violent, more likely to rape you, and so you shouldn't let them in women's restrooms. It reflects a general understanding that sex is a huge determining factor in the way that we structure society. So that kind of, I think, traditionalism is part of what makes them so available to some of these kind of right-wing alliances.
Sam Adler-Bell
Absolutely. I mean, and also, Midge Decter writing about homosexuality, about lesbianism in particular, and her book The New Chastity, really emphasizes this idea of heterosexual life as this violent thing. and which gay people, gay women in particular, are choosing to obviate themselves from in a way it's immature.
Matthew Sitman
I will say one of the funnier bits in Midge's Boys on the Beach was her noticing that lesbians had big like mastiffs with them all the time. And Gore Vidal very cheekily said, well, you know, if I was a lesbian on Fire Island and I saw two Podhoretzes waddling towards me with Leviticus in one hand, and Freud in the other. I'd want to protect a dog.
David Klion
I wanted to just add on to this. I do think, Andrew Sullivan, I do think you're absolutely right to situate as the pivotal figure in leading, I think, both the far center and also the center-left, I mean, just mainstream liberalism, to an accommodation with gay rights. I do think if you were going to name one intellectual who made them comfortable with it by basically saying, you know, gay people want to be normal, gay people want to have normal, bourgeois lives, which you know, for an awful lot of gay people, I think he was actually correct. And there was a lot of truth to that. And that's how you get Ted Olson, you know, arguing in front of the Supreme Court for this. You're also right that he's woke on Israel and has been for a while. On that point, though, I want to say, cycling back to the idea that all intellectual history is essentially the history of personal grudges. I think an awful lot of that comes out of the God. nasty fight that he had with Leon Wieseltier when they were both editors of the New Republic together. And when Andrew finally left the New Republic, having authored numerous catastrophes for the magazine, and tried to play it off as like, I'm leaving because I have HIV, and I need to take care of that. Leon gave some public statement where he was like, you know, I hope Andrew has a long and happy life, which he has so far. But you know, actually, you know, he said he breathed a sigh of relief when he left this magazine.
I think we all did. And they've been fighting about Israel ever since.
Matthew Sitman
Well, speaking of fighting about Israel, I want to give them one last question.
The politics of Jewish reaction
Matthew Sitman
I'm going to direct towards Sam before I think there'll be audience Q&A. But one of the terms we haven't really got to yet in the title is Jewish reaction, because neoconservatives, not all of them are Jewish. The far center, not all of them are Jewish. But nevertheless, the politics of Jewish reaction are in this title. And I wanted to just... Get your read on why that inclusion and what it might mean or what is the distinctive Jewish contribution to these movements we've been talking about.
Sam Adler-Bell
Yeah, I mean, I feel like the irony is that the people in this room who have come to this event and who have gone to the other panels today are probably the most aware of what that term means of anybody in the world. But what struck me as thinking about the neoconservatives again is that the fact that the older generations of Jewish neoconservatives, that they would see muscular American nationalism. as a boon to their interests, that they would see egalitarian liberalism as a threat to their privileges and conservative Christians eventually as their natural allies, is really an indication of how thoroughly Jews had been incorporated into the American mainstream and into whiteness and into the normative American power structure. They had total confidence in the sense that they would remain a natural and perhaps even exemplary part of the American story. And the one-time alliances they had. with the excluded or oppressed, with black people, with poor people, sexual minorities, the working class, those cease to feel natural or necessary.
Or normal. Yeah, exactly. And in a sense, it seems that a newfound security and confidence in the durability of the liberal promise is, ironically, a precondition for neoconservatism, even though they at the same time went around talking about how in danger the liberal promise was by the the people coming up from below. And I do think that I quote this all the time on the podcast, but the like the most psychologically acute, if sympathetic portrait of a neoconservative mind in this particular regard does come from Saul Bellow and in his novel, Mr. Sammler's Planet. Sammler, the main character, is a Holocaust survivor who lectures at Columbia, like a lot of neoconservatives, and laments what he sees as the growing decay and disorder of New York City, and this is the quote from the novel. Mr. Sammler was testy with white Protestant America for not keeping better order. Cowardly surrender, not a strong ruling class, eager in a secret way to come down and mingle with the minority mobs and scream against themselves.
David Klion
Yes, so incredible book. There's a better quote from it that I don't think we can say on stage. But if you read the first, I think, just chapter, you'll know what I'm talking about. Yeah, on the point of Jewish upward mobility after World War II, you know, this first generation, the reason they were going to City College was that the Ivies had quotas. City College was free, and it was at one point in the 30s, I think, 90% Jewish, and it was all male. So these were children of the Depression. Their parents were immigrants, mostly from the Pale of Settlement. And after World War II, you know, opportunities opened up. Daniel Bell became a tenured professor at Columbia Sociology, having never really done his PhD. He just got a bunch of essays he'd written for various magazines together and published it as the end of ideology, and that was his PhD. So this was a real golden age for Jewish men, and they really traveled a very long distance, hence the title of Norman's book, Making It, about his journey from Brownsville in Brooklyn to the Upper West Side. And it's very astute what you say, Sam, about the relationship to waspdom, which they're really just starting to contemplate up close for the first time. I mean, they saw the Ivys as wasp bastions, which they had been until five minutes earlier. And, for instance, a formative event for neoconservatism covered a lot in Commentary and everywhere else was the Ocean Hill Brownsville teacher strikes of 1968.
And without going into too much detail about them, the basic concept is that there was an experiment with community control in New York City public high schools and middle schools in this one neighborhood. And a group of black activists were given the administration of a public school in eastern Brooklyn in a neighborhood in Brownsville where Podhoretz had grown up that had been Jewish a generation earlier but was now mostly black. But the teachers were mostly Jewish. And they were unionized. And yada, yada, yada, things did not go well. There was a huge clash between the Jewish-dominated teacher union and a citywide strike that lasted something like six weeks. And in the aftermath of this, the community control experiment failed. world. But this was like a real rupture moment between Jews and Blacks in New York City that people still refer back to decades later. And Midge Decter, in an interview that she gave in the 80s, she's really gotten a lot of airtime tonight. Midge Decter said something really interesting. So the community control experiment was implemented by Mayor John Lindsay, who was a very progressive, civil rights-oriented Republican, like a blue blood from the Upper East Side. And it was done. with funding from the Ford Foundation, which of course was founded by the late Henry Ford and his son, Henry Ford at least being a notorious anti-Semite, which every Jew knows.
And Midge basically saw this as the anti-Semitic Ford Foundation and the WASP elites like Lindsay plotting against the hardworking Jewish teachers in alliance with the Black underclass, in pretty much exactly the way you're talking. So this is really a running theme. And you're absolutely right that the Jews who went neocon in the 60s and beyond were, in a sense, defending their well-assimilated turf against what they saw as America's old elites in alliance with America's underclass.
Matthew Sitman
How much time do we have before questions? One question? Maybe good. A lot of pressure on you.
The far center and the welfare state
David Klion
Yeah, you mentioned the neoconservative backlash to the excesses of the Great Society. And I wanted to ask how the far center relates to domestic policy, relates to the welfare state.
Andrea Long Chu
It's a good question. It is an ideology about culture, right? So first and foremost, the things that they are the most concerned with are moral, aesthetic, and have to do with cultural institutions, the arts, universities. So you don't find a lot of writing that is like directly about things like welfare, things like housing. These things get mentioned as, well, of course, I believe, right? You always have a disclaimer. Of course, I believe that everyone should have access to medical care. And of course, we believe that everyone should have it. You know, there's a lot of a lot of kind of lip service paid to sometimes they will say they're socialists, right? They'll say they're socialists about those things. but at the very least nice, liberal, social democratic, like robust social services and all of that. But I think this is connected to what Dave was talking about. The real sense is that the professional class has been poisoned by an influx of people who are not supposed to be there. Basically, those are Black people and trans people. and socialists, young people, sometimes it's just the fact that they are young, but it's a reaction to, you know, all the stuff at DEI, which they've also been extremely on board.
But, like, of course the terrible thing about the destruction of DEI is that we have to, like, go to bat for DEI now, right? You all know that's funny because DEI is this such, so obviously co-opting, you know, progressive discourse about identity, is or or if you're like a Catherine Liu or whoever, you think, well, this is what was so fucked up about identity politics in the first place. This is why we should have never abandoned class critique. But really, the fear is that there will be elites who do not identify with their role in society, that at least they're going to misbehave. And they're going to do that by seeing themselves as allied with working class voters, or with racial minorities, or sexual minorities, whatever. Even if those alliances are fake, or bloodless, or whatever, it is enough to be scary to this kind of intellectual. Because I think a very important thing about wokeness, fundamentally. You know, the woke left is like a really ambiguous term. Who is that actually referring to? That's referring to Donna in HR? She's part of the woke left?
Or is it the people in this room? Or is it, right, so it is a very flexible label. And part of that is that wokeness describes a, however flawed, coalition. It does represent a case in which The radical left and liberals were working together, and that is really fucking scary for these people. So the co-option, you know, all of the co-optation and that is part of trying to, you know, sap at that alliance. But I think fundamentally, the problem with wokeness is that it's such a big tent. It's suggested that, like... lots of people might come together and, for instance, elect Zohran Mamdani.
Matthew Sitman
Well, I think that's the perfect note to end on, actually. We do have to wrap, but thank you all so much. Thank you, Andrea, David. I was raised a demon with a moon that's so...