Who are the real heirs of neoconservatism? Taped live at Jewish Currents Live, this panel answers with one name: Bari Weiss, whom Sam calls “the core figure who ties this whole conversation together” , a neoconservative by lineage and, in his account, a prominent example of what Andrea Long Chu calls the far center. The idea that joins the two movements is Andrea’s: the far center, she says, “is not about freedom. It is about trying to replace politics with a certain kind of personality” , by illiberal means if need be. What it fears, she suggests at the close, is a coalition of liberals and the left big enough to “elect Zohran Mamdani” .

Key Topics

  • Matt starts in “Alcove No. 1 at City College in the 1930s” and follows Justin Vaïsse’s three ages: critics of the Great Society at The Public Interest , Scoop Jackson Democrats in the 1970s , and the National Greatness Conservatives of the Iraq War years .
  • Calling neoconservatism “a series of relationships and networks and generations” , David maps Weiss onto it: a first job at the neoconservative New York Sun , an internship at Yoram Hazony’s Shalem Center , and a Columbia magazine started, he says, with Tikvah Fund money .
  • Andrea revises her definition: the far center is “an elite-facing movement of elites” , and, after Helena Rosenblatt, “liberal” first named the free Roman’s duty to behave “in a gentlemanly way” .
  • Sam lists what the two movements share, from alarm at youthful radicalism, 1968 then and 2020 and the post-October 7 Palestine solidarity movement now , to comfort “with entertaining authoritarian means” .
  • David dates Sam’s McCarthy analogy to an article Irving Kristol wrote in 1952 , and finds “proto-cancellation” in Norman Podhoretz’s Making It and Daniel Patrick Moynihan’s report on the Black family .
  • Matt reads Midge Decter’s 1987 letter insisting that her Commentary essay “The Boys on the Beach” was “not homophobic” and recalls Gore Vidal’s reply ; David notes that the Podhoretzes had vacationed on Fire Island for years .
  • Andrea argues that “born this way” fitted gay respectability into a belief in natural sex differences which, in her account, aligns the far center with the far right on pronatalism and trans kids .
  • Sam argues that the neocons’ turn showed “how thoroughly Jews had been incorporated into the American mainstream” , and David recalls the 1968 Ocean Hill-Brownsville strikes as “a real rupture moment between Jews and Blacks” .

Notable Quotes

"This is kind of the backstory of Bari Weiss, zooming way out."
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 2:15
"It's a reactionary position. Psychologically, you can get there a whole lot of ways. It only takes one thing."
Andrea Long Chu, on the far centerasserted#
Andrea Long Chu, on the far center, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 22:49
"Mr. Sammler was testy with white Protestant America for not keeping better order."
Saul Bellow, read by Sam Adler-Bell, from Mr. Sammler's Planetreported#
Saul Bellow, read by Sam Adler-Bell, from Mr. Sammler's Planet, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 49:05

Outline

  • 0:00:01 — The live taping
  • 0:06:20 — Mark Krotov introduces the panel
  • 0:08:17 — Alcove One and the three ages of neoconservatism
  • 0:11:43 — Dynasties, networks and Bari Weiss
  • 0:19:14 — Defining the far center
  • 0:27:16 — What neocons and the far center share
  • 0:34:31 — Midge Decter’s letter and Fire Island
  • 0:39:49 — Gay respectability, nature and the family
  • 0:46:56 — The politics of Jewish reaction
  • 0:52:44 — The far center and the welfare state

Mentioned Resources

People

Organizations

  • Jewish Currents (left-wing American Jewish magazine)
  • n+1 (American literary magazine)
  • New York Magazine (the magazine where Andrea Long Chu is a critic)
  • City College of New York (free public college that educated the first generation of neoconservatives)
  • Columbia University (private university in New York City)
  • Commentary (the monthly that became a leading organ of neoconservatism)
  • The Public Interest (policy journal founded by Irving Kristol and Daniel Bell in 1965)
  • The Weekly Standard (neoconservative weekly founded in 1995)
  • Partisan Review (quarterly of the anti-Stalinist New York intellectuals)
  • Encounter (Anglo-American magazine Irving Kristol co-edited in London)
  • The New Republic (American magazine of politics and culture)
  • Tablet (online American Jewish magazine founded in 2009)
  • Tikvah Fund (New York foundation that funds Jewish and Zionist intellectual institutions)
  • Shalem Center (Jerusalem research institute founded by Yoram Hazony)
  • Committee for the Free World (anticommunist organization led by Midge Decter)

Places

  • Alcove One (corner of the City College cafeteria where the anti-Stalinist left gathered)
  • Fire Island (barrier island off Long Island known for its gay resort communities)
  • Brownsville (neighborhood in eastern Brooklyn)
  • New York City (center of American Jewish life)
  • Pale of Settlement (western provinces of the Russian Empire to which Jews were confined)
  • Israel (the state founded in 1948)
  • Palestine (the land the Zionist movement set out to settle)
  • Iraq (site of the war Matt ties to neoconservatism’s third age)

Works

Concepts

  • Neoconservatism (movement of former liberals and leftists who moved right from the 1960s on)
  • Far center (Andrea Long Chu’s term for a loose coalition of disillusioned liberals, centrists and heterodox writers)
  • Jewish reaction (the panel’s term for Jewish participation in conservative and reactionary movements)
  • Liberalism (the tradition of individual liberty and constitutional government)
  • Great Society (Lyndon Johnson’s 1960s domestic programs)
  • Cancel culture (public shaming and ostracism over offensive speech)
  • Never Trump (conservative opposition to Donald Trump)
  • Gay rights (the movement for the equal rights of gay people)
  • Wokeness (term, usually pejorative, for progressive identity politics)

Events

Closing

By reading one journalist’s career as the latest chapter of a family story that starts in a City College cafeteria, the panel argues that today’s far center replays an older reaction against new targets.


← Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History (w/ Benjamin Moser)