The Republican senator from Wisconsin who led the anticommunist purges of the early 1950s. In episode 03 he matters as an analogy: Sam compares the far center's attitude toward Donald Trump with the first neoconservatives' attitude toward McCarthy, and David grounds the comparison in Irving Kristol's 1952 article, which did not praise McCarthy but faulted liberals for being less clearly anticommunist than he was. Start at about 29 minutes.
Across the episodes
Enters as a historical mirror for the present, the demagogue whose usefulness against the left the first neocons weighed, held up to show the far center's bargain with Trump is an old one
Sam's analogy joins the two movements across seventy years: each makes its peace with a demagogue it does not admire.
One item in Sam's list of impulses the neocons and the far center share.
"I think you can see the far center's attitude towards Trump as comparable in a way to the original neocons attitude toward McCarthy and his successors."Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 29:19
Sam voicing the logic he attributes to both groups: illiberal means accepted for the sake of a liberal order, the same move Andrea had just described.
"It might be necessary to have a big, strong guy run certain people out of the community on a rail in order to preserve liberalism."Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 29:28
David takes up the analogy as the one item from Sam's list worth tracing back to a source.
"your reference to the McCarthy-Trump analogy is very interesting."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 30:32
Kristol's line places McCarthy as a standard liberals fail: the senator is credited with a clarity his critics lack.
David says he is paraphrasing Kristol's 1952 article gently.
"What the average American knows about Senator McCarthy is that he's against communism. And about the average liberal, they know no such thing."Irving Kristol, quoted by David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 30:56
The distance matters to the analogy: the stance was never affection for McCarthy, a man the New York intellectuals found coarse and hostile to Jews, but a calculation about him.
"None of the New York intellectuals did because he was a bore and an anti-Semite and, you know, just an unpleasant demagogic man. And these were sophisticated Jewish New Yorkers."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 31:09
The calculation in a phrase: McCarthy's value lay in whom he frightened, which is the role the panel suggests Trump plays for some of today's writers.
"But he was saying. you know, that he keeps the left in line."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 31:20
Connections
Sam likens the far center's view of Trump to the first neocons' view of McCarthy.
Kristol's 1952 article is David's origin for the analogy.
The New York intellectuals disliked McCarthy, but some saw use in him.
Sam's analogy: the strongman tolerated to preserve liberalism.