The term for public shaming and ostracism over offensive speech. In episode 03 it first appears in Andrea Long Chu's definition of the far center, which, as Sam reads it, is against cancel culture. David Klion then takes the idea back to the early neoconservatives and calls two of their formative episodes "proto-cancellation": the backlash to Norman Podhoretz's memoir Making It in 1967 and the New Left's attack on Daniel Patrick Moynihan's report on the Black family. In both, he argues, the criticism did little real damage but supplied a lasting grievance. Start at about 32 minutes.
Across the episodes
Enters as one of the far center's stated enemies and is then pushed back half a century, as the panel finds the same story of humiliation and grievance in the early neoconservatives
In Chu's definition, opposition to cancel culture is one of the far center's founding positions, listed with free speech and hostility to student protest.
"The far center is for free. speech and bourgeois institutions. It is against cancel culture, student protests, and radicalism of any kind."Andrea Long Chu, read by Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 19:59
David moves the phenomenon back half a century, so that the far center's complaint has a neoconservative ancestor.
"there are some episodes with the early neocons that I think almost work as, like, proto-cancellation."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 32:13
The first case: the literary world's response to Making It in 1967, in the magazines of the New York intellectuals.
"He gets reamed out for it in the New York Review of Books, in Partisan Review, everywhere. And he's basically chased and laughed off the scene."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 33:09
David's skeptical point about cancellation in general: humiliation without real loss, with Podhoretz still editing Commentary.
"So he gets cancelled in a sense. And like everyone he's canceled, usually, he's not really canceled at all."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 33:16
The second case: the reaction to Moynihan's report, which David presents as the more serious one, followed months later by The Public Interest.
"And the New Left just tore them apart for this."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 33:58
Connections
Chu's published definition sets the far center against cancel culture.
David's first case of proto-cancellation is the reaction to Podhoretz's memoir.
His second case is the New Left's attack on Moynihan's report.
David says Podhoretz was cancelled only in a sense, keeping his editorship.