Norman Podhoretz's 1967 memoir of his rise from Brooklyn to literary Manhattan. David Klion had discussed it on an early episode of the show, and in episode 03 he uses it twice: as the first of two episodes of "proto-cancellation" among the early neoconservatives, when Podhoretz published over his friends' objections and was savaged for it, and as an emblem of the generation's postwar ascent, the title naming a journey from Brownsville to the Upper West Side. Start at about 32 minutes, and at about 50 for the second use.
Across the episodes
Enters twice, first as an early case of proto-cancellation, a breach with the New York intellectuals, and then as the emblem of a generation's ascent, the title itself standing for Jewish upward mobility after the war
The book has history with the show: David's earlier appearance was about it, so its return here closes a loop.
"one of the first episodes of Know Your Enemy with Matt and Sam to talk all about Norman and his wonderful first memoir making it."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 11:55
The timing is the point: the memoir appeared while its author was still a man of the left, so its reception marks the start of his move right.
David's first example of episodes in early neocon history that work as proto-cancellation.
"was the publication of Norman Podhoretz's book, Making It, in 1967. Norman was still considered a liberal, maybe even a left liberal, in good standing at that time."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 32:28
The reception as a collective verdict by the little magazines that made up Podhoretz's own world.
"He gets reamed out for it in the New York Review of Books, in Partisan Review, everywhere. And he's basically chased and laughed off the scene."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 33:09
David's parallel to the present: the cancellation costs standing, not position; the author keeps his magazine and loses face.
"So he gets cancelled in a sense. And like everyone he's canceled, usually, he's not really canceled at all. He remains the editor of Commentary."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 33:16
The second reading of the title: a generational story of Jewish men admitted to institutions that had shut them out, told by one who made the trip.
David on Jewish upward mobility after World War II.
"So this was a real golden age for Jewish men, and they really traveled a very long distance, hence the title of Norman's book, Making It, about his journey from Brownsville in Brooklyn to the Upper West Side."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 50:09
Connections
His first memoir, published in 1967.
David's first case of neoconservative proto-cancellation.
Trilling begged Podhoretz not to publish it.
One of the venues where David says the book was savaged.
The memoir's arc runs from Brownsville to the Upper West Side.