organization

The New York literary and political quarterly that, from the late 1930s, was the main magazine of the anti-Stalinist New York intellectuals, the milieu that produced the first neoconservatives. In episode 03 David Klion mentions it twice: as the possible home of Irving Kristol's 1952 essay on Senator McCarthy, and as one of the venues that panned Norman Podhoretz's memoir Making It. The first mention is at about 30 minutes.

Across the episodes

03

Appears only in passing, as the house organ of the New York intellectuals, the world the first neoconservatives came from and the court that judged them when they broke ranks

The McCarthy essay is the episode's earliest instance of the stance it calls "anti-anti": criticizing the liberal critics of a demagogue rather than the demagogue. Kristol's piece, "Civil Liberties, 1952: A Study in Confusion", in fact ran in Commentary.

Answering Sam's comparison of the far center's attitude to Trump with the first neocons' attitude to McCarthy.

"when Irving Kristol writes an article, I believe in Partisan Review, it might have been a Commentary, in which he talks about McCarthy at kind of the peak of the Red Scare."
Davidhedgedqualifier: “I believe in Partisan Review, it might have been a Commentary”#
David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 30:42

The magazine here is the New York intellectuals' tribunal: Podhoretz's punishment for Making It came from his own milieu's journals, which is what David means by calling the episode a "proto-cancellation".

David recounting the reception of Norman Podhoretz's 1967 memoir.

"He gets reamed out for it in the New York Review of Books, in Partisan Review, everywhere."
Davidasserted#
David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 33:09

Connections

is remembered as the venue for an essay byIrving Kristol

David tentatively places Kristol's 1952 essay on McCarthy here, while allowing it may have been Commentary.

reviewed harshlyMaking It

One of the places David says Podhoretz's memoir was savaged on publication.