A corner of the City College cafeteria in New York where, in the 1930s, the anti-Stalinist left gathered, beside the communists' Alcove Two. In episode 03 it is where Matt starts the history of neoconservatism: the first generation of the movement, Irving Kristol, Daniel Bell and Nathan Glazer among them, came out of it, and David Klion uses it as the measure of temperament against which he sets Norman Podhoretz. Start at about 8 minutes, where Matt opens the panel there.
Across the episodes
Enters as the founding scene of the panel's genealogy, a cafeteria table whose anti-Stalinist regulars are followed from 1930s student politics to Washington and down to their present-day heirs
Matt's chosen origin for neoconservatism is a student hangout rather than a text or a doctrine, and the biblical joke casts the movement's later rise as a kind of exodus.
"And we will go back to the start, which in this case is not the book of Genesis, but Alcove No. 1 at City College in the 1930s. A different kind of promised land, you might say."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 8:32
The alcove is defined by a split on the left: its regulars were anti-Stalinist socialists, one table over from the communists, so the movement begins as a quarrel inside the left.
"And the intellectuals that came out of Alcove One, where the anti-Stalinists left, not the communists in Alcove Two."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 8:44
Steinfels's joke makes the alcove the low starting point of an upward-mobility story, measuring Kristol's career by the distance from the cafeteria to the White House.
"If Horatio Alger had written about intellectuals instead of newsboys. He would have wrote a book about Irving Kristol titled Irving, the Editor, or From Alcove One to the President's Dinner Table."Peter Steinfels, read by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 9:47
The alcove is offered as more than history: Matt promises the panel will trace its graduates' line into the present.
"the original generation, those who came out of Alcove One, they're still with us in many ways, as we'll show you."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 10:10
David treats the alcove as a temperament as well as a place, and the contrast with Podhoretz, who stood outside it, is one of the lines his forthcoming book follows.
"the interesting differences temperamentally between where Norman is coming from and where the Alcove One intellectuals, including most notably Irving Kristol, are coming from and how those have echoed down to the present."David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 12:11
Connections
Matt places the alcove in the City College cafeteria of the 1930s.
Steinfels's mock Horatio Alger title measures Kristol's career from the alcove to the President's table.
David's book sets Podhoretz, who went to Columbia, against the temperament of the Alcove One intellectuals.