person
also known as Steinfels

An American journalist and editor, long associated with Commonweal and later the New York Times, whose 1979 book The Neoconservatives was the first full study of the movement. Episode 03 leans on him from the start: Matt opens the panel with Steinfels's account of the first generation's formative disappointments and his Horatio Alger joke about Irving Kristol, David uses his ranking of the leading neoconservatives to show how unstable the label was, and Sam names the book as one source for his list of traits the neocons share with the far center. Start at about 9 minutes.

Across the episodes

03

Serves as the panel's shared foundation text, the critic whose early account of the movement sets the terms that Matt, David and Sam each build on and partly revise

Steinfels is introduced as common ground for the whole panel, a reading the hosts and both guests are assumed to share before they disagree about anything else.

"But Peter Steinfels, in a book I think all of us love, it was the first book written on the neoconservatives in 1979,"
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 8:52

Steinfels's origin story makes neoconservatism a movement of disappointed socialists, so its later politics are read as reaction against a lost faith rather than as a conservatism inherited.

"the formative experiences in their youth for the neocons, for the first generation of neocons, people like Irving Kristol, Daniel Bell, Nathan Glazer, was the rise of totalitarianism and the failures of socialism."
Peter Steinfels, quoted by Matthew Sitmanreported#
Peter Steinfels, quoted by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 9:01

The joke carries Steinfels's thesis in miniature: the movement's story is one of upward mobility and proximity to power, the arc the panel goes on to trace down to the present.

"If Horatio Alger had written about intellectuals instead of newsboys. He would have wrote a book about Irving Kristol titled Irving, the Editor, or From Alcove One to the President's Dinner Table."
Peter Steinfels, read by Matthew Sitmanreported#
Peter Steinfels, read by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 9:47

Steinfels's canon of the movement is not the one usually remembered: it centers social scientists and leaves out Podhoretz, whose magazine and family would come to stand for neoconservatism.

David illustrating his point that the neoconservative story was "never totally coherent".

"Daniel Bell and Daniel Patrick Moynihan, who were both identified by Peter Steinfels as, along with Irving Kristol, like the two most important neoconservative intellectuals in the 70s, he didn't think much of Norman Podhoretz."
Davidasserted#
David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 14:26

The figures Steinfels ranked at the top of the movement rejected membership in it, which supports David's view that neoconservatism is better described as a network than as a doctrine with adherents.

"Those two guys were always Democrats, and they always insisted they hated the term neoconservative."
Davidasserted#
David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 14:39

Steinfels becomes one half of Sam's comparison: his 1979 portrait of the neocons is the template Sam lays over the far center to see how much of it still fits.

Sam introducing his list of impulses shared by the neoconservatives and the far center.

"Peter Peter Steinfels book and the things that we've all written about the neoconservatives and that Andrea has written about the far center is actually there are,"
Sam Adler-Bellasserted#
Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 27:21

Connections

Matt cites it as the first book on the movement, from 1979.

Steinfels's Horatio Alger line about Kristol is the episode's first portrait of the godfather of neoconservatism.

identified as leading neoconservativesDaniel Bell

Steinfels ranked Bell and Moynihan with Kristol, though both rejected the label.

was skeptical ofNorman Podhoretz

David says Steinfels did not rate Podhoretz among the movement's major thinkers.