A letter of April 15, 1987, in which the neoconservative writer Midge Decter answered a lawyer, Howard Meyer, who had written to her objecting to her 1980 Commentary essay "The Boys on the Beach". Matt Sitman owns it, and in episode 03, the live taping, he reads from it: Decter denies the essay was homophobic and argues that gay pride would only deepen self-hatred. Matt uses the letterhead, the Committee for the Free World, to ask how neoconservatism's foreign-policy and cultural campaigns fit together. Start with episode 03 at about 34 minutes.
Across the episodes
Promised early and produced midway, it gives the panel a primary document through which the neoconservatives' turn to the culture war becomes visible
The letter is set up early as Matt's exhibit, when David first introduces Decter among the neoconservative wives.
"who Matt knows all about because he has this wonderful letter about her homophobia,"David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 12:34
Matt establishes the document's date, recipient and his own possession of it before reading.
"Since it was mentioned that I have, I own this insanely homophobic letter from Midge Decter to a lawyer named Howard Meyer that she sent on April 15th, 1987."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 34:30
The occasion: Meyer's objection to Decter's essay on Fire Island, seven years after its publication.
"But it was a response to an essay that Midge Decter wrote in 1980 for Commentary titled, The Boys on the Beach."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 34:50
The letter opens in flat denial, which Matt underlines by spelling out her emphasis.
"She starts with the boys on the beach is not homophobic. Capital N, capital O, capital T."Midge Decter, read by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 35:20
The letter's central charge, which Matt interrupts to place in time.
"She writes, the spiritual radicalism enjoined by gay rights, remember this was published in 1980, is a murderous condition."Midge Decter, read by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 35:33
Decter groups gay rights with the other liberation movements of the 1960s as harmful to the people they claimed to serve.
"It seemed and still seems to me that black power, women's lib, and gay rights would all bring greater suffering to their supposed constituents."Midge Decter, read by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 35:41
Her conclusion turns the language of pride against itself, the passage Andrea later says contains something true.
"but hate themselves more. You may see pride, for example, in the gay pride parade. I do not."Midge Decter, read by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 36:19
The letterhead ties Decter's anti-gay argument to her anticommunist organization, which is the point Matt wants to draw out.
"that letter was sent on letterhead from the Committee for the Free World."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 36:33
Matt turns the document into a question about how neoconservatism's foreign and cultural fronts came to be joined.
"Why is someone on the masthead of the Committee for the Free World so deeply kind of homophobic,"Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 36:41
Connections
Decter wrote the letter on April 15, 1987, in reply to criticism of her essay.
Meyer, a lawyer, had written to Decter listing the ways her essay was homophobic.
The letter defends Decter's 1980 Commentary essay on Fire Island.
Matt notes the letterhead to ask how her Cold War and anti-gay commitments fit together.
Matt owns the original and reads from it at the live taping.