A barrier island off Long Island, New York, known for its gay resort communities. In episode 03 it is the setting of Midge Decter's 1980 Commentary essay "The Boys on the Beach": Matt describes the essay as Decter's account of what she saw there, and David Klion corrects him, saying the Podhoretz family had summered on the island for years. The panel also recalls the essay's lesbians with their dogs and Gore Vidal's reply. Start at about 35 minutes, and continue at about 38 minutes.
Across the episodes
Enters as the setting of the movement's best-known attack on gay life, and the panel's correction of the story turns it from a place Decter visited to one she had long shared
Matt's version of the essay's origin, with Decter as an observer visiting the island, which David goes on to correct.
"And this was Midge Decter going to Fire Island. Believe it or not, not undercover, but walking around observing and writing this kind of shocked and at times, you know, appalled, offended at what she saw there piece for Commentary."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 34:57
The correction changes the essay's standing: Decter wrote as a longtime summer resident, not a visiting reporter.
"Midge did not actually go to Fire Island, like, on assignment to check it out. The Podhoretz family had been vacationing there for years,"David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 38:17
In David's reading the essay's real worry was what the island's openness would do to married straight men.
"Her real objection was that the gays, by showing off their phalluses, she really does get into this, and doing all kinds of drugs and drinking and partying, were hard. hurting men like her husband,"David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 38:42
A detail from the essay that Matt offers as comedy, and that sets up Vidal's retort.
"I will say one of the funnier bits in Midge's Boys on the Beach was her noticing that lesbians had big like mastiffs with them all the time."Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 45:07
Vidal turns the scene around, making the observers the threat on the beach, armed with scripture and psychoanalysis.
"if I was a lesbian on Fire Island and I saw two Podhoretzes waddling towards me with Leviticus in one hand, and Freud in the other. I'd want to protect a dog."Gore Vidal, quoted by Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 45:19
Connections
Decter's 1980 essay is about what she saw on Fire Island.
David corrects Matt: the Podhoretz family had vacationed there for years.
Vidal's reply pictures the Podhoretzes approaching a Fire Island lesbian.