Helena Rosenblatt's 2018 history of the word "liberal" and its meanings from ancient Rome to the twentieth century, which argues that it long meant a set of civic virtues, generosity among them, before it meant individual rights. In episode 03 Andrea Long Chu uses it to correct the definition of the far center that Sam had just read back to her: if being liberal means behaving as a free person should, then the far center is defined by a demand for a certain kind of personality. The passage starts at about 24 minutes.
Across the episodes
Arrives as the lever Andrea uses to revise her own definition of the far center, moving it from a politics of freedom to a politics of personality
Andrea sets up the book by retracting a line of her own published definition, so the revision that follows comes as self-correction rather than rebuttal.
Andrea responding to Sam's reading of her New York Magazine definition of the far center.
"I said there are liberals and so their highest value is freedom. That, I think, is a bad definition of what a liberal is."Andrea, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 24:02
Andrea establishes the source's standing first: a friendly historian of liberalism, so the critique that follows cannot be dismissed as hostile.
"There is a very good book by Helena Rosenblatt called you The Lost History of Liberalism. She is a liberal. She's like generally down for all of this,"Andrea, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 24:12
The book's etymology carries the argument: liberalism began as the status ethic of a privileged class, and its exclusions were built into the word.
"but she points out liberal doesn't mean having to do with freedom. Liberal means having to do with a person who is free and a person who is free in the Roman Republic, which is to say not a slave, not a woman, not a barbarian."Helena Rosenblatt, quoted by Andrea, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 24:21
This is the bridge to Andrea's thesis: if liberalism rests on conduct, then a movement anxious about liberalism will turn to policing personality, which is how she goes on to define the far center.
"A person who is free has certain obligations to behave in a freedman-like way, in a gentlemanly way."Helena Rosenblatt, quoted by Andrea, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 24:36
Connections
Andrea credits Rosenblatt, whom she calls a liberal herself.
Andrea draws from the book a definition of liberal as a free person's obligations rather than a love of freedom.
The book's history lets Andrea revise her own definition of the far center.