work

Andrew Sullivan's 1995 book Virtually Normal: An Argument About Homosexuality, which made the case for gay marriage and military service on conservative and liberal grounds. In episode 03 Matt brings up its title while Andrea discusses how a version of gay respectability has been absorbed by the far center, and David then credits Sullivan with bringing mainstream liberalism to an accommodation with gay rights. The passage starts at about 40 minutes.

Across the episodes

03

Surfaces as a title that sums up an argument, the respectability case for gay equality the panel sees as both a real victory and a path into the far center

Andrea's point sets up the title: a respectable, normalizing version of gay rights is the one the far center has taken in, and Sullivan is its model.

Andrea discussing how gay identity fits within the far center.

"So like Andrew Sullivan, maybe a version, normalcy, kind of respectability, whatever. has been like absorbed,"
Andreahedgedqualifier: “maybe a version”#
Andrea, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 40:24

Matt lets the title make the argument: Sullivan's case for equality was framed from the start as a claim to normalcy, the same value Decter accused gay men of threatening.

"Interestingly, his first book was titled what? Virtually Normal."
Matthew Sitmanasserted#
Matthew Sitman, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 40:43

David grants the book's thesis a real measure of truth, which makes Sullivan's influence harder to dismiss: the respectability argument helped win gay rights and also prepared a place for them in the far center.

David calling Sullivan the pivotal figure in liberalism's accommodation with gay rights.

"gay people want to be normal, gay people want to have normal, bourgeois lives, which you know, for an awful lot of gay people, I think he was actually correct."
Davidasserted#
David, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 3 (16 Nov 2026), 45:49

Connections

written byAndrew Sullivan

Matt notes it was Sullivan's first book.

argued for an accommodation withGay rights

David credits Sullivan with making mainstream liberalism comfortable with gay rights through the case the book made.