concept

Yiddish for "here-ness": the Bund's principle that Jews should fight for a better life in the lands where they already lived, alongside their neighbors, rather than leave for a homeland elsewhere. In episode 01 it is the positive idea set against Zionism. Sam Adler-Bell introduces it as a term every leftist Jewish listener knows, Molly Crabapple defines it and compares it to the Palestinian idea of sumud, and late in the episode Sam voices the Zionist argument that the Holocaust disproved it. Start at about 22 minutes; the challenge comes at about 74.

Across the episodes

01

Enters as the Bund's signature idea, is defined against Zionist exodus and beside the Palestinian sumud, and is then put on trial by the Holocaust in the episode's closing argument

Sam introduces the word as the Bund's best-known legacy, a term still current among left-wing Jews even where its history isn't.

"like the term doikayt, which is Yiddish for here-ness, which is associated with the Bund."
Sam Adler-Bellasserted#
Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 22:09

The concept's present life is as a badge among Jewish leftists, which Sam contrasts with how little it is known beyond them.

"I feel like every leftist Jewish listener to this show knows that term."
Sam Adler-Bellhedgedqualifier: “I feel like”#
Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 22:13

Crabapple's definition makes the idea a demand rather than a plea for tolerance: Jews' place in Eastern Europe was to be claimed and improved, not endured.

Answering Sam's question about the Bund's positive idea of what it meant to be a Jew in the Russian Empire.

"but to flourish and have beautiful, dignified lives in the lands where they already lived, which was Eastern Europe for the majority of Jews in the world,"
Mollyasserted#
Molly, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 22:55

The core is a claim of belonging held against neighbors who denied it, the direct counter to the nationalist view, shared by Zionism, of Jews as foreigners.

"And they called this here-ness. It was a commitment that this land that they lived on, no matter how brutal it was, no matter how much their neighbors tried to evict them, was theirs as well."
Mollyasserted#
Molly, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 23:14

Crabapple links the Bundist idea to the Palestinian ethic of staying on the land while disclaiming any line of descent between them.

"And it reminds me almost of this precursor concept to the idea of sumud, an unintentional precursor. I would never say sumud came from it,"
Mollyhedgedqualifier: “I would never say sumud came from it”#
Molly, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 23:30

Sam's formula sets the idea against Zionism's story of redemption by departure.

Following his reading of Meyer London's speech about Jewish youth in Russian Poland praying to free Egypt rather than leave it.

"Revolution without exodus is what here-ness comes down to,"
Sam Adler-Bellasserted#
Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 24:55

The strongest objection to the concept, the Zionist reading of the Holocaust as its refutation, which Crabapple goes on to answer point by point.

Sam explicitly steelmanning the Zionist critics of the book.

"And those of you who stayed out of this naive hope for solidarity across difference and a belief in here-ness instead of exodus, you were wrong. You died."
Sam Adler-Bellcontested#
Sam Adler-Bell, Know Your Enemy on the Jewish Left and Right, Episode 1 (10 Apr 2026), 1:16:18

Connections

Sam introduces the term as the idea associated with the Bund.

set againstZionism

Sam's formula, revolution without exodus, opposes it to Zionist departure.

echoed inMeyer London

London's line about freeing Egypt rather than leaving it prompts Sam's formula.

tested byThe Holocaust

Sam voices the Zionist claim that the Holocaust refuted it.